Official Rate My Trade Thread

[JBH3]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeah...THAT Guy

Or, even better, a guy that can play point or SG and shoot from outside.

OJ Mayo can be that guy. He should be getting 38 to 40 minutes so I'd move him over to point and bring in a shooter from the bench when it's time to spell Westbrook.

[Meatloaf86]

I'm debating about which team to roll with, but for now it's the Bobcats. I trade away one of my lesser used centers for Sean May, I know he isn't anything special, but he is younger, and has some better potential than the guy I traded.

I'm trying to get rid of Stephen Jackson, but not sure who to look for in exchange. I like to shoot the 3, but don't really have a sure fire 3 point threat, have a few guys who can hit it, but not really a sure fire guy like Peja or someone of that sort. Does anyone have any suggestions about who to go for with Stephen Jackson as the main guy. I'm looking for a SF or a C in exchange, but mostly a 3 point shooting SF.

[iRepOklahoma]

I'm OKC. Its year two. The heat have signed Boozer, and are playing Beasley at the 3.

OKC Trades:
Jeff Green
Kyle Weaver
2011 1st rnder

MIA Trades:
Michael Beasley

I'd edit Jeff Green to his natural 3 position, which gives him a 79 rating. The Heat don't have a real 3, and are using Beasley. I don't have a real 4, and Im using Green. Is this going to be fair? (assuming they even accept it)

[chezzie11]

Personally, I think you paid you much.

[chokokoko]

OKC Trades:

Big man:

Greg Oden for Kristic & 11 1st round

PG:

T. Evans for Westbrook & 10 1st round pick

I think Evans will turn out to be bigger than Westbrook

[The_Patriot_12]

I am the Grizzlies and i want a good defensive minded center. Would it be fair/realistic to trade marc gasol 76 ovr. for greg oden 75 ovr. or joakim noah 73 ovr.

[iRepOklahoma]

Quote: Originally Posted by chokokoko

OKC Trades: Big man: Greg Oden for Kristic & 11 1st round PG: T. Evans for Westbrook & 10 1st round pick I think Evans will turn out to be bigger than Westbrook

Neither is fair. You gave up too much for Evans and got waaaay too much for Nenad. Center's like Kristic are a dime a dozen. If Portland wanted a Nenad type player, they'd sign him and keep Oden too. 2011 OKC first rounder is nothing either

[Comduklakis]

Quote: Originally Posted by iRepOklahoma

I'm OKC. Its year two. The heat have signed Boozer, and are playing Beasley at the 3. OKC Trades: Jeff Green Kyle Weaver 2011 1st rnder MIA Trades: Michael Beasley I'd edit Jeff Green to his natural 3 position, which gives him a 79 rating. The Heat don't have a real 3, and are using Beasley. I don't have a real 4, and Im using Green. Is this going to be fair? (assuming they even accept it)

Too much for Beasley. He's not an all star in the game and IRL he's absolutely been going backwards in the last month. I expect his ratings to drop in the next roster update. However I understand why you did it. I had the Heat sign Boozer and tried Boozer at C with Beasley at PF and it tanked. So I tried Beasley at SF and inserted Joel Anthony at C just to rebound (O'neal was gone). That failed miserably too. Boozer and Beasley just didn't play well together. I would say that Weaver and Green is probably fair for Beasley without the pick.