NBA 2K13 Player Ratings - Javale McGee – 74, Josh Smith – 87, Kemba Walker - 78

[ojandpizza]

I just don't see how Kemba deserves a 78.. Did I miss him going HAM in summer league or something? If not then I'm completely lost lol

[nova91]

Quote: Originally Posted by FedExPope

As if its his fault. Its funny, even here in the supposed 'hardcore' basketball fan group of people, the Hawks get zero discussion, even when their best/most iconic player they currently have is in a thread title. No, we'd rather talk about some rookie being rated too high on the worst team to ever have played.

If you want to talk about Josh Smith, then talk about him. Ain't nobody stopping you.

[iamheat]

wow look how overrated MJ is, a 99 is too damn high for someone who doesnt even play anymore.....he wasnt even a 99 in his prime. KOBE4LIFE

[Paul Pierce_OS]

Quote: Originally Posted by iamheat

wow look how overrated MJ is, a 99 is too damn high for someone who doesnt even play anymore.....he wasnt even a 99 in his prime. KOBE4LIFE

[andeee]

Quote: Originally Posted by ojandpizza

Undeservingly lol

Yeah. You're right. Leading your team to the best record in the NBA while having two major pieces injured for a combined 57 games doesn't warrant an MVP.

[OTCU]

Quote: Originally Posted by andeee

Yeah. You're right. Leading your team to the best record in the NBA while having two major pieces injured for a combined 57 games doesn't warrant an MVP.

This year proved that rose isn't as valuable to the bulls success as many thought during his MVP year

[KasparV]

I disagree with the entire premise that a player should get a higher rating if they play with better teammates. Of course I know this will probably be the case, but ideally it should be that player X has a certain rating and based on his teammates, he should perform better or worse, and it shouldn't change his rating. A lot of players averaged greater numbers when they played for the Suns, with Nash, because he could find them in ways other PG's couldn't, he makes players play better. To me, that is what the signature skill "Floor General" is for, but ratings shouldn't be affected because a player gets better looks, he should be able to do the same things at the same level, but be in better positions and situations so he can utilize the things he does best more and better.

[Wildcats302]

Quote: Originally Posted by OTCU

This year proved that rose isn't as valuable to the bulls success as many thought during his MVP year

They lost in the 1st round to the 8 seed without him, going 1-4 in games he did not play in.

Yeah they went 17-9 in the regular season without him but that does not prove he is not important LONG TERM for them. I doubt you see them do very well until he comes back this coming season.