Home
Feature Article
MyCAREER Has a Realism Problem

Last year, you “Lived the Dream.” This year you experienced your “Prelude” to greatness. Both of these modes in Visual Concepts’ NBA 2K franchise were supposed to acclimate and immerse you into the game’s premier mode, MyCareer. Both years had you assume a player whose visage and role you could create, but whose persona was already determined via the story mode crafted by Visual Concepts. I’m not here to talk about the merits of last year’s “movie of the week” presentation (personally, I liked it) or this year’s evolved version that grants you much more control over your player during your rookie NBA season.

I’m here to talk about something else. Just like last year, your guy. You. The President of basketball, aka Pres, flat out SUCKS!

I was really excited to load up the Prelude this year. It took the most exciting things about last year’s attempt and removed a lot of the perceived contrived portions about Freq, his “twin” sister and his troubled entourage. You start at the end of your high school basketball career showing your mentor and high school coach, Washington Falls, your highlight reel. You are a high school All-American, the number one recruit in the country. You pick your college, but everyone knows you’re too good to stay there more than your mandatory freshman year. Then you get to upgrade Pres’ attributes for the first time to discover you’re rated...55!? Which country was I the top recruit in, Angola?

All of the commentary casts Pres as the second coming. A leader destined for greatness the same way as Carmelo Anthony, who also brought his college program to the championship his freshman year. However, you, as the “President of Basketball,” have difficulty finishing a layup or sinking a free throw. Opposing players run circles around you. By the time you're drafted five games later, you're lucky if you've earned enough Virtual Currency (VC) to have raised him a couple attribute points. You wind up drafted as a one-and-done transcendent player who is (conservatively) 20 points below his contemporaries (you also might end up going very low in the draft, which is also awkward for your status).

There is a way, of course, to make Pres better right away. It involves spending extra money on VC to “juice” your way to mediocrity. To date I’ve spent 40 dollars on VC. I bought the Legends edition of the game that included 30,000 in VC (approximately $10 USD value) which cost $79.99. Then I bought 75,000 VC in-game for 20 bucks. With 105,000 VC, Pres catapulted from 55 to 82.

I assume the point of making MyCareer is to immerse the player in the world of an up and coming professional basketball player. After all, the cutscenes are full of recognizable faces interacting with your virtual avatar and performing all sorts of activities with you. The problem begins when you attempt to approximate NBA basketball at the burgeoning superstar level, only to fall way short.

I spent almost 100 dollars to get my player to a level where it makes sense that he’s receiving endorsement deals every other day. Many people can’t afford to spend that much on one game. And either way, no player should ever have to spend that kind of money on something like this. As I see it, the only reason to make your player start so low is to push you to spend real dollars to buy VC. Wouldn’t it make sense from a immersion -- and moral -- standpoint to start your player with a rating in at least the 70s? If he’s the number one basketball recruit in the number one basketball country in the world, wouldn’t it make sense that he’s at least as good as the other guys getting drafted in his NBA draft class?

I mean I had barely made it to December of my rookie year, and I had already received endorsement deals from Gatorade, Foot Locker, 2K, Mountain Dew and Tissot. Plus, I had a shoe deal. I had only started one game and was averaging just over 10 points a game. These aren’t numbers that garner major endorsement deals. Beyond that, if I only bought the game and used no extra VC except for what I earned through gameplay, I’m under the impression I would have still been offered most of those deals, if not all of them. Bye immersion.

It’s really a shame that the desire to capitalize monetarily on a flawed system was more important than fixing said system to increase its realism. If I wasn’t spending all that VC on attributes, I probably would have still spent it on something else with the game, like accessories for Pres or stuff for MyCourt. The difference would be that I’d be happy about spending it there.


Member Comments
# 101 jfsolo @ 11/13/16 11:11 AM
IMO, as bad as the storyline aspect is, the gameplay/A.I. for mode is actually much, much worse.
 
