Home
Feature Article
MLB 14 The Show: The Best Lineups

Today I want to look at, what I think are, the best starting lineups in MLB and therefore in MLB 14: The Show. We're going to focus on the top five most dangerous lineups to face as a pitcher. We'll look at the strengths and also any potential weaknesses of the lineups. So without further ado, let's go!

5. New York Yankees – With an off-season shopping spree in New York that included new starting pitcher Masahiro Tanaka, the Bronx Bombers also spent a lot of money to improve their starting lineup. The additions of Jacoby Ellsbury, Carlos Beltran, Brian McCann and Brian Roberts headline the improvements. Here is the Yankees 2014 starting lineup, as projected by ZIPS on March 3, 2014.

OF Jacoby Ellsbury
SS Derek Jeter
OF Carlos Beltran
1B Mark Teixeira
C Brain McCann
DH Alfonso Soriano
OF Brett Gardner
3B Kelly Johnson
2B Brian Roberts

That leaves Ichiro Suzuki as the best pinch hitter off the bench. That's a pretty good lineup when you consider what kind of season each player is capable of having. Obviously the departure of Robinson Cano leaves a huge void. The addition of Brian Roberts adds gap-to-gap power, but can't possibly make up for the power and RBI ability that Cano brought. Curtis Granderson also departs while Ellsbury comes over to fill his offensive void. The loss of Alex Rodriguez's bat can't be ignored. Kelly Johnson will have his hands full trying to produce at the hot corner.

4. Los Angeles Angels – This off-season saw the addition of Raul Ibanez, David Freese, and Carlos Pena to a roster that was already a nightmare for opposing pitchers. Every baseball fan knows Mike Trout, but so much of this team's fortunes rely on Albert Pujols and Josh Hamilton having strong campaigns. Last year, this team looked poised to set offensive records, but Pujols was bogged down by injuries, and Hamilton's numbers were down across the board. Here is the Angels 2014 starting lineup, as projected by ZIPS on March 3, 2014.

SS Erick Aybar
OF Mike Trout
1B Albert Pujols
OF Josh Hamilton
3B David Freese
DH Raul Ibanez
2B Howie Kendrick
OF Kole Calhoun
C Chris Iannetta

That makes Pena the best option off the bench for a pinch-hit at bat. If everyone plays as well as they are capable of, the Angels will be underrated at No. 4 on this list. The departure of Mark Trumbo certainly hurts from a loss of power perspective, but the Angels hope the 42-year-old Ibanez can fill that void. Top prospect Kole Calhoun also looks to make a splash for the Halos, as he's expected to be an everyday player.

3. Atlanta Braves – While the Atlanta Braves didn't make any significant additions to the lineup for 2014 -- and they loss of McCann -- this team still has the potential to be one of the best lineups in all of baseball. Much of that will depend on the ability of Evan Gattis to play every day behind the plate, and the capability of both B.J. and Justin Upton to have bounce-back seasons after struggling in 2013. The Braves have potentially, one of the best outfields in the big leagues. Chris Johnson's emergence last season at third base helped soften the blow from the retirement of Chipper Jones, and Freddie Freeman is becoming one of the best young hitters in the game. Here is the Braves 2014 starting lineup, as projected by ZIPS on March 3, 2014.

OF Jason Heyward
OF Justin Upton
1B Freddie Freeman
C Evan Gattis
3B Chris Johnson
SS Andrelton Simmons
2B Dan Uggla
OF B.J. Upton
Pitcher's Spot

That leaves Ryan Doumit as the the first option off the bench for Atlanta. Jason Heyward's health will also be a hot topic for Braves fans. This lineup has everything you fear if you are an opposing pitcher: Great L/R balance, power and speed. If Andrelton Simmons continues to improve as he's expected to, this lineup gets that much scarier as an opposing pitcher. Uggla is a bit all-or-nothing in his approach but he can give you that homer you need in the clutch.

2. Baltimore Orioles – Very few teams in MLB can match this lineup on paper. The addition of Nelson Cruz and Delmon Young to an already stacked roster should sound air raid alarms for opposing pitchers. Third baseman Manny Machado had a horrific injury late last season, but he's expected to make a full recovery and be back for the 2014 season at some point. That's great news for any fan of baseball. Looking over this lineup, there are no real holes if they get healthy and stay healthy. Here is the Orioles starting lineup, as projected by ZIPS as of March 3, 2014.

