I wasn't going to respond to this, but I just can't let it go. This is exactly why you get the crap you get from some guys on this site. I've been on about 5 threads today, and I haven't seen any "blatant bashing and complaining". What I have seen is valid discussion between many different fans of football gaming. Some fans who are very pleased with Madden, some who aren't and some who lie somewhere in between. What's not productive are most of these posts like yours. This is a discussion thread, that's what people do. They DISCUSS. Maybe in the threads we should have more discussion like this:
Guarantee your post doesn't appear if this stuff was plastered everywhere. You go into every thread that doesn't supply you with affirmation that your favorite game ever isn't really everything that YOU think it is and have to attempt to "put the complainers in their place". The best thing to do is avoid the threads if you can't present a valid argument/discussion point. Most of us are not 12 as you seem to think. Hating a game because it's made by EA is a childish argument and is something that should be reserved for xbox.com or the forums at IGN. Many of us started playing football games and Madden long before you did, so keep that in mind.
With respect to the fact that they put in a bunch of work on a few things... Your reaction is EXACTLY what many of us would expect from Tiburon. "We listened to the fans and worked long hours, so we want a pat on the back, even though massive issues that break the game are still there for years on end." I don't feel bad for them, just like customers don't feel bad for me where I work. That's my job, to build a product that is worth the expense of the customer. One year is a long time to wait for a lot of guys. When you are talking about several years, they get a little frustrated, especially at 60 bucks a pop.
No one has an issue with you loving everything Madden and Tiburon. That's awesome. However, I take issue with you being critical of people who don't. Especially when those people present their case in an intelligent and mature manner, which 99% of the guys on here do.