FIFA 17 News Post

FIFA 17 Review

06:35 PM - September 24, 2016 by Steve_OS

It’s 2 a.m. and I’ve been playing FIFA 17's new mode ‘The Journey’ for the past five hours. Well, at least I think it's 2 a.m. -- I’m far too hooked by the mode's addictive qualities to look at my phone. Alex Hunter’s tale is an intriguing one, and my personal mission to achieve glory as a member of the AFC Bournemouth squad has engulfed my interest.

I don’t want to venture elsewhere, but there's more to discover. After I've sampled its entire feature set, I come to realize that FIFA 17 is somewhat of a divided experience on the pitch –- a game of two halves, if you will. While it succeeds in creating a primarily authentic experience against the CPU, it undoes a lot of that work when more users get involved, fluctuating between arcade and simulation tendencies along the way.

Read More - FIFA 17 Review (Written by: Fraser Gilbert)

Game: FIFA 17Reader Score: Vote Now
Platform: PC / PS3 / PS4 / Xbox 360 / Xbox OneVotes for game: 0 - View All

Member Comments

# 1 michaelhawj @ 09/24/16 06:44 PM

nice score : 8. i see career mode unchanged.. shame on EA for being lazy to improve better in career mode.. 2ksports are best at add more features and improve My GM/League. i don't know if it worth playing

# 2 Gleebo @ 09/24/16 08:05 PM

Im in love with PES 17 but I was ready to buy both this year but this review has turned me away.

"Another thing that lets it down is its lack of personality. If it weren’t for the immersive levels of presentation, it'd be easy to forget who you were up against. Every team tends to play in a similar fashion, and the lack of diversity becomes evident in no time."

Same reason I skipped NHL 17 this year....

# 3 Lovesports @ 09/25/16 12:58 AM

I think a lot of what you're referring to as far as multiplayer gameplay goes has to do with the way people play online. Most of the people I play online have a very attack oriented game style and no matter how you make the game it'll never feel as if you're playing the CPU.

I actually bought PES17 and it's a good game but I found myself playing the FIFA demo literally hours after purchase. FIFA in my opinion is a more complete game and I feel more immersed playing it. Frostbite has done wonders for the game visually. The lighting, player sweat, facial expressions are on point. I don't agree with the score of an 8 unless you're planning on giving PES 17 a 7. I'm a PES guy for the record but for the first time ever, the graphic detail for FIFA doesn't feel cartoonish and the game plays beautifully. I give it a solid 9 and PES an 8.

# 4 WALTERBERRYPAOK @ 09/25/16 04:23 AM

PES 17 is fun and everything, but as an XBOX ONE owner it would be silly to pick this over FIFA 17.Through the years i bounced between the two games but since FIFA 12 i loved the simulation style of gameplay, the footplanting, the animations, the physics and collisions and of course, the integration of the league licences.If the British Premier League is your favorite, then this game will blow you away. The way players move, the AMAZING SHIELDING of the ball, makes this game so realistic and strategic on high difficult levels!! Also, there are so many things that happen on the pitch that PES 17 would only dream of. Great referees, fair play, pushing fouls when defending a player that shields the ball, player emotions, incredible goalkeeper deflections that feels and are non-scripted, a ton of animations for every little thing, when the ball carrier is near the corner, protecting the ball and you place the defender near him, he adjusts his stance and the tackle animations change accordingly, the corner kicks are totally new because of the ball having more weight and players pushing and pulling, MANUAL CURVED SHOTS and i could continue the list for ever.
I am not a fifa fanboy. I just love football.I want my game to be even more realistic, every year. Yes, i enjoy PES but compared to FIFA is way to fast and arcadey for my taste.Always comparing the two games with the hardest difficulty, FIFA gives me MORE CONTROL to protect the ball and keep the POSSESION longer. I left the best for last....GAMEPLAY SLIDERS...Like NBA 2K, FIFA has sliders that let's you make the game play the way you want...I read some critics complain about not being able to steal the ball from the CPU. Do they not know that you can increase the PASSING ACCURACY? Or the speed and acceleration of the players and the pass and shot speed so much more? The sliders are the way EASPORTS negates all complains about their game and for me it makes it like a sandbox game. I can go to the extremes and change gameplay 100%.And this is amazing for a company so hated. It gives total freedom, given you have a true passion for the sport, to make EVERY MATCH play the way you want to. If you are a KONAMI fanboy all these may sound strange...