OF Nick Markakis
3B Ryan Flaherty
1B Chris Davis
OF Adam Jones
OF Nelson Cruz
C Matt Wieters
SS J.J. Hardy
DH Nolan Reimold
2B Jemile Weeks

That leaves Young as the best bat off the bench. Once Machado heals and joins the lineup, Flaherty will also be a great bench bat. Chris “Crush” Davis has potential to go after the home run record again this season with the added protection of Cruz in the lineup. One of the weaknesses of this lineup, lack of speed, was somewhat addressed with the addition of Jemile Weeks. He and Adam Jones still represent the only real speed threats on the bases for Baltimore and that's a potential problem. Baltimore has strong roster depth, and once Machado is healthy, they will be a force to be reckoned with.

1. Los Angeles Dodgers – When you're lineup is so stacked that Matt Kemp could actually come off the bench, you know you have one of the best lineups in baseball. The Dodgers made headlines last season with the additions of Adrian Gonzalez, Carl Crawford, and Hanley Ramirez and the emergence of rookie phenom Yasiel Puig. This season doesn't bring the same roster turnover excitement and the Dodgers main players are now known commodities. However, the money was spent and this team is loaded with stars. Let's look at the Dodgers 2014 starting lineup, as projected by ZIPS on March 3, 2014.

OF Yasiel Puig
OF Carl Crawford
SS Hanley Ramirez
1B Adrian Gonzalez
OF Matt Kemp
3B Juan Uribe
C A.J. Ellis
Pitcher's Spot

That leaves Andre Either to platoon in the outfield and be maybe the best bench bat in the league assuming that Kemp does start, as ZIPS projects. Seriously, where is the weakness here? Speed? Check. Power? Check. Guys that can get on base and set the table? Check! The Dodgers are one of the favorites to make it to the World Series in 2014, and the amazing starting pitching isn't the only reason. This lineup looks like an All-Star team and Uribe is a very capable hitter (ZIPS projects a .293 average this season). Only the very best pitchers in Major League Baseball will be able to consistently compete with this starting lineup.

1a. Texas Rangers – When a playoff team that was in the World Series two seasons ago goes out in the off-season and adds Prince Fielder, Shin-Soo Choo, and J.P. Arencibia you know they are serious about winning it all. Considering the Rangers already had one of the most feared lineups in all of baseball last season, this season's edition is legit scary. Texas lost Ian Kinsler in the trade to acquire Fielder, but they have Jurickson Profar armed and ready to take over at second base full time in 2014. Mitch Moreland will be a strong and steady DH. The loss of Nelson Cruz will be more than made up for by Choo and Fielder's added production. This is in my opinion, the best lineup in MLB. Here is the Rangers 2014 starting lineup, as projected by ZIPS on March 3, 2014.

OF Shin-Soo Choo
SS Elvis Andrus
1B Prince Fielder
3B Adrian Beltre
OF Alex Rios
DH Mitch Moreland
C Geovany Soto
2B Jurickson Profar
OF Leonys Martin

Wow. That leaves Texas with Michael Choice and J.P. Arencibia as option 1a and 1b off the bench. Power, speed, a great mix of veterans and younger players, hitting from both sides of the plate, I mean how do you attack this lineup? Alex Rios seems to be back in form if last season's run with the Rangers is any indication and Choo brings an incredible ability to get on base whether by hitting, taking a walk, or being hit by pitch.


OK, so I cheated and gave you six lineups. I honestly can't decide which lineup is more dangerous; the Dodgers or the Rangers? So Operation Sports, help me out. Which offensive starting lineup do you think is the best? Dodgers or Rangers? Or maybe I totally missed the mark and one of the other teams has the most dangerous lineup?

You tell me, sound off in the comments and let me know what I missed!


MLB 14 The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 21 GruffyMcGuiness @ 03/07/14 11:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShowTyme15
Dee Gordon has been playing well this spring and is probably going to win the job. Guerrero is starting to hit, but needs work on Defense.
You know who had a good spring last year? BJ Upton.
 
