Home
Feature Article
Madden NFL 09: Ups and Downs

So how many of you have bought into the madness? Are you all pressed up against the windows, your breath fogging up the glass, your eyes all sad and puppy dog-like, whimpering for the clock to strike 12 on August 12th? Has the EA Sports marketing hype machine injected that sweet addictive substance straight into your veins, making us a gaggle of itching, drooling junkies hungry for that late-summer fix?

I must confess, I used to be among you. Not an August would pass that I wouldn’t get that tingly sensation in my belly, with my thumbs feeling somehow sad and alone. Even with NCAA Football releasing only a short few weeks prior to Madden, that game usually could not quench my ravenous thirst for football video gaming. Now, however, things have changed.

While Madden’s release used to signal the time for NCAA to begin its somber chore of dust collection, it is now barely a blip on my radar.

Perhaps it is that I have grown older, reaching the creaky age of 27. Perhaps it is that now I live in a quiet apartment, as opposed to a 1,400 square foot ranch filled with liquor-fueled shenanigans on Francis Drive in a certain land of ‘Paign. Perhaps it is that my life is now dominated by a rigorous and stress-filled routine that often exceeds the normal five-day 8 a.m.-5 p.m. time clock, rather than 12-hour-a-week class schedule that includes Fridays and Mondays off. Perhaps it is because, for whatever reason, I now prefer the college game to the NFL. Or finally, it might just be because Madden NFL has lost its luster.

For the past couple of years, I have failed to find that giddy inner child that used to dominate my psyche every second week of August. While Madden’s release used to signal the time for NCAA to begin its somber chore of dust collection, it is now barely a blip on my radar. Don’t get me wrong, I will shuffle into my local Gamestop next week and lay down three Andrew Jacksons for this year’s installment, but I won’t break the sound barrier racing home for a five-hour freak-out session.

Despite my new-found sense of apathy, I cannot ignore Madden 09’s brash boasts of 85 new features, set to right the recent wrongs of next-gen Madden offerings. Are they enough to re-invigorate my since-faded love affair with the NFL’s only video gaming option? Time will tell. Here are some features I find promising, and others that might have the same appeal of tightly-coiled piles my neighbor’s dog leaves on the sidewalk.


Madden NFL 09 isn't out yet and we know there definitely needs to be a roster update upon release.

 

The Ups: Adaptive AI

Last year’s NHL 08 marked my return to hockey gaming after a four year hiatus -- and my experience couldn’t have been better. The right-thumbstick control scheme had a lot to do with my delight, but not so much as the Adaptive AI system. No longer could I attack with the same mind-numbing strategy of one-timers across the slot. I also could not to check my way out of odd-man rushes every time.
Money plays have long been the scourge of sports video games, and historically all of our favorites have suffered from this flaw.

If Madden’s new Adaptive AI system is as remarkable as that of its hockey step brother, we might be in for a very big treat. Money plays have long been the scourge of sports video games, and historically all of our favorites have suffered from this flaw. The old NHL games suffered from hyper-effective wrap-arounds and wristers while cutting across the slot. The NFL 2K series failed to address out-routes and sweeps as legitimate offensive threats. And finally, any defense in Madden has failed miserably to stop the roll-out deep corner combo, even in the most recent editions.

Hopefully, Madden 09’s new system will cure this malignant vexation for the football gaming genre, and do so for the foreseeable future. Here’s hoping this system might find its way into NCAA Football 2010 as well.

The Ups: Old-School Uniforms


In the grand scheme of things, this is a minor detail. But for those of us who were part of the last-generation orientation, the re-inclusion of old-school alternate uniforms is something to stand up and applaud.

While the on-field attire is ultimately insignificant when compared to the overall gameplay, the return of past and alternate uniforms is somehow symbolic (at least to me) that EA Sports may be hearing our collective groans about stripped-down next-gen, and have finally decided to appease those who help line its pockets every summer.

The Ups: Online Leagues

Hot on the heels of NCAA 09’s Online Dynasty (problems or not), Madden 09 aims to please the online community with online leagues, allowing up to 32 users to compete in a season.

For those of us who have tired of the drudgery of Madden online drawbacks, this new system could very well breathe new life into the dullness of quick matches and lobby searching. Thankfully, I will no longer have to satisfy my need for human competition against the Patriots or Colts every single time. I mean, seriously.


Madden NFL 09 will be here next week, but is it a huge event nowadays?

The Downs: Online Leagues


So why the duality when it comes to one of Madden’s biggest features? Online leagues are set to completely overhaul Madden’s tired online experience. The only reason I list online leagues as a negative, is that they are not online franchises.

Although online franchise is the obvious next step, it is unfortunate that it did not make this year’s game. I get that old tingly feeling when I think about importing a draft class from my online dynasty into my online franchise. Sounds wonderful, does it not?

