Madden NFL 15 Top 5 Quarterbacks

[Godgers12]

Wilson should be a 80-82 tops. He is an average QB, he is a lot closer to Alex Smith than Tom Brady lol. No way should he be a 93.

[bmj2k7]

Wilson: Not even a top 10 Qb, if you actually start listing QB's he might not make some people's top 15.

Brady: Voted by the players as the 2nd BEST QB IN THE NFL, AND 3RD BEST PLAYER IN THE NFL! His stats the 2nd half of the season even without Gronk, was around 100 passer rating. With Gronk THEY HAD THE NO1 OFFENSE IN THE NFL FOR OVER A MONTH! Yes this clearly shows Brady is going down hill LOL! With Ridley fumbling, and Gronk not playing, half there D was on IR, there OL was banged up, and some on IR, and had ROOKIES, and 2nd in DROPS! Will be a 97 after 4 games into the season if they stay healthy and the WR's make that 2nd year jump most do, they will probably be a top 3 Offense again!

[Dr. Poe]

Russell Wilson is rated too high.

[friscob]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dr. Poe

Russell Wilson is rated too high.

Its madden, everyone is. The individual ratings matter more than ovr and im sure his athleticism bumped that ovr up quite a bit. Rosters can be edited and shared so it shouldnt matter anyway

That Russ screenshot looks great. Curious to see what noodle arm Manning's thp is lol

[TheSaints7]

Quote: Originally Posted by mrprice33

He's not rated as an 83, though. He's a 93. It's an elite rating. It's 4th best among QBs. Could you argue for him ahead of Manning, Rodgers, or Brees? You'd have the best argument to put him ahead of Brees, who's gotten sloppy with the ball the past couple of years, but he seems to be rated about where he should be, no?

hahaha. Sloppy with the ball? You clearly don't watch NFL. He's thrown for 5000+ yards 3 years in a row. 39 TDs last season and only 12 interceptions. He doesn't have an argument to put Wilson with any of the 3. Rodgers was the one with just 17 touchdowns last year.

[friscob]

Quote: Originally Posted by bmj2k7

Wilson: Not even a top 10 Qb, if you actually start listing QB's he might not make some people's top 15.

If you actually believe that youre a complete fool. The hawks were a .500 or worse team before russ showed up. He plays behind an awful o line with a below avg wr corp. Brady would be eaten alive on that team. The seahawks/russ wilson relationship is mutully beneficial.

And brady gets the luxury of playing in a division thats incredibly weak yr after yr. Bradys great, but that doesnt mean wilson isnt too.

[The JareBear]

Quote: Originally Posted by friscob

Its madden, everyone is. The individual ratings matter more than ovr and im sure his athleticism bumped that ovr up quite a bit. Rosters can be edited and shared so it shouldnt matter anyway That Russ screenshot looks great. Curious to see what noodle arm Manning's thp is lol

I think the article says his arm strength is 86.

I would probably put it a couple notches lower, honestly.

[CT Pitbull]

Quote: Originally Posted by underdog13

And Cutler will probably have 67 speed again smh..

yup Cutty's speed and overall athletic ability is overlooked every year. If you don't think Cutler is a GREAT athlete I invite you to look up some of his high school basketball/football highlights on you tube. The man has some hops!


Some of his dunks are absolutely FILTHY!...but because ESPN doesnt like his demeanor and the fact that he refuses to give them an interview every 5 minutes he gets no respect.