# 5 RogerDodger @ 09/25/16 06:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WALTERBERRYPAOK


	Yes, i enjoy PES but compared to FIFA is way to fast and arcadey for my taste

I see it differently, this year - and I'm only speaking for this year, rather than the past - PES is the more realistic game. But that's just my opinion.

# 6 Lovesports @ 09/25/16 07:54 AM

I agree with Walter. PES is arcadish. Every possession feels like a breakaway.

# 7 Da-Man @ 09/25/16 08:23 AM

Pros- "significant presentation improvements"..... i'm sorry but you couldn't be more wrong here because the Premier League presentation has been significantly downgraded compared to the last two editions. The overlays look like an exhibition match with generic starting lineups and music. This is extremely baffling because EA sports has the license for the premier league and la liga.

# 8 maremas @ 09/25/16 10:25 AM

Great review, this year we have 2 decent games! PES is finally on the right spot!

# 9 KG @ 09/25/16 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maremas


	Great review, this year we have 2 decent games! PES is finally on the right spot!

Shameless plug but FIFA & PES fans should really check out your Youtube videos. I've been using them for years:

https://www.youtube.com/user/mzivhotmail

Thanks for all the hard work and welcome to OS!

# 10 baseballguy @ 09/25/16 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Da-Man


	Pros- "significant presentation improvements"..... i'm sorry but you couldn't be more wrong here because the Premier League presentation has been significantly downgraded compared to the last two editions. The overlays look like an exhibition match with generic starting lineups and music. This is extremely baffling because EA sports has the license for the premier league and la liga.

Isn't the Premier League presentation part of a day one patch?

# 11 Moose Factory @ 09/25/16 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve_OS


	The first comes in the form of Squad Builder Challenges. If you wish, you can complete challenges by trading in a select group of players with certain characteristics -- sharing chemistry or differing in nationalities, for example. There are a lot of rewards on offer, and this is something that expands the potential of the mode.

I highly recommend doing some of these squad challenges. I did the gold upgrade one which was basically just trading in non-rare gold players for 2 rare untradeable players and I totally pulled a Messi! Who cares if it's untradeable it's Messi!!! Finally something to do with all those non-rare players that I usually just quick sell anyways.

# 12 Peji911 @ 09/25/16 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lovesports


	I agree with Walter. PES is arcadish. Every possession feels like a breakaway.

LOL... WHAT?????

I think you're confusing the two games. In PES, you can barely pass by someone with a run until it's timed perfectly.

Im willing to bet you never played it. How can you call it 'arcadeish'

# 13 Lovesports @ 09/25/16 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peji911


	LOL... WHAT????? I think you're confusing the two games. In PES, you can barely pass by someone with a run until it's timed perfectly. Im willing to bet you never played it. How can you call it 'arcadeish'

I have it dumb dumb. And typically I prefer it over FIFA. However, that stuff you're talking about with the runs, pure nonsense.

# 14 SCB1990 @ 09/25/16 09:38 PM

The writer of this review is clearly not a "real football fan".

# 15 extremeskins04 @ 09/25/16 10:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peji911


	LOL... WHAT????? I think you're confusing the two games. In PES, you can barely pass by someone with a run until it's timed perfectly. Im willing to bet you never played it. How can you call it 'arcadeish'

Last year PES was extremely arcadish. Not sure what you're talking about. I haven't played this year's version yet but I went back to FIFA last year because in PES, the goalies were too stupid and would let goals just roll by. Hated it.

# 16 TheDutchDad @ 09/25/16 10:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lovesports


	I have it dumb dumb. And typically I prefer it over FIFA. However, that stuff you're talking about with the runs, pure nonsense.

