2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[hradekbr]

Quote: Originally Posted by TGov

I'm the Red Sox and I want Josh Reddick back! lol... What do you think is a fair trade...? I'm just trying to an idea of what to offer, thank you...

Use the spreadsheet for values than propose an offer

[Totte]

Quote: Originally Posted by hradekbr

Gary Brown for Ellsbury straight up is crazy talk, like ridiculously crazy

Kinda agree with you but Sabean went out and acquired Beltran at the deadline for Wheeler so we've seen the Giants make deals like that before. Also wouldn't be surprised to see Ellsbury resign (as a FA, not during the season) with SF if he went there. Ellsbury and Pagan would make a nice speedy OF combo

[koenigcarl]

What are your thoughts about morneau for belt and zito?

Gesendet von meinem HTC One XL mit Tapatalk 2

[shadow2201]

Quote: Originally Posted by koenigcarl

What are your thoughts about morneau for belt and zito? Gesendet von meinem HTC One XL mit Tapatalk 2

Seems ok on paper, but besides being able to dump Zito's contract, I don't think very realistic! Morneau is on the downswing of his career, although still a serviceable 1B, the Giants have finally opened up 1B for Belt to take, and I don't think they'd go for Morneau over Belt at this point!

[Skuxx24]

Quote: Originally Posted by koenigcarl

What are your thoughts about morneau for belt and zito? Gesendet von meinem HTC One XL mit Tapatalk 2

Maybe a tad much IMO Belt is still fairly young and has got upside while Zito is old yea but showed he still has some Value in the rotation with his performance in last years postseason. I agree that the giants need more power apart
From panda and Posey there ain't much power guys in the lineup. Cause use another 25-30 Hr guy

[koenigcarl]

And Morneau + Scott Diamond for Smoak/ Kendry Morales + Wells ?

Gesendet von meinem HTC One XL mit Tapatalk 2

[iRepIndiana]

Quote: Originally Posted by hradekbr

Use the spreadsheet for values than propose an offer

This isn't refer people to the spreadsheet and get back to us thread. Whats so hard about helping people out? This isn't what made last years thread fun.

Idc who put it together. People ask about a player, throw names out there. That's what made last years thread a success. Not referring people to a spreadsheet and making them fend for themselves.

Cheers.

[nowitsourtime]

Quote: Originally Posted by koenigcarl

And Morneau + Scott Diamond for Smoak/ Kendry Morales + Wells ? Gesendet von meinem HTC One XL mit Tapatalk 2

I personally think the Mariners are really winning that trade...