Madden 11 Player Ratings: Who’s Overrated And Who’s Undervalued (Sportsgrid)

[jsmoovexD]

Quote: Originally Posted by thesteamontheboat

UNDERRATED: Matt Moore is way better than Jay Cutler arm not as strong but should be rated higher than him alot of QBs should.

Culter's arm is the best without doubt Moore is a QB on the team you said had no passing

[thesteamontheboat]

Quote: Originally Posted by jsmoovexD

Culter's arm is the best without doubt Moore is a QB on the team you said had no passing

No passing till he got there and played the last few games and beat min, nyg, and saints. Reason for Jake being in Cleveland. Basically saying the no passing comment was for b4 Moore not after. Plus how can you be rated that high with all those pics and not that many wins or tds to even it out?

[jsmoovexD]

Even though Cutlers still a good QB new team changes alot aand 1 season shouldn't amount to a career he can preform well so he deserves it Moore had a top 10 reciever as well

[thesteamontheboat]

Quote: Originally Posted by jsmoovexD

Even though Cutlers still a good QB new team changes alot and 1 season shouldn't amount to a career he can preform well so he deserves it Moore had a top 10 receiver as well

Last time I checked these ratings are suppose to be based off last season not your career potential in the future. If that was the case LT should be in the 90s. So because Tom Brady has a top five receiver his rating shouldn't be high? Jake Delhomme proved having a great receiver doesn't mean a thing when it comes to throwing more picks than TDs.

[Black81984]

I honestly think Manning mite be the best QB we will ever see do it in our lifetime guys will have better years and what not but he's the best the guy is insane.

[at23steelers]

Underrated:

Big Ben - 88 ovr (93 ovr)
Calvin Johnson - 91 ovr (96 ovr)
Ray Rice - 90 ovr (95 ovr)

The only reason WR Jackson is overrated to me is because Calvin is the same overall as him. I would just bump up Calvin though, and leave Jackson's rating the same, because in no way should they be the same overall.

[BloodMeridian]

Quote: Originally Posted by djack10jmac18

Those of You who think that desean Jackson is underrated are ignorant. You obviously know nothing about football and should stop talking because your making yourself look dumb. Desean may seem one dimensional to you because you saw his long touchdowns and you assume that's all he does. But your dumb and don't realize that he is a great route runner and did learn from the best, jerry rice. He explodes off the line of scrimmage using his speed, runs his route greatly, modifies his route to adjust to the defense and get open. And yes he does go across the middle. I.e. against the chiefs last season. He then blows by everyone for a score. He also deserves a high rating. When you are arguably the most explosive and dangerous player in NFL, tie the record for most 50+ yard TDs and play well at your position you should be rated an elite player. And whoever tried to say he wasnt the first to be voted to 2 positions as a starter is pretty close to ********. He was the first starter at 2 positions in the pro bowl and it was well documented during the game even. HE WAS VOTED AS A STARTER are the main words there. And who needs over 65 receptions when you only need a couple per game to make your team win. And no one can hate on him for fumbling the ball on the 1 yard line. That was one of his few turnovers and the eagles scored on the very next play. Desean Jackson scores touchdowns no matter what. If it means catching, returning punts, running the ball or anything else. He gets it done. Only educated responses are accepted. Thank you to davey225 for knowing what he is talking about.

Oh the irony!

You're an Eagles fan.....we get it. He was nearly invisible in the wildcard game.

[monkeybutlerz]

Taking a quick peek at the Ravens O-line, Grubbs is overrated, while Gaither and Yanda are underrated.