MLB 10 News Post

MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1

09:24 PM - April 6, 2010 by RidinDwnKingsley

OK guys, here it is.

Any suggestions, fixes or edits should be posted here. If you have any questions on how to get the rosters working, make sure you check this thread first.

Sportsconnect

Title: OSFullMinors2010V.1

Manual Download Here

All real players
Faces for the entire NL East and top 5-10 prospects for each team
Opening day lineups/rotations
Every player on a MLB roster is included
AAA lineups/rotations best as possible
Great for franchise play

Thanks to Knight for letting me join the cause and to Ksig for his excellent scouting and potential matches. I'm sure Knight will be around to provide input on V.2.

Game: MLB '10: The ShowReader Score: 9/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3Votes for game: 66 - View All

MLB '10: The Show Videos

Member Comments

# 1101 Fedexpress @ 05/07/10 02:57 AM

Some players not from V1 who might be interesting additions

Two top NDFA from the last summer - Guillermo Pimentel (CF - SEA) or Cheslor Cuthbert (3B - KC). There is also Wagner Mateo (OF) who just signed with AZ but I already mentioned him in a previous post.

Luis Jimenez is a 3B prospect in Angels org. Missed all of 09 with shoulder issues but is in Midwest League this year - supposed to have good upside Offense and Defense.

Jonathan Garcia (CF) was drafted last year out of Puerto Rico by Dodgers. Good stats in Arizona Rookie League and is considered the best defender from Dodgers draft last year.

If you wanted to add the position player equiv. of Yu Darvish - there is always Cuban Yulieski Gourriel who some consider the best position player not currently playing in the states.

# 1102 franch1se @ 05/07/10 03:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fedexpress


	Some players not from V1 who might be interesting additions Two top NDFA from the last summer - Guillermo Pimentel (CF - SEA) or Cheslor Cuthbert (3B - KC). There is also Wagner Mateo (OF) who just signed with AZ but I already mentioned him in a previous post. Luis Jimenez is a 3B prospect in Angels org. Missed all of 09 with shoulder issues but is in Midwest League this year - supposed to have good upside Offense and Defense. Jonathan Garcia (CF) was drafted last year out of Puerto Rico by Dodgers. Good stats in Arizona Rookie League and is considered the best defender from Dodgers draft last year. If you wanted to add the position player equiv. of Yu Darvish - there is always Cuban Yulieski Gourriel who some consider the best position player not currently playing in the states.

Another guy to add in the Padre organization is P Juan Oramas. Check out that kids strikeout numbers! Him and Alexis Lara are someone I would like to see added.

# 1103 gkasper @ 05/07/10 07:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Knight165


	Nearly 2/3 finished. 1 more A.L. team to do and then the NL Central and NL West. Short night tomorrow...and I've got work Saturday(all day/all night)...so Sunday night will be my next update. Okay...I've got one A potential player to use.(position player) Who either needs a bump up(from B) or (I prefer) needs to be created that isn't on v1? Thanks. M.K. Knight165

Wilson Ramos is Baseball America's #58 prospect. He is only a B rating in the v. 1 rosters. He got 7 hits in his first two games but has only gotten one hit in the last 3... now batting a measly .400 Most likely he will be sent to triple A for the year to work on hitting breaking balls.

I think he definitely deserves an A rating... yes I am biased...

but do you see a lot of great catchers out there? Due to the presence of Joe Mauer and also Jose Morales, Ramos is trade bait and GMs are already salivating. The Twins won't just give him away.

# 1104 bigjdotcom01 @ 05/07/10 09:18 AM

Is there an ETA on V2 yet? Are we looking at another week or so?

# 1105 Vanman2425 @ 05/07/10 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gkasper


	Wilson Ramos is Baseball America's #58 prospect. He is only a B rating in the v. 1 rosters. He got 7 hits in his first two games but has only gotten one hit in the last 3... now batting a measly .400 Most likely he will be sent to triple A for the year to work on hitting breaking balls. I think he definitely deserves an A rating... yes I am biased... but do you see a lot of great catchers out there? Due to the presence of Joe Mauer and also Jose Morales, Ramos is trade bait and GMs are already salivating. The Twins won't just give him away.

