MLB '10: The Show Top 5 Second Baseman

[BKBond007]

Quote: Originally Posted by keymax

Fielding pct. isn't a good way to evaluate a defensive player. It just says how many errors were made. And errors are determined by the the hometown scorer. So there is a subjective side. That's bad enough. Also it doesn't show how good a player is getting to the ball at all. If you don't get a ball, you can't commit an error.

Ok so Hills career avg UZR/150 at 2B is +6.9 and Cano's is -5.4 seems like a big difference

[keymax]

Quote: Originally Posted by BKBond007

Ok so Hills career avg UZR/150 at 2B is +6.9 and Cano's is -5.4 seems like a big difference

You're right. Didn't do my homework and just looked it up for 2009.

[Rod_Carew29]

For '09, I used Kotsay's stance...

I know there were a lot of changes for '10, but I fear that it's gonna be another mass-editing year once again...grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

Quote: Originally Posted by Shakedowncapo

Still haven't touched B-Phillips stance...Gonna be some pissed fans when they see this.(I forget who keeps asking for it every year)

[BKBond007]

Im not saying Hill should be number 1 and Im not saying Cano isnt a decent 2nd baseman that hits very well..just dont knock Hill to make Cano look better..

Hill is a great player and very entertaining..he's a grinder.

[Ewing]

Quote: Originally Posted by a4reak

You can give me this stats BS tag line but I know when I see him get to the balls that more the half the starting 2B cant get to that makes Cano a good defender.

[JermaineDye05]

Seriously, Robinson Cano fans, let it go. Your team is rated first in the game. I don't think you should be that disappointed because he's not in the top 9.

I agree, it's a mistake, but you need to let it go. You can always edit the players. And if you're too lazy, there are people on this board who are known for editing players to the T.

Not to mention the game does tend to update quite frequently.

[Knight165]

I ADORE these "top" threads.
I was going to watch Shutter Island...but I think I'll just wait for the SS and 3B threads!

M.K.
Knight165

[ParisB]

I'd take a healthy Howie Kendrick over several of the 2b on that list