NCAA March Madness 09 News Post

NCAA Basketball 09 - A Second Opinion

01:49 PM - November 20, 2008 by RaychelSnr

I have been a College Hoops 2K fan since the inception of the series back on my PS2. As a huge fan of college basketball, I always loved how 2K was able to get the little things about the game right. I loved how they would include all the teams, all the fight songs, all the mascots, all the arenas, all the jerseys, and it didn't hurt that the game always played great.

As the years progressed, the 2K engine started showing its age, and I became increasingly bored with the series up until College Hoops 2K8 was released last November. 2K8 was the pinnacle of college hoops gaming -- from the outstanding pregame analysis, to the weekly wrap up shows, to the incredibly deep gameplay mechanics, CH 2K8 was a college basketball fan's dream come true. Needless to say, I was crushed earlier this year when I heard that 2K would no longer be continuing the franchise that had left me wanting more after the release of 2K8.

Read More: NCAA Basketball 09 - A Second Opinion

NCAA Basketball 09 screenshot gallery - Click to view

Game: NCAA Basketball 09Reader Score: 7/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3 / Xbox 360Votes for game: 29 - View All

NCAA Basketball 09 Videos

Member Comments

# 41 K_rob11 @ 11/21/08 04:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by indyfree


	countryboy...aka- wanna be EA game tester... get off EA'S ****. The game isn't good and no one in their right mind would dish out 60 bucks, if they've played the 2k series before. The demo puts it all out there...like a fat chick in a bikini...aka-ur mom. But next time you try to defend EA, get your facts straight! EA hasn't been anything since SEGA GENSIS days!!!!

Internet fight! Internet fight! WHOO HOO!!

# 42 VTPack919 @ 11/21/08 04:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by indyfree


	countryboy...aka- wanna be EA game tester... get off EA'S ****. The game isn't good and no one in their right mind would dish out 60 bucks, if they've played the 2k series before. The demo puts it all out there...like a fat chick in a bikini...aka-ur mom. But next time you try to defend EA, get your facts straight! EA hasn't been anything since SEGA GENSIS days!!!!

3 Posts in and this is what comes out? You are garbage.

# 43 elprez98 @ 11/21/08 04:15 PM

I would think that this is a perfect game reading this article. Not impressed.

# 44 VTPack919 @ 11/21/08 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elprez98


	I would think that this is a perfect game reading this article. Not impressed.

Then that begs the question.....

Can you even read sir?

# 45 ronnyballgame @ 11/21/08 04:26 PM

Wow, this review may have convinced me to buy the game. Can you import NCAA draft classes into Live?

# 46 VTPack919 @ 11/21/08 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ronnyballgame


	Wow, this review may have convinced me to buy the game. Can you import NCAA draft classes into Live?

No unfortunately not.

# 47 Bumble14 @ 11/21/08 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elprez98


	I would think that this is a perfect game reading this article. Not impressed.

Where at any point during this article did I ever say the game was perfect and had no flaws?

# 48 VTPack919 @ 11/21/08 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bumble14


	Where at any point during this article did I ever say the game was perfect and had no flaws?

Just ignore him in hopes he will go away....

# 49 ronnyballgame @ 11/21/08 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VTPack919


	No unfortunately not.

Stinks, but I am definitely going to look into this game...if the wife lets me, haha

# 50 phlipmode @ 11/21/08 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bears5122


	Some people just have higher expectations, especially for a company as large as EA. I personally don't think the game is bad. But I understand it's still 2 years behind where the CH series was. It's tough to give a company credit for making a game miles behind their dead competitors game from last year. We know that EA can make a good game when pushed. Just look at FIFA and even NHL. Some don't want to praise them for mediocrity. They should be blowing our minds in sports games.

This is the best post in this thread,.. its just that simple thx bear..

Guys enjoy this game if you like it, as for myself and many others we will not accept a game from EA until they make games better than 2k. GOD knows they have the money.

And Im not applauding a company that should have been making better bball games since live'95...