The Downs: Rewind

Beating a dead horse here, I know. But still, I cannot shy away from a chance to throw grenades at the general direction at this abomination.
I just find it bothersome that actual dollars were spent in developing something that appeals to a fringe audience before the game was perfected for the core following.

I am from the school of thought, that sports video games were made with the avid sports fan designated as the target market. From Tecmo Bowl to Madden, we have always seen games become more complicated, more realistic, and thus, increasingly satisfying. The Rewind feature in 09 is a step in the wrong direction, robbing the game of its true sense of sports simulation.

Yes, I know all the arguments. You do not have to use it; it won’t be available online; etc, etc. I just find it bothersome that actual dollars were spent in developing something that appeals to a fringe audience before the game was perfected for the core following. Just my opinion.

The Downs: I’m a Pessimist


This really is not the fault of EA Sports' developers, but then again, maybe it is. My expectations have been set so triumphantly low, that even a braggadocios list of 85 new features sounds like a lot of smoke and mirrors. In fact, after scrutinizing the list, it sounds like these “features” should be rightfully named “improvements” or “upgrades.” With as many problems as NCAA 09 experienced, I cannot help but be skeptical about such a vast list of potential tweaks.

Whatever the reason for my dispirited nature, I will still be among the masses trekking to Gamestop to lighten my wallet in honor of the EA Gods next Tuesday. Good or bad, at the very least, Madden 09 will be a temporary diversion from watching Brett Favre updates.


Madden NFL 09 Videos
Member Comments
# 21 ewto16 @ 08/08/08 10:39 AM
Should have mentioned that EA left out in-game saves, which would make the game much more enjoyable for us that have lives and wives.
 
# 22 labguy @ 08/08/08 10:47 AM
"The only reason I list online leagues as a negative, is that they are not online franchises. Although online franchise is the obvious next step, it is unfortunate that it did not make this year’s game. I get that old tingly feeling when I think about importing a draft class from my online dynasty into my online franchise. Sounds wonderful, does it not?"

AMEN brother! I could not have said it better! Online leagues are half-***! EA needs to deliver the goods on a full online franchise mode! The league feature wouldn't feel like such an insult except the fact every board or forum I have been a part of for the last few years has been clamoring for a online franchise mode. It's like EA just hasn't been listening. Hopefully that has changed.
 
# 23 asu666 @ 08/08/08 12:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cdon2k
Thanks for bringing up NCAA in the comments of a Madden article.
You're welcome. The two go hand-in-hand for me because I like to alternate seasons and import my draft class from NCAA. That being the case, if NCAA has problems, then it hurts Madden too. For me, they are two halves of the same game. I would like to thank you for your useful comment about pointing out my comment.
 
# 24 mwjr @ 08/08/08 12:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wil McCombs
Yes, I know all the arguments. You do not have to use it; it won’t be available online; etc, etc. I just find it bothersome that actual dollars were spent in developing something that appeals to a fringe audience before the game was perfected for the core following. Just my opinion.
First of all, great article. Excellent points that reflect my position on Madden. I used to be a release-purchaser of both NCAA and Madden. No more.

I see your point regarding the rewind feature. But I usually won't fault a company for trying out a new feature like this AS LONG AS IT DOES NOT TAKE RESOURCES AWAY FROM OTHER, MORE IMPORTANT FEATURES OF THE GAME
 
# 25 mwjr @ 08/08/08 12:31 PM
Oops. I hit enter too soon.

As I was saying...

I see your point regarding the rewind feature. But I usually won't fault a company for trying out a new feature like this AS LONG AS IT DOES NOT TAKE RESOURCES AWAY FROM OTHER, MORE IMPORTANT FEATURES OF THE GAME

But therein lies the problem: we don't know what else they could be doing.

One of the features from the Triple Play baseball series, an otherwise crappy video gaming experience, that I liked was the option to select either an Arcade style of play or a Simulation style of play. I wish like hell that EA would adapt this feature to its football titles. This 'rewind' feature would be a great aspect of an Arcade play style. It does appear that, as you pointed out, Will, this feature can be turned off. In that regards, kudos to EA.

The problem is that these arcade aspects have seeped their ways into the gameplay of the mainstream gameplay action. Case in point: the inability to play a solid game along the defensive line in the NCAA 09. EA appears to have opted for a more arcade-ish style of gameplay (i.e. wide-open gameplay), allowing the offense to dominate, as opposed to a more sim-style gameplay, which would appeal to folks like myself who are die-hard football fans.

Why must it be an either/or proposition? Why not make these arcade-like features and gamplay options, as opposed to the standards??

These are a few of the reasons why I'm no longer a release-day purchaser.
 
