MLB 13 The Show Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

[Factzzz]

Quote: Originally Posted by seanjeezy

Lol I was trying to avoid this one since it is the most obvious case of Felix's superiority... Dickey - 9.9 WAR Felix - 17.3 WAR Felix should be rated between 171 and 173 Want to just use last year's #'s? Dickey - 4.6 Felix - 6.1

Why look at WAR when you can actually look at the wins they both got their teams

[tabarnes19_SDS]

The problem with numerical ratings is that people get hung up on the numbers instead of how the player performs. Sure there were ratings bars before(and I could view the ratings in the editor, but I couldn't access that info in game) but the Overall was so ambiguous that it made it difficult to determine who was rated higher.

This allows for a more realistic experience as a GM or coach. Girardi doesn't look down the bench and say, "hmmm I need a pinch hitter rated 80 or higher and he needs at least a 75 contact vs left and 85 power."

Like was stated before, as well, ratings are based off a formula based on position and a combination of ratings spit out of a formula to give you a number. So I'll have to choose between my 98 pitcher or 99 pitcher..

[Nooooovak]

Quote: Originally Posted by Factzzz

Why look at WAR when you can actually look at the wins they both got their teams

...that is exactly what WAR is.

[todder85]

Quote: Originally Posted by Richie12

Honestly I don't think they have space issue with a Bluray disc. PS3 internal memory I can understand if you want to animate the opening/closing of the roof. But what people are asking is a closed version of the dome that is loaded at game time like any other stadium.

All Star Baseball 2005 had roof open/closed and even closing. I remember playing at Safeco and watching the roof close as it moves along the tracks.

[tonadom]

Quote: Originally Posted by todder85

All Star Baseball 2005 had roof open/closed and even closing. I remember playing at Safeco and watching the roof close as it moves along the tracks.

Yea, but The Show is much more intricate than that game is. I have a feeling if they tried to do that now, it would eat up a lot of development time, which is probably why they don't wanna do it 'til the PS4 is out.

[Factzzz]

Quote: Originally Posted by Nooooovak

...that is exactly what WAR is.

No i mean record wise, as in Dickeys 39 Ws compared Felix 40 Ws

[CabreraMVP]

They can't control whether they get the win in games they pitch. That is based on their teams offense and the opposing teams pitching staff.

[yanksdaniel99]

Quote: Originally Posted by Factzzz

No i mean record wise, as in Dickeys 39 Ws compared Felix 40 Ws

You realize wins are a product of the team they play on right ?