NBA Elite 11 OS Exclusive Video: Oklahoma City Thunder @ Detroit Pistons

[Forever_Young83]

Quote: Originally Posted by rEAnimator

What do you mean? He pointed out some flaws in the game, he's right, except for the ankle breaker one which I explained. What more would you like to know? I'll watch it again and see if there's more insight I can provide, but the video speaks for itself.

Sorry but it only looked like you talked about when the defender stumbled.

[Forever_Young83]

Quote: Originally Posted by rEAnimator

I'm pretty sure that's a user control thing. I forget the name of he control, but the right stick passing gives you the no look pass among other things.

Oh thanks for the answer.

[WTF]

Quote: Originally Posted by Court_vision

Co-sign PM. I am with you and The Admiral. Somehow they've managed to derail this series yet again. Blocks dropping to the floor, guys rebounding in the wrong directions, no fastbreak logic (guards still run to the wings, not the hoop), horrible animations... Oh well. I've been stupid enough to stick by this series for a hell of a long time now. After the mess that was NCAA basketball and EA's complete failure to support that game / bugs left all through it.........i am kind of glad to be off the EA basketball train and not buying any of their stuff this season. Even though NCAA was highway robbery with it's bugs, I'd still have spent my $$$ on Elite if it was good as I love basketball games. It looks terrible though, so it's an easy decision not to get it.

Add me to the list. Very nice post.

[rEAnimator]

Quote: Originally Posted by Forever_Young83

With all due respect sir, why didn't you touch on the other instances pointed out in the video?

OK, here's another thought...

In my opinion the critique about the offensive board may not be quite fair.

Hard to tell, but I think the defensive player simply jumped too early and the offensive player timed his jump better which is why he got the board.

I agree that the contact animation and physics looks a little unnatural, but it is dynamic and the outcome played out in real time and wasn't predetermined when the defensive player jumped.

[supdog]

I thought 10 was a decent game and enjoyed live for the first time in years and after watching this video it looks like they went backwards with the player interactions.

[RayDog253]

Quote: Originally Posted by rEAnimator

OK, here's another thought... In my opinion the critique about the offensive board may not be quite fair. Hard to tell, but I think the defensive player simply jumped too early and the offensive player timed his jump better which is why he got the board. I agree that the contact animation and physics looks a little unnatural, but it is dynamic and the outcome played out in real time and wasn't predetermined when the defensive player jumped.

I think that's the problem, because we don't see the game the same way you see it. You know whats going on because you developed the game, so all the under the hood type stuff is noticable to you.

But to us, we look at it like we're watching a game of Basketball on T.V.. So if something looks off to us, were not going to think, 'Oh thats all right cause it's not two player animation and it's all dynamically driven by RTP'.

Don't mean to sound rude or anything, just trying to help you understand why I think most people aint feeling these videos.

[Moe24-]

Quote: Originally Posted by rEAnimator

OK, here's another thought... In my opinion the critique about the offensive board may not be quite fair. Hard to tell, but I think the defensive player simply jumped too early and the offensive player timed his jump better which is why he got the board. I agree that the contact animation and physics looks a little unnatural, but it is dynamic and the outcome played out in real time and wasn't predetermined when the defensive player jumped.

Did you just say something is wrong with the game

[magicman32]

Quote: Originally Posted by jfsolo

Great Post. They've put all their eggs into one philosophical basket, deciding that total control is exponentially more important then anything else. So, as you say, we'll now see how many gamers subscribe to that philosophy. I feel like the average online player will love this game. Since everything will be about what they do on the sticks. Winning and losing completely in their hands, just the way they want it.

I think this depends on if the defense seems fair and user friendly. IMO, the offense seems to have the advantage user vs user. And once people learn the shot releases it be a lot of made baskets, cuz a perfect release equals a make 100% of the time. But we'll have to wait and see.