FBGRatings Seeks to Recalibrate Madden Ratings, Change Game

[Culture Rot]

Why would I want a rerated roster when the football season ends?

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by xlatinoheatx

Why would I want a rerated roster when the football season ends?

then don't, but thank you for sharing??!!

[mestevo]

Kind of leads to a question worth asking though, will the data at the end if the season reflect the nfl rosters as of the start of the season or the end if it, and at what point does it become a 'nevermind, will be working towards next season' project... with the hope that formulas don't change yet again?

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by luisffsilva

I think the idea is good, but is not well done, not even close for me. I think there is another variants to consider, how a player is a "playmaker", what the player do in the past, consider the actual stats like tackles, receiving yard, running and etc. I agree the players are over rated by EA and week by week rating update is not necessary, the player have to play like 3/4 games good to receive a upgrade or not. EXAMPLES: Toddy Heap is the third best TE ?!? in what world !?? Osi Umenyiora rating 65 ?!? Andy Dalton 62 ?!? Adrian Peterson is behind Jones Drew and Steve Jackson ?!? Colston is better than Nicks, Austin, Wayne and others like this calibers players ?!? C' MON MAN !!!!

1. Stats never equate to scouting info. In this system all players are rated via scouting data only.

2. Injuries affect the OVR.

3. Those examples of players listed seem like pure opinion to me. Please include some data to support your statements regarding said players.

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by mestevo

Kind of leads to a question worth asking though, will the data at the end if the season reflect the nfl rosters as of the start of the season or the end if it, and at what point does it become a 'nevermind, will be working towards next season' project... with the hope that formulas don't change yet again? Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk

All of the data from the end of the season will still be from last July. Only reason being that it will be a bit easier to process. However, the true end of season ratings will follow shortly thereafter. I just want to experiment with the OVR formulas first to work out any kinks.

[shagrugg]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

1. Stats never equate to scouting info. In this system all players are rated via scouting data only. 2. Injuries affect the OVR. 3. Those examples of players listed seem like pure opinion to me. Please include some data to support your statements regarding said players.

You've probably already answered this somewhere in this thread... but from your previous post ^^

If injuries affect the OVR, why wouldn't statistical achievements or stat trends?

I get the scouting data as a baseline of physical attributes coming out of college... but over time that should become less a contributor as there is statistical data seasonal achievement and career trends up and down that should contribute to OVR.

[tarantism]

I say we Occupy this thread! Who's with me???

[luisffsilva]

Pure opinion ??! I don't think so ! you see nfl games or just play videogames and do scouting !??

I think alot of users agree with me.

Adrian Peterson is behind Jones Drew and Steve Jackson ?!?

Fullback best rating is 86 ?!??

See a NFL game, than talk... Scouting is better than stats, OK, i agree but they are REAL numbers.

Like Todd Heap, he is third TE in Cardinals depth chart and the rating is 91 ?!?
He never was a PLAYMAKER and lost alot of games with injuries.


Now numbers:

Carrer
Todd Heap RATING 91 years pro 11
REC 480 YDS 5,642 TD 41

Jason Witten RATING 90 years pro 9
REC 673 YDS 7,680 TD 41