Uh, no. There is no way you have it, or you're just totally lying. PES is in no way arcadey, and in no way can you just sprint past people. Maybe up the difficulty next time if you have indeed played it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by extremeskins04


	Last year PES was extremely arcadish. Not sure what you're talking about. I haven't played this year's version yet but I went back to FIFA last year because in PES, the goalies were too stupid and would let goals just roll by. Hated it.

I'm not sure what you're talking about...last year PES was a number of things, but it still was not an arcade soccer game. The goalies this year in PES are light years ahead of what they were last year. PES 17 is simply one of the best pure soccer games I have ever played, and that's not hyperbull.

Someimes when it comes to people comparing the two, FIFA and PES, I feel like I'm on Planet Crazy cause FIFA fans always claim the most ridiculous things about PES, that don't come close to the truth.

And yes, I have fifa 17, and really enjoy it, but your assessment of PES is far off base.

# 17 extremeskins04 @ 09/25/16 11:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDutchDad


	Uh, no. There is no way you have it, or you're just totally lying. PES is in no way arcadey, and in no way can you just sprint past people. Maybe up the difficulty next time if you have indeed played it. I'm not sure what you're talking about...last year PES was a number of things, but it still was not an arcade soccer game. The goalies this year in PES are light years ahead of what they were last year. PES 17 is simply one of the best pure soccer games I have ever played, and that's not hyperbull. Someimes when it comes to people comparing the two, FIFA and PES, I feel like I'm on Planet Crazy cause FIFA fans always claim the most ridiculous things about PES, that don't come close to the truth. And yes, I have fifa 17, and really enjoy it, but your assessment of PES is far off base.

I think it was more of the goalie AI that killed the game for me last year. I've read some reviews where PES 2017 beats FIFA in the "on the pitch gameplay", but lacks in everything else. To me I need the graphics, the licenses, the career mode, and the gameplay. I need the whole package honestly.

# 18 BSDShoes @ 09/25/16 11:22 PM

Wow I can't believe people call PES arcadey, PES strayed away from that back in 2013 or so (don't remember exactly).

Quote:

Originally Posted by extremeskins04


	I think it was more of the goalie AI that killed the game for me last year. I've read some reviews where PES 2017 beats FIFA in the "on the pitch gameplay", but lacks in everything else. To me I need the graphics, the licenses, the career mode, and the gameplay. I need the whole package honestly.

Master league is one of my favorite career modes in a sports game, it's pretty flexible and I like how the CPU approaches me wanting to trade some of my players, and licenses are easy to fix with option files.

# 19 extremeskins04 @ 09/26/16 12:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BSDShoes


	Wow I can't believe people call PES arcadey, PES strayed away from that back in 2013 or so (don't remember exactly). Master league is one of my favorite career modes in a sports game, it's pretty flexible and I like how the CPU approaches me wanting to trade some of my players, and licenses are easy to fix with option files.

Yea the career modes are my main thing. So Master League is good this year? I liked how FIFA handled the youth training and progression of your youngsters last year. Not sure how Master League is in that aspect.

# 20 Lovesports @ 09/26/16 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDutchDad


	Uh, no. There is no way you have it, or you're just totally lying. PES is in no way arcadey, and in no way can you just sprint past people. Maybe up the difficulty next time if you have indeed played it. I'm not sure what you're talking about...last year PES was a number of things, but it still was not an arcade soccer game. The goalies this year in PES are light years ahead of what they were last year. PES 17 is simply one of the best pure soccer games I have ever played, and that's not hyperbull. Someimes when it comes to people comparing the two, FIFA and PES, I feel like I'm on Planet Crazy cause FIFA fans always claim the most ridiculous things about PES, that don't come close to the truth. And yes, I have fifa 17, and really enjoy it, but your assessment of PES is far off base.

I have it and don't like it as much as FIFA...sorry. I've hated on FIFA for years and didn't feel bad about telling FIFA fanboys that their game was crap. I'm not saying I don't like PES because I do. It plays a good game, I just like the tempo of FIFA better. This isn't an attack on you so stop getting worked up. You don't get a dime from Konami so you can stop your heroic attempts of defending your favorite football game. I like both and this year I'll take FIFA with all the upgrades they've made.

« Previous12 3 Next »

More Links

FIFA 17 Review