# 22 HustlinOwl @ 03/07/14 11:57 PM
Upton and Uggla in same lineup in top 5?
 
# 23 GruffyMcGuiness @ 03/08/14 12:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HustlinOwl
Upton and Uggla in same lineup in top 5?
Yeah, the one with Heyward, Upton, Freeman and Johnson.
 
# 24 cardinalbird5 @ 03/08/14 12:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HustlinOwl
Upton and Uggla in same lineup in top 5?
Yeah I don't get it. They pretty much made no changes and were a slightly above average lineup. I mean it isn't bad, but it has tons of holes after the 5 hole.

Dodgers have a good lineup on paper, but once again only ranked 7th last year in the NL. So unless Kemp comes back strong and they find a place for all 4 OF's, I don't see them being a top 5 offense.

Orioles I can agree with and Texas I definitely agree with. Detroit and St. Louis should be in there, IMO too. The Tigers have the best hitter in baseball and the Cards have so much depth it is unreal. We only lost Beltran, but we also have Craig/Adams healthy and Tavaras coming up.

Boston should be in there as well. They don't have a sexy lineup, but they grind AB's and know how to get on base.
 
# 25 True Talent @ 03/08/14 12:31 AM
The O's had a a pretty good lineup last year, could be better this year.

They were in the 5th in runs, 8th in hits, 5th in doubles, 1st in HR (by 24), 3rd in total bases, 5th in RBI, 10th in AVG, 3rd in SLG %, and 4th in OPS.

I don't expect Davis to have a year like he did last year, but you never know, I think Machado will be better offensively (he should be back for opening day, and if not, very soon after, Flaherty will be at second), and Cruz at DH should be better than anything they stuck there last season.
 
# 26 cardinalbird5 @ 03/08/14 12:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GruffyMcGuiness
Yeah, the one with Heyward, Upton, Freeman and Johnson.
You guys virtually made no changes, except losing Mccann. Do you think you guys have a top 5 lineup?

Maybe I guess they overrate Uggla and BJ in the game, but I don't see it lol. Simmons, Uggla, and BJ are pretty terrible hitters.

Also the Angels are extremely overrated. I loved Freese, but the guy was below average last year. Pujols might bounce back, but who knows? That lineup is not a top 5 lineup.
 
# 27 GruffyMcGuiness @ 03/08/14 12:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cardinalbird7
You guys virtually made no changes, except losing Mccann. Do you think you guys have a top 5 lineup?

Maybe I guess they overrate Uggla and BJ in the game, but I don't see it lol. Simmons, Uggla, and BJ are pretty terrible hitters.

Also the Angels are extremely overrated. I loved Freese, but the guy was below average last year. Pujols might bounce back, but who knows? That lineup is not a top 5 lineup.
#1 in homers last year and 3rd in runs. McCann had his worst year yet and was hurt much of the year.

I keep seeing you bash Simmons' hitting. You do realize before halfway through last season, he had played a total of 44 games above A ball? He hit 17 homers and had an average BA for a SS. I see his hitting as FAR from terrible.
 
# 28 CaseIH @ 03/08/14 01:34 AM
Im suprised the Cardinals arent in this list. They were the best clutch hitting team in baseball last season, and by a large margin. I cant imagine them putting up those types of numbers again in the clutch, but they will still be a pain to deal with daily. On paper they might have actually gotten better this year, cause they no longer have a weak hitting ss.

I dont like giving the Cardinals any credit and wish they would play Cubs baseball, but it is what it is, the Cards are the best ran organization in baseball. Not only should they be in everybody's top 5 offensive teams, they should be in everyones top 5 teams overall.

The Yankees were my dads team so they are my 2n favorite team, but I wouldnt put then in the top 5 offensive teams in baseball. Roberts will probably have a season ending injury before Opening day or shortly after, as that seems to be his routine yearly,lol.
 
# 29 HustlinOwl @ 03/08/14 02:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GruffyMcGuiness
Yeah, the one with Heyward, Upton, Freeman and Johnson.
lol Johnson
 
# 30 cardinalbird5 @ 03/08/14 06:32 AM
This will be the cards lineup:

Carpenter-3b
Peralta-SS
Holliday-LF
Craig-RF
Adams-1B
Molina-C
Jay-CF
Wong-2B

Bench:
Robinson
Cruz
Bourjous
Ellis
Tavaras (at some point)

Someone prove to me that isn't a top 5 lineup lol

I also think Milwaukee is flying under the radar, but I wouldn't consider them a top 5 lineup.