Buster Posey, Jesus Montero, Wil Meyers, and Carlos Santana are all better prospects.

# 1106 bigjdotcom01 @ 05/07/10 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by b22gamer


	dude you dont ask ETA's!!!! just read knight's posts

Sorry, I was just hoping that V2 would be out before Memorial Day and was just wondering. Last year V2 with RazR's pitching edits was out by May 1st. I know that I could care less about faces and would rather have the latest rosters with the pitching edits.

That being said, these rosters are the best and well worth the wait. Great job Knight!

# 1107 bfindeisen @ 05/07/10 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigjdotcom01


	Sorry, I was just hoping that V2 would be out before Memorial Day and was just wondering. Last year V2 with RazR's pitching edits was out by May 1st. I know that I could care less about faces and would rather have the latest rosters with the pitching edits. That being said, these rosters are the best and well worth the wait. Great job Knight!

Ditto. Getting very excited to start the 2-Player franchise I play every year with my buddy. We wait for Knight's rosters to come out, with Razr's pitch edits, then we pick 2 franchise in the same division, do a fantasy draft, and compete against eachother. We play all games against each other (testing our playing abilities), then sim all the other games (testing our GM abilities). It's such a blast, and we usually make it through 4-5 seasons. We're itching to start, but refuse to do so without Knight and Razr's spectacular efforts!

# 1108 longranger @ 05/07/10 12:36 PM

Just do what you do Knight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

www.sportstalk4us.blogspot.com

# 1109 Side Effect @ 05/07/10 12:43 PM

The Cubs called up top prospect Starlin Castro today.

# 1110 D3C4K @ 05/07/10 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Side Effect


	The Cubs called up top prospect Starlin Castro today.

Yeah, blowing a perfect opportunity to gain some ground while the Cards had to deal with the Phillies probably had something to do with that. Getting blown out by the Pirates of all teams in the process only added fuel to the fire. Oh well, I've wanted Theriot to play 2nd for a while now, so there's always that.

# 1111 beelo @ 05/07/10 01:18 PM

More Mariners Notes:

Milton Bradley was put on the restricted list
RHP Ricky Orta Released
Mark Lowe on 15 Day DL
Shawn Kelley Called Up
Michael Saunders Called Up

# 1112 jethrotull @ 05/07/10 02:41 PM

Austin Jackson could use a bump from a B to an A, considering he was AL rookie of the month and is hitting .350

# 1113 chicubsfan20 @ 05/07/10 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by D3C4K


	Yeah, blowing a perfect opportunity to gain some ground while the Cards had to deal with the Phillies probably had something to do with that. Getting blown out by the Pirates of all teams in the process only added fuel to the fire. Oh well, I've wanted Theriot to play 2nd for a while now, so there's always that.

Same on the Theriot situation. I think he's more suited for a 2nd. It's his naturally position.

# 1114 gkasper @ 05/07/10 05:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vanman2425


	Buster Posey, Jesus Montero, Wil Meyers, and Carlos Santana are all better prospects.

Posey=A
Montero=A
Meyers=A
Santana=A
Ramos=B

Meyers is 19 and just got started... Montero is only 20 but is super good. Posey may spend time at 1st base in his career.

I guess I feel that in the MAJOR leagues there are not a lot of great catchers. These guys all are going to make a mark because of that. I feel that Ramos is going to be ready very soon to play in the majors every day for a team. Posey and Montero are also there.

Home runs?
Ramos =31 in 5 years, Posey= 19 in 4 years, Montero=37 in 4 years

You can't tell me that Ramos doesn't at least deserve the A rating like the rest of them! Especially when Meyers hasn't even seen any time yet.

Don't like the Twins much?

Anyway I agree with you that there are some nice catching prospects out there. I meant... 'how many good catchers do you see in the major leagues?' Mauer, McCann, Martinez, um........ Wieters?Suzuki? The top-level catcher pool is rather slim.