# 102 meccs @ 11/14/16 04:33 AM
My main problem is Justice. Not as a addition to the game but more that he is so good and takes away one starting spot. I mean if you are a PG and move to OKC or the Clippers for example, Westbrook and CP3 get send to the bench which is ridiculous! Who would want that? It ruins MyCareer for me this year.
 
# 103 MrCrashAndBurn @ 11/15/16 03:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by meccs
My main problem is Justice. Not as a addition to the game but more that he is so good and takes away one starting spot. I mean if you are a PG and move to OKC or the Clippers for example, Westbrook and CP3 get send to the bench which is ridiculous! Who would want that? It ruins MyCareer for me this year.
My problem with Justice is that, from an attribute standpoint, is better than you can possibly make your player.

He has close to Sharpshooter's shooting ability. He has Playmaker levels of ball control. He can finish almost like Slasher. He has max defensive stats.

It fills like a slap in the face from 2K. They decide to give you restrictive caps, then they give us a created teammate that laughs at those caps.
 
# 104 TheBigTicket205 @ 11/15/16 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Whomario
My Career has a cutscene problem. Stop trying to act like you want to produce "The Last of us 2" rather than a basketball game.

Also stop forcing people into "themes" and design a system for offline-users to actually play it as a career mode rather than a means to enter online-modes, that way i as an offline user would not be handicapped by restrictions put in place to "protect" other online users.
I have no desire to use my player online, all i want is start as a decently rated player and choose my own parameters of playing the game (heck, i would even enjoy being able to limit my potential to improve).
I love this comment... Although I enjoy the cut scenes they give the mode a bit of immersion... They just need to come up with a better more relatable story line.
 
# 105 Worst3PTShooter @ 12/06/16 03:44 AM
I don't understand it either. The rating you start with is terrible, when you can see players like Simmons, Ingram and Kris Dunn rated more than 70 and 75, yet you're the worst in the first round and still get picked in the lottery.
Why is Justice better than you, when he goes undrafted? Isn't it your player who should be better?
And when you get doubleteamed, you can pass it to Justice, who's WIDE open and got amazing 3PT shot and he still misses 50%. His defense is rated 99 in my game, but I still see Klay, Kyrie, Dwayne Wade and even flippin' J.R. Smith dropping him like he was a fly.
It makes no sense, it's sad to think about.
 
# 106 adamspag @ 12/06/16 04:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Worst3PTShooter
And when you get doubleteamed, you can pass it to Justice, who's WIDE open and got amazing 3PT shot and he still misses 50%.
lol......
 
# 107 Worst3PTShooter @ 12/06/16 04:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by adamspag
lol......
Yeah, it's a joke..
 
# 108 gausec @ 12/12/16 12:29 PM
I have to say I totally agree, at first I was excited for mycareer and saw I was a 50 overall. I was like okay I can grind and get him decent. I play on HOF I'm not amazing but I do okay, my guy is averaging 7 points, shooting 40 percent, average 4 assists, and 4 rebounds a game, turnovers are high with 2. Now I don't think I should be able to enter the NBA and dominate everyone but when I enter the game and can't nail an open shot without putting VC in then its annoying. I was supposed to be one of the best players in college.

You choose an arch type and even that skill isn't NBA ready I would be okay if I started low 60s and say I made myself a sharpshooter I had good shooting ability, but no. After awhile the grind doesn't feel worth it.

Oh and lets not mention that Justice starts off better as you, but so does Denver... In MyCareer on the bucks Denver is actually the starter, he averages 22 minutes I get 25. I don't know his numbers off hand but I saw the other game I played me and him tied with points at 16.. I had the better +/- though
 
# 109 thefranchise03 @ 12/16/16 02:55 AM
All I wanted to do is create an international player from Hong Kong and become the next Yao Ming. The past two years, I'm unable to do that because I'm being forced into their crappy stories. Why am I forced to be black? Why can't I be Asian? Do they not know that every race plays this game too?
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.