MLB The Show 16 OSFM HYBRID V1 Roster Available Now

[Russia0524]

Quote: Originally Posted by tonybologna

Or, give him some time to recover from the previous punch from Odor? LOL!

Sigh.......

[Garrett59]

Quote: Originally Posted by Nulap

Given that all players are rated using the same system I believe that complaints should be forwarded to: http://steamerprojections.com/blog/about-2/ from what I've seen so far people only seem to be at odds with 1 or 2 players. If there were issues with say 20 or more I could see questioning the system, with 1 or 2 it seems, to me, it may be a personal bias.

Lindor without a douct should be an A i dont know how people disagree with this logic. He is a gold glove caliber defender with speed and ability to steal bases and is hitting tremendous, these type of players dont come around often

[Willard76]

Quote: Originally Posted by Garrett59

Lindor without a douct should be an A i dont know how people disagree with this logic. He is a gold glove caliber defender with speed and ability to steal bases and is hitting tremendous, these type of players dont come around often

Everyone who agrees please change Lindor to anything above 90 you want in your roster - if you disagree and agree with scouts and experts please let him be.

For sake of argument I ran a sim and Lindor ended up 92 potential after season 1


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[WaitTilNextYear]

Quote: Originally Posted by Willard76

For sake of argument I ran a sim and Lindor ended up 92 potential after season 1

How it should be, imo. Let him continue to earn that A through progression.

People are reading wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy too much into his MLB batting stats so far at this early juncture in his career. Lindor is simply not a .320 hitter at the MLB level, sorry (he never hit higher than .289 in the minor leagues above high A ball). Not close. He's posted a .350 BABIP (!) in the bigs, and he hits with neither the authority (4 homers, just .110 ISO this year) nor has the blazing speed to be a BABIP outlier. ZiPS has him at .282 ROS, Steamer at .277 ROS. We try not to over-correct for small samples, which is what relying on the projections is good for guarding against.

When Lindor finds his true level as perhaps a .280/.330/.400 hitter with 10 HR/15 SB and slick to Gold Glove defense, an 88 POT will look just fine. I mentioned this earlier in the thread and I'll say this again, but offensive players that don't hit for power should almost never be considered as an A (HOF level player).

But, there's really no reason to keep dragging this up. Nitpicking ratings on this guy here and that guy there doesn't get you anywhere. Even if you think you've made your point, we're not changing him. You can do what you want with your copy.

[caldi06]

Which sliders do you guys suggest for your rosters?

[WaitTilNextYear]

Quote: Originally Posted by caldi06

Which sliders do you guys suggest for your rosters?

We don't suggest any specific set. Just try some sets out and find what you like best.

[AC]

Quote: Originally Posted by WaitTilNextYear

ZiPS has him at .282 ROS, Steamer at .277 ROS.

Just for future reference I wouldn't use ZiPS for anything, lol.

[cwhalx23]

Willard can you create blue jays prospect jeremy gabryszwski in AA he having solid season.Willard did you create blue jays prospect shane dawson if not can you upload your version of him.