# 1115 Vanman2425 @ 05/07/10 06:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gkasper


	Posey=A Montero=A Meyers=A Santana=A Ramos=B Meyers is 19 and just got started... Montero is only 20 but is super good. Posey may spend time at 1st base in his career. I guess I feel that in the MAJOR leagues there are not a lot of great catchers. These guys all are going to make a mark because of that. I feel that Ramos is going to be ready very soon to play in the majors every day for a team. Posey and Montero are also there. Home runs? Ramos =31 in 5 years, Posey= 19 in 4 years, Montero=37 in 4 years You can't tell me that Ramos doesn't at least deserve the A rating like the rest of them! Especially when Meyers hasn't even seen any time yet. Don't like the Twins much? Anyway I agree with you that there are some nice catching prospects out there. I meant... 'how many good catchers do you see in the major leagues?' Mauer, McCann, Martinez, um........ Wieters?Suzuki? The top-level catcher pool is rather slim.

I live in MN, and the hype for Ramos after 1 game just made me a little sick.

I am however not much of twins fan, I'm a Giants fan, and Posey will catch, they just tried him at 1st in ST because they resigned the tub-o-lard Bengie Molina, and they thought they could maybe find time to play him at 1st sometime this year. His future is behind the plate though without question.

You just asked to name better catchers, and I think they did. I really couldn't care less what Ramos is rated, it's a video game, I would personally be more concerned with what he does in real life.

And if you rate a player simply on HR ouput in the minors, then I hope the Giants don't hire you as a minor league scout.

# 1116 gkasper @ 05/07/10 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vanman2425


	I live in MN, and the hype for Ramos after 1 game just made me a little sick. I am however not much of twins fan, I'm a Giants fan, and Posey will catch, they just tried him at 1st in ST because they resigned the tub-o-lard Bengie Molina, and they thought they could maybe find time to play him at 1st sometime this year. His future is behind the plate though without question. You just asked to name better catchers, and I think they did. I really couldn't care less what Ramos is rated, it's a video game, I would personally be more concerned with what he does in real life. And if you rate a player simply on HR ouput in the minors, then I hope the Giants don't hire you as a minor league scout.

Well I didn't even start talking about his defense yet, which may be his best attribute. A great defensive catcher who is currently managing Minnesota's pitching staff well with Mauer on the DL. A .288 minor league hitting line and power potential.

My point is that everyone on your list has an A rating on the rosters. Ramos is a good person to bump up to an A rating. Some of us were hyped up about him before his lights out Spring Training and major league debut.

Now Austin Jackson is also a prime candidate... so far he has been an ideal lead off hitter. However, he has got to come back to earth some day.

# 1117 Aloia50 @ 05/07/10 07:42 PM

anyone know when v2 will be released?? Thanks!!

# 1118 rynecandy @ 05/07/10 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by D3C4K


	Yeah, blowing a perfect opportunity to gain some ground while the Cards had to deal with the Phillies probably had something to do with that. Getting blown out by the Pirates of all teams in the process only added fuel to the fire. Oh well, I've wanted Theriot to play 2nd for a while now, so there's always that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by chicubsfan20


	Same on the Theriot situation. I think he's more suited for a 2nd. It's his naturally position.

and he hit a 3 run HR in MLB debut...hope that is a sign of more to come.

# 1119 ltw0303cavs @ 05/07/10 07:55 PM

Montero is a DH dressed up as a catcher. Austin Romine is the future Yanks catcher. Montero has great hitting potential but they have no confidence in his catching ability at all trust me. Ramos is a catcher. Ramos im ok with a B remember in the Show now he could build to a A if you train him right.

# 1120 gkasper @ 05/07/10 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ltw0303cavs


	Montero is a DH dressed up as a catcher. Austin Romine is the future Yanks catcher. Montero has great hitting potential but they have no confidence in his catching ability at all trust me. Ramos is a catcher. Ramos im ok with a B remember in the Show now he could build to a A if you train him right.

I will surely make steps to make him good in my franchise play in spite of his B rating. I still think out of a strong list of catching prospects... Ramos is highly underrated at a B rating. Montero is going to be a terrific hitter. Posey will be a good player and a great hitter for average, but I have seen scouting reports with him at 20-25 HR a year and I don't buy into that. And we haven't even mentioned Derek Norris (Nationals fans) or Jason Castro (Astros fans).

I am excited to see the catchers that are coming up! Give em all A's!

« Previous 1 2…53 54 555657 58 59…78 79 Next »

More Links

MLB '10: The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors V.1