Home
NCAA Football 14 News Post


The Southeastern Conference announced today that it will not, as a conference, license its trademarks in the EA Sports NCAA Football video game. This decision does not involve member universities as of yet, as this only involves the SEC conference name and logo.

However, this could be the type of event that opens the flood gates to future defections from the game. While the future of the College Football series looked somewhat on stable ground after EA and the CLC agreed to a three year deal, this news rattles the very foundations and future of the series.

"Each school makes its own individual decision regarding whether or not to license their trademarks for use in the EA Sports game(s)," the SEC said in a statement. "The Southeastern Conference has chosen not to do so moving forward. Neither the SEC, its member universities, nor the NCAA have ever licensed the right to use the name or likeness of any student to EA Sports."

This is another move in response to the Ed O'Bannon case which could end collegiate video games forever given unfavorable rulings from the courts.

Today's news only brings more questions as to the viability of the product going forward.

UPDATE: ESPN's Kristi Dosh is reporting that the Big XII says they have yet to make a decision on the inclusion of their marks in future College Football video games.

UPDATE #2: ESPN is now reporting the Big Ten is out as well.

UPDATE #3: In a statement to Joystiq, a CLC representative said "150 collegiate institutions, including SEC schools, have approved renewal of the EA college football license, to begin with the 2015 edition. As with any licensed product, individual schools continue to make their own decisions."

We are putting in a question with the CLC on whether this means schools can still opt out of the game at any time or not as the wording certainly seems to leave that possibility open.

Update #4: Jeremy Fowler of CBS is reporting that the Pac-12's marks also won't be in the new game.

Game: NCAA Football 14Reader Score: 8/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3 / Xbox 360Votes for game: 54 - View All
NCAA Football 14 Videos
Member Comments
# 341 moose1234 @ 08/15/13 03:20 AM
Can Someone explain me how they can just do this like that . Isn't there some sort of contract in place
 
# 342 wiscowilz @ 08/15/13 06:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by moose1234
Can Someone explain me how they can just do this like that . Isn't there some sort of contract in place
Contract between EA and the conferences??

If there is I would bet it ran out with this game just like NCAAs contract did.
 
# 343 ndfan1993 @ 08/15/13 09:56 AM
Two things of note:

1) This will save me money each year and make it such that I won't want to grab the new console.

2) I know it wouldn't be as fun but could EA not just go the Ultimate team route, renegotiate with the conferences and even the NCAA but just use old rosters with non-active players and negotiate with them individually?
 
# 344 cdawg44 @ 08/15/13 10:09 AM
http://sports.yahoo.com/news/confere...33--ncaaf.html

Big 12 looks to still be in according to Yahoo. The rest of the confrences are "evaluating" the situation
 
# 345 BadAssHskr @ 08/15/13 10:47 AM
I'm surprised there has been no other news, no EA response. I thought i'd be coming in to work today and already have some reading to do.
 
# 346 N51_rob @ 08/15/13 11:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BadAssHskr
I'm surprised there has been no other news, no EA response. I thought i'd be coming in to work today and already have some reading to do.
Perhaps they are still reeling from the announcement, maybe this is just a negotiating tactic from those conferences to get more money? I don't know but there is no way this is a good thing for EA and the future of the NCAA franchise.
 
# 347 JLoco11 @ 08/15/13 11:45 AM
You know that if the NCAA and EA win their argument against O'Bannon, they'll all come rushing back with another game.
 
# 348 jayhawkfan11 @ 08/15/13 11:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cdawg44
http://sports.yahoo.com/news/confere...33--ncaaf.html

Big 12 looks to still be in according to Yahoo. The rest of the confrences are "evaluating" the situation
It doesn't say anywhere in that article that the big 12 is still in... He said "nothing has changed"... I would expect to see all BCS conferences withdrawal by the end of this week...
 
# 349 awill25 @ 08/15/13 01:00 PM
Looking from a glass half full perspective...A lot of folks on here talk about how they wish EA would release the game every 2 years to make sure they get things right. In a perfect world, IF the game is canceled because of the ongoing lawsuit, wouldn't it be nice if EA/NCAA won and EA started with a new build on next gen. I understand Ignite is supposed to be great, but isn't the game supposed to be built with a lot of the same code? Could this process be a blessing in disguise. I understand the NCAA and the conferences are running for cover now, but if they win the lawsuit, then that would end all of our problems. It would also give EA a chance at another build......this is me hoping they would scrap the current one in the meantime...
 
# 350 sbunce5 @ 08/15/13 01:27 PM
For those of you that are wishing for a fully customizable game, what makes you think that's actually going to happen? Or are we all just trying to hope for the best here and pretend EA...well, nevermind.
 
# 351 cferg21 @ 08/15/13 01:34 PM
Could all this mean we will finally get an NCAA basketball game again?
 
# 352 GisherJohn24 @ 08/15/13 01:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sbunce5
For those of you that are wishing for a fully customizable game, what makes you think that's actually going to happen? Or are we all just trying to hope for the best here and pretend EA...well, nevermind.
Roster share and create a team would solve all problems. IMO. Call me crazy but that seems like the easiest solution even if every conference backed out.
 