# 26 acarrero @ 08/08/08 01:44 PM
Does everyone have problems defending the roll-out passing in both NCAA and Madden? I hear so much complaining about this and i don't get it. I love when an opponent tries that against me - all you have to prevent is the QB from rolling out, and you do that easily by blitizing from both sides, or blitzing from one side and taking over the DE on the other side and rushing out as far as possible to make the other player either run into the blitz or have to try to dodge you - which is hard if you're using a good DE. It works agaist Pat White, so it can work against any QB. Of course, if the opposing player only does this once in a while, it will be harder to contain because you will get burned if you blitz every play, but if their offense is based on scrambling out of the pocket and throwing on the run, then you should welcome that kind of offense because it's easy to contain.
 
# 27 ibis @ 08/08/08 05:29 PM
i have been playing madden since 92 when I purchased it for my sega genesis. I am now 33 and this is the first year I have not been excited about this franchise. The past 2 iterations of the game have killed it for me. I can expect game issues but EA's inability to correct these issues in a timely manner and to make matters worse their horrible communication with the community.

Based on what I have seen this year and the Issues with NCAA, EA has done a great job at communicating and is even working on patches. With that being said, i am optimistic that this is the year EA gets their ish together and brings back some excitement I felt many years ago.
 
# 28 slavestate13 @ 08/08/08 07:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hndavis
yall need to stop hatin on madden..like for real this is the best pro football game out since the 80's hands down..madden is the king of football gaming and video games itself..im going to be one fo those ppl wating in line at midnite wating for madden hopefully ill even sneak out of my moms house idc..i love madden and its all i play

When someone starts a sentence off with "ya'll", I don't even read the rest of the post. Is it just me?
 
# 29 asu666 @ 08/08/08 08:30 PM
Just think, with a lot of hard work and a little luck, Madden NFL may one day be almost as good as NFL 2K5 was four years ago. Did I mention it was only $20 new too.

Anyway, it looks like this year's Madden is going to be a decent jump over last year's. I ended up messing around with the original Xbox version of NCAA and Madden last year because there were so many missing features in the current gen versions. I'd still take a high def version of NFL 2K5 over this year's Madden on current gen consoles, but I'm looking forward to playing this year's Madden too. I hope it is a step in the right direction. I'm getting the LE version because I am looking forward to Head Couch's comback. I was very disappointed with the retail release of NCAA this year, but I think Madden will give me some hope going into 2010 for a solid football offering from EA on both the college and pro fronts.
 
# 30 db56 @ 08/10/08 02:34 PM
32 years old, married for 11 years with 2 sons 7 and 3 and get absolutely stoked for the release of Madden every year, although the game is far from perfect. playing Madden every year is just an integral part of my life, I need counseling. Go Broncos! Go Hawkeyes!
 
# 31 Herky @ 08/10/08 03:35 PM
31 years old and the past two years Madden has made me cringe on release day for the next gen.

I remember the days when I didn't have to worry about EA releasing a half *** version of Madden.
 
# 32 Kramer5150 @ 08/10/08 04:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hndavis
yall need to stop hatin on madden..like for real this is the best pro football game out since the 80's hands down..madden is the king of football gaming and video games itself..im going to be one fo those ppl wating in line at midnite wating for madden hopefully ill even sneak out of my moms house idc..i love madden and its all i play
 
# 33 xV3L0CiTY @ 08/10/08 05:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VikingFan4Ever
31 years old and the past two years Madden has made me cringe on release day for the next gen.

I remember the days when I didn't have to worry about EA releasing a half *** version of Madden.
Man...I miss those days...
 
# 34 Stroehms @ 08/10/08 05:50 PM
EA needs to find a balance between the defense and the offense. The O is too powerful and the (CPU) defense can't even produce a 3 and out for the user once in awhile. Here's an idea:

Bring in a momentum engine.

Where if the opposing D creates a big stop or stops the Offense to give them good field position, the engine would give the (CPU or even user) team momentum, thus going on a lengthy drive (eating up the clock or even scoring).
 
# 35 texbuk84 @ 08/13/08 05:26 AM
great read. i really like this years madden though. they need to do something about the server and people quitting the games early. instead of playing the computer who are super cheats, they need to let us get the win.
 
# 36 ChubbyBanana @ 08/13/08 09:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMD
Ha, older gamers, you guys are babies at 27, Talk to me when you're in your late 40's like I am. Every year at this time I'm like a 5 year old waiting for Christmas morning. First I look forward to the new Madden game and second I can't wait for the first Sunday that kicks off the NFL season. Football kicks ***.
I guess you got me there.

What I meant to say is that I feel old when I stand in a midnight release line with 17 year olds knocking each other's hats off their heads and chasing each other around the parking lot.

That's what I meant to say. No offense to any really "old" gamers.
 

« Previous 12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.