Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

[dmv dreadhead]

its obvious these ratings are made to appease the fans of hype. nobody in their right mind would rate Luck and RGIII so high. also the ratings are way too bunched up, hire me as the ratings guru, this is ridiculous.

[raiderphantom]

Cam had a nice rookie year and he has a smoothe deep ball but his short/mid accuracy is not that good.

[jmurphy31]

Remember when Reggie Bush came out there was ton of hype and his madden rating was set high. How did that work out his first year and typically RB have an easier adjustment than QB. (Though that trend seems to be changing).

[DNMHIII]

Quote: Originally Posted by OhioBuckeyes7

who cares it's a video game. in Real Life you really don't know who the strong arm is. here is what you do know Vick Pryor RG3 and Cam are Fast QB's. No need for them to get shafted. weather you played a NFL game or not. Fast QB's should not have speed lowered from college because they have not played. there fast. Cam newton threw some picks and RG3 is a Better passer than cam. so is luck. so they should be ratted better.

lol.......wut?

Newton was a much better passer in college than Luck ever was and he torched the NFL. RG3 is comparable to Newton, but the nod still goes to Newton and I'm basing that on what they did in college and I'm not even looking at what Newton did in the NFL.

[So Cal]

I see alot of guys stating who got shafted and whos ratings are unbelievable, and I get that especially with the incoming rookies....my thing is how much are they going to change them once a player has a bad week. I think we have all seen how a player can play ok and EA boosts they ratings like 4 points and someone can have a just decent game and drop, but my favorite is how someone players have turnover prone games and they dont hardly get touched.

[Afrikan]

is Cam Newton really 8pts slower than RGIII?

come on. I think they went alittle crazy with RG's speed. Or at least add more to the rest of the field of QBs who are just as fast.

[NDAlum]

I think RGIII's speed is accurate. They are completely different physical specimens.

Not a fan of the ratings as a whole. My biggest snub is Sam Bradford.

[TomSNC]

Quote: Originally Posted by DNMHIII

lol.......wut? Newton was a much better passer in college than Luck ever was and he torched the NFL. RG3 is comparable to Newton, but the nod still goes to Newton and I'm basing that on what they did in college and I'm not even looking at what Newton did in the NFL.

This. The rookie ratings are ridiculous and this is coming from a big fan of both, no big problems though.