Would you applaude a 7yr old that just stop wearing diapers to bed???

# 51 VTPack919 @ 11/21/08 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by phlipmode


	This is the best post in this thread,.. its just that simple thx bear.. Guys enjoy this game if you like it, as for myself and many others we will not accept a game from EA until they make games better than 2k. GOD knows they have the money. And Im not applauding a company that should have been making better bball games since live'95... Would you applaude a 7yr old that just stop wearing diapers to bed???

Okay, we get it.

# 52 countryboy @ 11/21/08 06:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by indyfree


	Let me first say that this game NCAA is about 5 years behind... meaning no multiplayer dynasty mode, bad camera views, legend teams= stick figures, the commentary sounds like robots, and the player and ball movement is stiff... March Madness and 09 NCAA Basketball is comparable to regular poo to poo w/ corn. We are suppose to buy a game for 60 bucks that is still way behind from where it should be? I think NOT!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by countryboy


	Sorry to hear that you disliked the game this much, especially after spending $60 on it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by indyfree


	countryboy...aka- wanna be EA game tester... get off EA'S ****. The game isn't good and no one in their right mind would dish out 60 bucks, if they've played the 2k series before. The demo puts it all out there...like a fat chick in a bikini...aka-ur mom. But next time you try to defend EA, get your facts straight! EA hasn't been anything since SEGA GENSIS days!!!!

do you even know what you're talking about, because I sure don't. All I said was that I'm sorry you disliked the game. What facts do I need to get straight?

Wanna be game tester? No not really, I'd rather play the games and continue to work at the job I currently have.

Defending EA? Have you always had issues with reading comprehension or is this something new?

3 posts and this is what you come up with. My guess is that you're a previously banned user or you're just an ignorant, gutless, wanna be tough internet guy, son of a bitch that has nothing better to do than troll an internet forum. Hell, maybe you're both. But in any event, congratulations, I'm sure you're parents are proud of the piece of sh!t you've turned out to be.

# 53 HustlinOwl @ 11/21/08 06:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by countryboy


	do you even know what you're talking about, because I sure don't. All I said was that I'm sorry you disliked the game. What facts do I need to get straight? Wanna be game tester? No not really, I'd rather play the games and continue to work at the job I currently have. Defending EA? Have you always had issues with reading comprehension or is this something new? 3 posts and this is what you come up with. My guess is that you're a previously banned user or you're just an ignorant, gutless, wanna be tough internet guy, son of a bitch that has nothing better to do than troll an internet forum. Hell, maybe you're both. But in any event, congratulations, I'm sure you're parents are proud of the piece of sh!t you've turned out to be.

# 54 dimez10 @ 11/21/08 07:36 PM

I am an old school basketball gamer. Lakers vs. Celtics; Bulls vs. Lakers; Bulls vs. Blazers; NBA Showtime; and who can forget the timeless classic "Coach K Basketball"? I have been an EA supporter until recent years. I can honestly say 2K sports has had a strangle-hold on the basketball video gaming market since NBA 2K on the Dreamcast. Last year's College Hoops 2K8 captured my love for the game like only Coack K had done. I thought in impossible and vowed to not give EA a chance ever again. Make no mistake this is no Coach K, but it is good. The developers have done a great job of adjusting the Live 09 game engine to simulate the college basketball experience. I will use my game from last night as an example. I was playing as Davidson went up against Duke. I move Stefan Curry over to the point guard position before the game to work him in the pick and roll from the tip. While he did a great job of finding the open man and not turning over the ball (which was one of my game focuses), he struggled with his shot off of the dribble. He was 1 of 6 from the 3 pt line in the 1st half; mainly from creating his own shot off the dribble. The Duke's aggressive man-to-man had him bottled up at the point. In the 2nd half, I switched him to the 2 guard spot and I could not believe my eyes. Even when I didn't run a set play, Curry could be clearly seen running off baseline screens and curling off of off-ball back picks. He ended shooting 5-9 from 3-pt land in the 2nd half (6-15 for the entire game) including his final long range shot with 12 seconds on the clock to put us ahead for the win. Not to mention the quickstrike moves are executed way more seamlessly than in it's "older brother" counterpart (Live 09) as well as the fluid player movements. Little subtlties like that explain why this game has once again captured my attention and has we anxiously awaiting "clock-out" time at work to go home and run another game. Please understand, by no means am I saying this is a perfect game or without flaw; but I am saying it is a winner for the hard-core basketball sim gamer as well as basketball fan.