It really depends on how SCEA rates some of our players. They never updated Adams to what he should have been last year, but they were all over Gattis and Puig.
 
# 31 HouseofSuhs @ 03/08/14 11:09 AM
Tigers lineup is better than the Yankees.
 
# 32 GruffyMcGuiness @ 03/08/14 11:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HustlinOwl
lol Johnson
Yeah, you're right. Second best batting average in the NL sucks when discussing best lineups.
 
# 33 MrChainsaw @ 03/08/14 01:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman18
He's referring to the fact that the author left out the Dodgers 2nd baseman completely from his list
Haha yep.
 
# 34 mb625 @ 03/08/14 02:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mikeq672
Everyone thinks their team should be higher, shocker. It is very easy to pick apart any team on any persons list.

The sox shouldnt be on here as they lost their table setter in Ellsbury, Victorino is due for regression, youre starting two young unproven guys at third and short, another in center, its doubtful Daniel Nava repeats, Pierzynski cant be any better than Salty was. Ortiz is going to eventually breakdown.

See how easy that was?
I don't think my team should be higher. The Twins are going to be awful. LOL.

Anyway, I think that Choo signing was one of the most underrated signings of the off-season. To me, with all they added, that makes the Rangers my pick to win the AL.
 
# 35 HustlinOwl @ 03/08/14 02:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GruffyMcGuiness
Yeah, you're right. Second best batting average in the NL sucks when discussing best lineups.
last year an anomaly
 
# 36 GruffyMcGuiness @ 03/08/14 02:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HustlinOwl
last year an anomaly
Guess you can say the same with BJ then, huh?
 
# 37 cardinalbird5 @ 03/08/14 02:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mb625
I don't think my team should be higher. The Twins are going to be awful. LOL.

Anyway, I think that Choo signing was one of the most underrated signings of the off-season. To me, with all they added, that makes the Rangers my pick to win the AL.
I agree. The Rangers lineup is going to be nasty. They deserve to be in the top 5 lineups for sure.

BJ was no anomly. He might not do as bad, but I don't see him doing anything productive.

Johnson isn't an anomly so to speak. He might not hit for that high of an average again, but he still will be a .280+ .330+ OBP .780+ OPS type of guy. His line LD pct was pretty good last year so even though he had a high BABIP, it was due to him making good contact and not so much luck. However he does strikeout a decent amount and doesn't draw too many walks. He isn't no top tier hitter by any means though. I'd say just a solid hitter.

Braves have a solid lineup, but I just don't see it justified being in the top 5. We won't know till the game comes out though.

I know currently with the last updated rosters (even with McCann) their lineup is ranked like 10th or so.
 
# 38 Grnngld @ 03/08/14 02:43 PM
Not surprised to see no love for the team that scored the 4th most runs in the league last year, finished 3rd in OPS and tied for 3rd in wRC+. Of course, the A's do it with platoons and maximize production from every spot in the roster; other teams do it with big names and are thus more noticeable.

Anyways, I don't think the A's necessarily have a top 5 lineup this year but hopefully in the Show, they are at least top 10 instead of being ranked at the bottom half of lineups as they usually are.
 
# 39 cardinalbird5 @ 03/08/14 03:13 PM
The Indians and A's could make an argument, but I think what holds them back is the DH. If they were in the NL, would be a superior offensive team? I am not sure who Oakland's primary DH will be (Moss, Jaso?), but Cleveland uses Santana at DH.
 
# 40 mikeq672 @ 03/08/14 03:46 PM
People love hating on the Braves. They scored the 3rd most runs in the NL lasty year, only St Louis and Colorado ahead of them, and return the same lineup. Mccann sucked outside of one good month. Jupton, Heyward, Freeman, and Simmons will all take strides being young talented players. BJ cant be any worse. Uggla will be replaced by May by someone more productive.

The Cards are prolly a better lineup, but theyll regress some, that average with RISP is due to come back down to earth. Dodgers are good, lot of question marks. Rockies will score runs, but partly because of Coors.
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.