NCAA Football 14: 2015-16 Roster Update (PS3)

[BE3585]

Ohio State
#6 QB/WR (You will see why down below) Torrance Gibson
Appears (still speculation) he is in the process of moving to WR for atleast his freshman season due to the crowded QB room (obviously). I think it may be wise to move him over to WR for now, but he won't get too much playing time there either, so his rating should probably be somewhere around 75-78, although his speed will probably need a boost as I believe its only around an 82 as of right now.
Source: http://ohiostate.247sports.com/Artic...To-WR-38087998

[muckcity]

Quote: Originally Posted by thesportsguru11

We need to do away with upperclassmen rating scales completely for the fall updates. I thought it would work, and I understand that it's easier for a lot of our editors for a spring roster, but we're just having more discrepancies than I originally thought ...doesn't work for me. We still should keep these All-Conference teams in mind when rating, but not let it solely dictate ratings. But if I'm overruled, I'll suck it up and make the changes on my own.

i am starting to agree, i got some Miami players rated based off the Phil Steele scale we have but i am not going to just go back and fix it and rate them the way i think, for example, i have Chad Thomas a DE for Miami who didn't start but played but didn't have an impact but based off the chart he would be and 87

[vikesfan059]

Quote: Originally Posted by thesportsguru11

We need to do away with upperclassmen rating scales completely for the fall updates. I thought it would work, and I understand that it's easier for a lot of our editors for a spring roster, but we're just having more discrepancies than I originally thought ...doesn't work for me. We still should keep these All-Conference teams in mind when rating, but not let it solely dictate ratings. But if I'm overruled, I'll suck it up and make the changes on my own.

Quote: Originally Posted by muckcity

i am starting to agree, i got some Miami players rated based off the Phil Steele scale we have but i am not going to just go back and fix it and rate them the way i think, for example, i have Chad Thomas a DE for Miami who didn't start but played but didn't have an impact but based off the chart he would be and 87

I agree there have been some questionable selections. Usually his Midseason and Postseason lists are much better than the Preseason lists. Perhaps we should remove the upperclassman scale for now and revisit the issue when he releases his Midseason list?

[Lilmoon78]

Ro’Derrick Hoskins
#18 LB 6’2 234 RS Soph Orlando Fla.


Vickers is listed at FB

[muckcity]

Quote: Originally Posted by vikesfan059

I agree there have been some questionable selections. Usually his Midseason and Postseason lists are much better than the Preseason lists. Perhaps we should remove the upperclassman scale for now and revisit the issue when he releases his Midseason list?

i agree, i am going to start fixing my teams when i get the file tomorrow, i think people should make sure those guys that are on the list be rated better then the other guys on the team though

[chucknorris1]

1st off great job I appreciate all y'all do...

Haven't seen it listed but VT needs another look Joshua Stanford is no longer on the team #5 is now cam Phillips switched #s...travon McMillan should be added unless I missed something he will be in the top 3 in depth chart for tb...because of his growth #15 Joel Caleb has been moved to wr...

Thanks again
recheck could be wrong but I know y'all like accuracy...

[muckcity]

Quote: Originally Posted by Lilmoon78

Ro’Derrick Hoskins #18 LB 6’2 234 RS Soph Orlando Fla. Vickers is listed at FB

i seen you posted this already, the other FSU guy said add Vickers

[muckcity]

Quote: Originally Posted by chucknorris1

1st off great job I appreciate all y'all do... Haven't seen it listed but VT needs another look Joshua Stanford is no longer on the team #5 is now cam Phillips switched #s...travon McMillan should be added unless I missed something he will be in the top 3 in depth chart for tb...because of his growth #15 Joel Caleb has been moved to wr... Thanks again recheck could be wrong but I know y'all like accuracy...

i will get this fixed, you got any links