MLB 2K10 News Post

Major League Baseball 2K10 Preview (Kotaku)

07:17 PM - January 23, 2010 by ExtremeGamer

Kotaku has posted their preview of Major League Baseball 2K10.

Quote:


	"It's hard to tell whether last year's MLB 2K9 - one of the worst-reviewed (and deservedly so) games ever for this class of sports simulation - raises or lowers consumer expectations for MLB 2K10. 2K9 suffered from glitches, clipping, bizarre baserunning and fielding AI, and, frankly, unacceptable graphics, especially in the player modeling. Conditioned to expect subtle changes in the fundamentals of year-to-year sports titles, I really didn't know what to expect. A set of drastic changes could bomb just as badly as ones tone-deaf to last year's problems. 2K gave me a four-hour guided preview of the game at their Novato, Calif. studios on Tuesday. Rather than attempt to certify whether this is an overhaul, a tuneup, or something in between, I decided to do what Visual Concepts seems to have done: Clear my mind of last year's game, and start all over on this one."

Game: Major League Baseball 2K10Reader Score: 6/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3 / Xbox 360Votes for game: 33 - View All

Major League Baseball 2K10 Videos

Member Comments

# 1 Blzer @ 01/23/10 07:23 PM

I'm liking what I hear about hitting, specifically the fact that he called contact hitting "standard hitting", and that influencing hitting is not designated to hit the home run, but rather simply to attempt to get lift (sacrifice flies, etc.).

Unfortunately, I wouldn't look forward to just flicking the stick up, I'd much rather load. But if it sounds like a stick flick is the standard way of swinging, then the defensive mechanic makes sense in that regard. Now if next year they can instead give every swing type a load (including DSM), then the mechanic will increase tenfold in my book.

# 2 jkra0512 @ 01/23/10 07:39 PM

This game is sounding more and more like it's going to get at least an 8 this year. I will still rent it first before buying it.

I will be absolutely ecstatic if they make a good baseball game this year! I wish them luck

# 3 SoxFan01605 @ 01/23/10 07:42 PM

Not particularly deep at all (especially on game play, but that's typical for these types of quick rundowns), but I liked what I read about a couple of areas of concern for me:

1. The more I read about changing the pitch selection to the face buttons, the more I think I like it. This description best summed up my hopes. Selecting the pitch first will take away the ambiguity of what's being thrown. Now, in theory, missed gestures are supposed to affect effectiveness, which is exactly how it should be. It was encouraging to see the mention of accuracy being less pinpoint and seeing more walks thrown.

2. Ignoring for a moment the obvious check-swing omission we've all been debating, the hitting system sounds like it's much more responsive (I actually like that he found it twitchy at first...it suggests its "loose" which is far better than the delayed input reaction from the last few, IMO). Also love how influence seems to be a lot less powered up and more of a gentle push, so to speak. My only other concern would be just how effective the DSM will be. Hopefully it's ratings based and not too effective. Too early to worry about it of course, but it's something to watch for.

3. A small thing by comparison to the first two, but it's encouraging to see the pitch speeds appear to be ramped up. I always felt the ball seemed like it almost floated to the plate. The fact that they upped that and still focused on the drawing of walks through other means is also encouraging.

# 4 Bellsprout @ 01/23/10 07:45 PM

I'm still buying The Show, but that said I never even gave a thought to renting 2k9 last year to see what I was missing. With what i've read so far this year, I will be renting that game and if I like it enough I'll be going the 2 baseball game route this year.

That's a big step, I think, to get people like me who never gave 2k9 a chance interested in 2k10, and i'm definitely interested.

# 5 bigfnjoe96 @ 01/23/10 07:55 PM

I'm really liking that they've tighten-up the L-Analog Stick for both Pitching & Hitting. It sounds like the writer felt the same way:

Quote:


	this year's configurations make loads more sense. They also represent a deliberately more deterministic mode of play that account for the many degrees of success or failure within the delivery of a pitch or the swing of a bat.

Quote:


	From what I saw of it, MLB 2K10's hitting and pitching philosophy justifies the use of the analog sticks.

Also looks like the Graphics did get an upgrade..

Quote:


	Judged by the visuals alone this will be a much better game than 2K9. All of the major league stadiums have been rebuilt, as well as character/face modeling, eliminating last year's embarrassments. Cap logos are appropriately proportioned, one of my pet peeves from 2K9.

Also liking the 2-player animations that have been done for this year:

Quote:


	One of the best updates will be the addition of two-player animations, in which double-plays or plays at the plate incorporate both runner and fielder (and the ball coming loose, where appropriate), for seamless collisions and outcomes with no distorted clipping or incongruent behaviors.

Bring-on the videos.....

# 6 brendanrfoley @ 01/23/10 08:17 PM

The preview is a good and honest assessment of what Owen played last week.

The visual improvements must come across better in motion than they do in stills; Owen says the 2K10 does not look as nice as Sony's offering, but says the improvements to the players, stadiums and animation "get it in the discussion."

