NEW 2K13 PROJECT TO KEEP THE PHILOSOPHY OF 2K5 ratings

[mika77]

the 2K5 Offensive linemen (T, G , C) http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sport...ne_x.htm#chart

[mika77]

the 2K5 defensive backs (S and CB): http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sport...ks_x.htm#chart

[mika77]

the 2K5 backers (ILB and OLB) http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sport...rs_x.htm#chart

[mika77]

the 2K5 DE and DT : http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sport...ne_x.htm#chart

[mika77]

now we have a good picture of the top 25 2k5 players for each position, we need now to find a pattern for these guys in checking what rating did they have on the game...

[mika77]

here is the nba 2k series rating guideline , let's see if we can translate it to the Nfl 2k series , i'm waiting your propositions guys :

RATING GUIDE
95-99: Goats (Greatest of All-Time. Not the animal.)
90-94: Superstar (All-NBA First Team mainstays)
85-89: Perennial All-Star (All-NBA Second Team)
80-84: All-Star Caliber (possible All-Stars or even All-NBA Third Team)
75-79: Average NBA Starter (or Sixth Man of Year contenders)
70-74: Below Average Starter (or typical 6th/7th men)
65-69: Rotation Player (8th-10th men)
60-64: End of Bench (11th-15th men and most D-League callups)
55-59: Should not be in NBA (i.e. training camp invites w/ non-guaranteed deals)
50-54: Hopefully earned their college degree.

[chibears96]

Quote: Originally Posted by mika77

i've found this wich is a pretty good base for categorizing 2k13 players : they rate the best 1000 players and they give their respective position rank too. it pretty accurate and realistic... cdn.bleacherreport.net/documents/br_nfl_1000.pdf

Yes I used this somewhat when editing my rosters though his ratings are out there sometimes like calling Sproles the best RB in the league, but still reliable. You should ask Gillbold for permission to use his rosters as a base since you can use his in franchise, and starting from scratch is a daunting task.

[mika77]

thanks to the NBA 2K series rating guideline and after looking at the official NFL 2k5 player ratings i have been able to define a rating guideline for NFL 2K5. Keep in mind i want to stick with the original philosophy .

95-99 Greatest of all Time ( future all of famer without a doubt)
90-94 superstar, multiple time probowl
85-89 star , pro bowl alternate
80-84 above average starter
75-79 average starter and 1st round rookies
70-74 below average starter , above average backup(starter potential) and situationnal role player (nickel, 3rd down pass rusher) 2nd round rookies
60-69 average backup (2nd team) and 3/4 round rookies
50-59 below average backup (3rd team) and 5/6 round rookies
40-49 end of bench, practice squad player , 7th round and undrafted rookies

once again , i wanted a realistic rating guideline sticking with the original 2k5 philosophy.

any thoughts?