# 55 seanhazz1 @ 11/21/08 08:25 PM

It seems to me that those who are bashing NCAA 09 assume that a "DEMO" of a game includes all the features, bells, and whistles of a final product.
Spend your hard earned money any way you want, but to come into a forum and bash a game you (a) don't own, (b), never played, and (c) have no real knowledge about makes you seem hired to do the bashing, by the floundering TAKE TWO company (their stock has plummeted since refusing the EA offer) as a last gasp before they go under.

The reviewer gave an honest opinion, posted here for those who may have been on the fence about buying the game, not for those who already had their mind made up since 2003.

Those that say NBA 2K9 and CHOOPS 2K8 are the pinnacle of sports hoops to date must enjoy:
..... being able to exploit the CPU and players with known trap glitching, out of bounds stealing, continuous clipping issues, corrupted league files, frequent 2K server disconnects and down times, warping players, lack of online dynasty, players who have Jordan-like skills even though their ratings say drastically different, or no fatigue in online play.

I played 20 dynasty seasons in CHOOPS 2K8, and I can't even take that game seriously because I just like this game more...to the point I've already traded in NBA 2K9 because I won't play it anymore.

The llow of the game is much more college-like than any hoops game I've played before it since Coach K.

Those on the fence, read the review 2-3 more times and let it sink in, but ultimately you'll have to play for yourself to actually decide for yourself.

# 56 indyfree @ 11/21/08 09:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by countryboy


	do you even know what you're talking about, because I sure don't. All I said was that I'm sorry you disliked the game. What facts do I need to get straight? Wanna be game tester? No not really, I'd rather play the games and continue to work at the job I currently have. Defending EA? Have you always had issues with reading comprehension or is this something new? 3 posts and this is what you come up with. My guess is that you're a previously banned user or you're just an ignorant, gutless, wanna be tough internet guy, son of a bitch that has nothing better to do than troll an internet forum. Hell, maybe you're both. But in any event, congratulations, I'm sure you're parents are proud of the piece of sh!t you've turned out to be.

Damn son, didn't you get enough from the first round countryboy? Your fairy-like comeback is barely worthy of my time, but for my amusement I'm going to say this once. If you even think that EA is compareable to 2k than that's almost as big of a joke as your job, which probably involves stroking a shaft... FAGGGG!!!

# 57 countryboy @ 11/21/08 09:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by indyfree


	Damn son, didn't you get enough from the first round countryboy? Your fairy-like comeback is barely worthy of my time, but for my amusement I'm going to say this once. If you even think that EA is compareable to 2k than that's almost as big of a joke as your job, which probably involves stroking a shaft... FAGGGG!!!

Can you show me where I said that EA was better than 2k? Go ahead, I'll wait.

And I'm the fagg? I'm not the one having these fantasies about another man swinging from or stroking a dick.

# 58 23 @ 11/21/08 10:04 PM

The troll should be gone soon enough

# 59 Marino @ 11/21/08 10:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by countryboy


	Can you show me where I said that EA was better than 2k? Go ahead, I'll wait. And I'm the fagg? I'm not the one having these fantasies about another man swinging from or stroking a dick.

No he was calling you a bundle of sticks.

Now me I personally do not understand the joke, I mean what is so funny about a bundle of sticks?

# 60 Flightwhite24 @ 11/21/08 10:56 PM

Stop, please just stop. I want to enjoy what I read also their are minors that visit these forums. Peace fellows, Peace!!!

« Previous 1 234 5 Next »

More Links

NCAA Basketball 09 - A Second Opinion