# 353 The_Rick_14 @ 08/15/13 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cferg21
Could all this mean we will finally get an NCAA basketball game again?
More likely means the exact opposite.
 
# 354 tessl @ 08/15/13 01:44 PM
I see it more as an inconvenience than something which will prevent EA from releasing a game next year. While authentic logos are nice they aren't the reason I play the game. Release a game with some generic teams in various cities and states with the same options they have now, custom conferences etc.

Hopefully the NCAA and the conferences are smart enough to realize what great advertising this game is for their sport and how many young people get interested in college football because of this game.
 
# 355 SpartyParty11 @ 08/15/13 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cferg21
Could all this mean we will finally get an NCAA basketball game again?
Nope, NCAA has the license for March Madness. So it'll be called College Basketball but none of the NCAA logos will be on it. NCAA didn't have that much effect on the football games since none of the NCAA logos were clearly visible during the game, but in basketball, it's at center court.

As for football, yes, the CLC renews its contract with EA but some of the bigger name colleges were not part of the CLC as in Ohio State, I believe Oregon, but don't quote me, Michigan State and USC
 
# 356 bwiggy33 @ 08/15/13 01:46 PM
EA may have to call the PES team about their editing system, or give users the opportunity to edit all teams on team builder so they can make jerseys, stadiums, rosters, etc accurate. To me that's the only way to give the opportunity to the user to make the game almost 100% authentic. Even though it would take a huge community effort, users could probably do a better job than EA with jerseys and what not.
 
# 357 sbunce5 @ 08/15/13 02:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GisherJohn24
Roster share and create a team would solve all problems. IMO. Call me crazy but that seems like the easiest solution even if every conference backed out.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tessl
Release a game with some generic teams in various cities and states with the same options they have now, custom conferences etc.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bwiggy33
EA may have to call the PES team about their editing system, or give users the opportunity to edit all teams on team builder so they can make jerseys, stadiums, rosters, etc accurate. To me that's the only way to give the opportunity to the user to make the game almost 100% authentic. Even though it would take a huge community effort, users could probably do a better job than EA with jerseys and what not.

I'm all for a totally customizable game next year, don't get me wrong. But let's not be blind fools guys. EA had no problem cutting their losses with NCAA Basketball, MVP Baseball, NBA Live to an extent, and many other games. What makes this franchise any different? Anyone with half a brain knows a fully customizable game won't sell as good as a licensed game.

With the remaining conferences also dropping out on the horizon, then followed by individual schools, I just don't see a game coming out next year. With EA's history, it just seems all but confirmed that they'll drop the game if it's going to be mainly generic schools.
 
# 358 prowler @ 08/15/13 02:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sbunce5
I'm all for a totally customizable game next year, don't get me wrong. But let's not be blind fools guys. EA had no problem cutting their losses with NCAA Basketball, MVP Baseball, NBA Live to an extent, and many other games. What makes this franchise any different? Anyone with half a brain knows a fully customizable game won't sell as good as a licensed game.

With the remaining conferences also dropping out on the horizon, then followed by individual schools, I just don't see a game coming out next year. With EA's history, it just seems all but confirmed that they'll drop the game if it's going to be mainly generic schools.
Pretty much this. Look at EA's portfolio; this is not a company known for taking chances with new IPs, they take proven commodities and milk them dry. With all the hurdles they'd need to clear to release a college football game, NCAA is officially dry. And this is coming from someone who loves Teambuilder and would love the idea of a fully customizable game.
 
# 359 JLoco11 @ 08/15/13 02:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sbunce5
I'm all for a totally customizable game next year, don't get me wrong. But let's not be blind fools guys. EA had no problem cutting their losses with NCAA Basketball, MVP Baseball, NBA Live to an extent, and many other games. What makes this franchise any different? Anyone with half a brain knows a fully customizable game won't sell as good as a licensed game.

With the remaining conferences also dropping out on the horizon, then followed by individual schools, I just don't see a game coming out next year. With EA's history, it just seems all but confirmed that they'll drop the game if it's going to be mainly generic schools.
I agree with certain parts of that... in particular EA knowing when to cut their losses. NCAA Basketball wasn't selling well, Live was getting killed in reviews and sales and desperately needed an overhaul, so they took a few years to re-work the game.

But MVP Baseball was a different issue. They lost MLB exclusivity to 2K (one of the reasons EA tried buying Take Two Interactive a few years ago was to get that license, and big game properties to their roster).

After they lost MLB, they tried a college baseball game, built on the same engine as MVP... while it was smooth, it didn't catch on since college baseball isn't a big seller. They cut their losses after 1 release.
 
# 360 ndfan1993 @ 08/15/13 02:54 PM
Someone with a better understanding of this whole lawsuit can correct me but is this not bigger than just gaming? I mean E$PN makes a ton of money off of college football and features players by name in their promo's which generate revenue. Does this also not mean that they could be on the hook? What about conferences?

I guess the bigger question is where does this end?
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.