Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Weeks]

no i was going based on this years roster, not knowing what their assoc. roster looked like

nice trade, your teams looks pretty scary

[sammogard]

chris duhon 1st round pick- vilonana that pf from pistons.

its like haveing two harringtons and one whose more consitent and younger and only getting better


i did 3 trades to get mayo on my team reall didnt ruin anything it was alot trades that made sense first i traded t mac for kevin martin liked t mac so i traded back lmao.

[The_Patriot_12]

Quote: Originally Posted by The_Patriot_12

Suns Recieve: K.Garnett PF 87 ovr. R. Wallace C 74 ovr. M. Daniels SG 65 ovr. 1st round pick Celtics recieve: A. Stoudemire PF 85 ovr. J. Dudley SF 72 ovr. L. Amundson PF 65 ovr. J. Collins C 48 ovr. Let me kno if you guys think this trade is fair/sim. The suns strengthen their frontcourt/ defense and the celtics get som youth and a scorer off the bench.

thoughts please

[jeremym480]

Quote: Originally Posted by The_Patriot_12

thoughts please

Seems fair to me.

[jlneste]

Quote: Originally Posted by The_Patriot_12

thoughts please

It just depends what you are going for...as far as in real life? It's not happening. Rasheed and KG are really beginning to show their age. Amundson is developing into a great "glue" type of guy for the Suns, so I don't see them letting him go anytime soon. Dudley is another one, pretty cheap player that adds outside shooting off the bench.

As far as in NBA 2K10, the Suns are getting the short end of the stick. Amare is dominant in the low post, KG and Wallace don't equal his offensive power. Defense KG and Wallace are better, but you don't know what you will get from them on the other side. Plus how do you run Amundson and Big Baby? Niether is much of an option at center, they are both power forwards. Daniels for Dudley doens't help the Suns since they already have Richardson and Barbosa at the 2. And Dudley is a better option playing the 3.

Just my thoughts...

[The_Patriot_12]

Quote: Originally Posted by jlneste

It just depends what you are going for...as far as in real life? It's not happening. Rasheed and KG are really beginning to show their age. Amundson is developing into a great "glue" type of guy for the Suns, so I don't see them letting him go anytime soon. Dudley is another one, pretty cheap player that adds outside shooting off the bench. As far as in NBA 2K10, the Suns are getting the short end of the stick. Amare is dominant in the low post, KG and Wallace don't equal his offensive power. Defense KG and Wallace are better, but you don't know what you will get from them on the other side. Plus how do you run Amundson and Big Baby? Niether is much of an option at center, they are both power forwards. Daniels for Dudley doens't help the Suns since they already have Richardson and Barbosa at the 2. And Dudley is a better option playing the 3. Just my thoughts...

Well my theory is there is a big possibility of amare leaving in the offseason and they will lose him for nothing. They also strengthen their weakest spot at center. Do u think the trade would be more fair if i drop dudley from the trade

[K_rob11]

Quote: Originally Posted by JBH3

I made the move for OKC because they went 50-32 last year and made the NBA Finals beating Denver in 5 games. However, they got swept by the Chris Bosh led Knicks - who also still have Lee, Gallinari, and Chandler + T-Mac and TJ Ford. OKC loses Harden but they have Shannon Brown who has progressed well, and ADD a big man like Millsapp who can board and be fed in the post. I moved Durant to SG, Jeff Green to SF, Millsapp plays the 4, and Jermaine O'Neal is OKCs Center. Russ Westbrook is still at point, and Eric Maynor, Leon Powe, Pops Mensah Bonsu, CJ Miles, a 67 rookie center, and Kyle Weaver make up the rest of that squad. Still think OKC was shafted given that info? My 76ers lineup looks like this now: PG-Deron Williams SG-Louis Williams SF-James Harden PF-Elton Brand C-(R) Chris Valentine (70 ovr) 6th man Jason Richardson RP Al Thornton RP Jrue Holiday RP DaJuan Summers RP Fabricio Oberto I also have a 70 over SF I drafted 8th overall and a 74 rated SG I drafted after yr1. Neither have factored into my current plans though.

JBH3...with the way you have Lou Williams playing, I think this is a very good trade. The only worry I would have is how strong your backcourt will be on the defensive end....especially losing a defensive player like Iggy at the 2. Also, this rookie you got must be good for you to give up on Speights. But we'll see....looks like a fun team!

[JBH3]

Quote: Originally Posted by K_rob11

JBH3...with the way you have Lou Williams playing, I think this is a very good trade. The only worry I would have is how strong your backcourt will be on the defensive end....especially losing a defensive player like Iggy at the 2. Also, this rookie you got must be good for you to give up on Speights. But we'll see....looks like a fun team!

Yea...I'm a bit undersized at the 2 now, and have enjoyed my time w/ Louis running point, but two years of losing called for a change.

As for Speights...he will be missed. He was a cap casualty being in the final year of his rookie contract, and being that I drafted a PF/C rookie w/ A- potential who I want to start so I can get reward points to use in mini-camps and further develop my team.