I am also excited about the changes in game play. Despite the lack of check swings, I like this year's hit stick. It makes sense to me. I am also happy I will no longer throw the wrong pitch. Some gestures (curve/slider) are too similar for me in 2K9.

Owen admits 2K10 will not unseat The Show as a "best in class offering," but it does sound like the game is solid.

# 7 KeMiKaL @ 01/23/10 08:50 PM

sounds pretty good. i do still wish MLB the show was on xbox, but i think 2k may just not be a disappointment this year.

# 8 Motown @ 01/23/10 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brendanrfoley


	The preview is a good and honest assessment of what Owen played last week. The visual improvements must come across better in motion than they do in stills; Owen says the 2K10 does not look as nice as Sony's offering, but says the improvements to the players, stadiums and animation "get it in the discussion." I am also excited about the changes in game play. Despite the lack of check swings, I like this year's hit stick. It makes sense to me. I am also happy I will no longer throw the wrong pitch. Some gestures (curve/slider) are too similar for me in 2K9. Owen admits 2K10 will not unseat The Show as a "best in class offering," but it does sound like the game is solid.

sounds intriguing, i HOPE us PS3 owners will get this title on par w/ or CLOSE to the 360

anyone heard anything on the PS3 version? thanks

# 9 KeMiKaL @ 01/23/10 09:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Motown


	sounds intriguing, i HOPE us PS3 owners will get this title on par w/ or CLOSE to the 360 anyone heard anything on the PS3 version? thanks

its called " MLB the SHow"!!> nah, im joking, but i would think since u have ps3, u would get the show

# 10 Motown @ 01/23/10 09:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeMiKaL


	its called " MLB the SHow"!!> nah, im joking, but i would think since u have ps3, u would get the show

Ah hell yeah...The Shows already there dawg, I'm just wantin' a little competition...both games got their own thang...ya dig?

# 11 KeMiKaL @ 01/23/10 09:32 PM

yea i got you.

all of the people who dont have ps3, are really hoping 2k pulls through

# 12 MizzouRah @ 01/23/10 11:03 PM

Excellent read.. and from someone who was critical of 2k9. (who wasn't

)

Pitching and hitting both seem improved and I like the "eye" feature.

It might not be perfect, but if it's fun and the results seem like it's me making them happen, I'll give it a fair shake.

# 13 mkharsh33 @ 01/23/10 11:11 PM

Read the article...sounds promising. All I want is simulation baseball - hopefully this game is getting closer to that. No doubt we'll be playing with sliders, but if the major glitches are gone (ie. too many strikes thrown, outfielders dropping fly balls) and we have more freedom to edit players, i'm liking what i'm hearing.

# 14 Scooter3 @ 01/23/10 11:16 PM

I have a PS3 and it's not about either platform it's about baseball.
I love Chocolate Ice cream but once in a while I have to try Pistachio...I'm hoping for 2 great baseball games in 2010 and it looks very promising!

scooter...

# 15 Blzer @ 01/23/10 11:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KeMiKaL


	sounds pretty good. i do still wish MLB the show was on xbox, but i think 2k may just not be a disappointment this year.

I think part of the greatness of MLB The Show is that it has no limits being on the PS3. That is, games like this, Uncharted 2, GT5, MGS4, Little Big Planet, etc. couldn't be made on Xbox, mostly because of the way that it's made and how much content is put on the disc.

That being said, you wouldn't wish it was on 360, because it probably wouldn't be all that it is now.

# 16 Jamin23 @ 01/23/10 11:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blzer


	I think part of the greatness of MLB The Show is that it has no limits being on the PS3. That is, games like this, Uncharted 2, GT5, MGS4, Little Big Planet, etc. couldn't be made on Xbox, mostly because of the way that it's made and how much content is put on the disc. That being said, you wouldn't wish it was on 360, because it probably wouldn't be all that it is now.

I wish the 360 was as powerful as the PS3 so than we could enjoy the show too.

Unfortunately that's not going to happen.

# 17 jeffy777 @ 01/24/10 12:21 AM

Good read. Unlike the IGN and Gamespot previews, it sounds like this guy knows what he's talking about and actually plays baseball games. So for him to speak positive about this game is a good sign, especially since he was well aware of 2K9's flaws.

# 18 PhillsPhan26 @ 01/24/10 01:16 AM

No way in the world this game competes with "The Show".

# 19 ExtremeGamer @ 01/24/10 08:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blzer


	I think part of the greatness of MLB The Show is that it has no limits being on the PS3. That is, games like this, Uncharted 2, GT5, MGS4, Little Big Planet, etc. couldn't be made on Xbox, mostly because of the way that it's made and how much content is put on the disc. That being said, you wouldn't wish it was on 360, because it probably wouldn't be all that it is now.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jamin23


	I wish the 360 was as powerful as the PS3 so than we could enjoy the show too. Unfortunately that's not going to happen.

Both statements are incorrect, but this isn't the place to discuss, keep the conversations on topic please.

# 20 ExtremeGamer @ 01/24/10 10:21 AM

Next person to go off topic, will get an infraction, final and only warning.

« Previous12 Next »

More Links

Major League Baseball 2K10 Preview (Kotaku)