MLB '10 The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors v.3

[xNobleEaglex]

Quote: Originally Posted by abcabc

what pitcher level are you, pope?

I use HOF for pitching with meter.

[MizzyMike05]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bondsfan

I kind of liked the pitching stamina and attributes prior to the V3 release. I'm not crazy about the idea of radically changing the stamina ratings. I do however think the game needs serious changing of player ratings, especially hitters. Its going to be tough to decide between using V2 or V4. On one hand, I don't want the pitch edits, but on the other, I really want the batter edits.

Quote: Originally Posted by mattlanta

I'm w/ ya bro... dunno what to do either. Maybe wait for V5.

I think i'm with you guys. This roster is amazing, and i am so appreciative of these rosters its not even funny. I am going to use this roster set no matter what happens. I just think that tweaking with the stamina drastically like they did is unnecessary. I AM NOT BASHING ANYONE OR ANY WORK DONE TO THIS ROSTER SET, so please don't make a useless post saying that i am complaining. Unlike bondsfan, I actually like the pitch edits a lot (except for there almost being no straight fast balls), but i disagree with the stamina edits. Otherwise, this roster is seriously UNREAL. If SCEA hired them to do this, i would definitely pay whatever i had to get my hands on these. I hope there is a V4.1 to fix the stamina edits, but if not, then i don't mind at all. Yet again, thanks again to all involved in this project.

[Bondsfan]

When I said pitch edits, I was referring to the stamina. I'm right with you stu. I'm not sure if the V4.1 roster is going to change all the staminas back to the original, or what.

[TheRunAndShoot]

Quote: Originally Posted by stusteelersqb5

I think i'm with you guys. This roster is amazing, and i am so appreciative of these rosters its not even funny. I am going to use this roster set no matter what happens. I just think that tweaking with the stamina drastically like they did is unnecessary. I AM NOT BASHING ANYONE OR ANY WORK DONE TO THIS ROSTER SET, so please don't make a useless post saying that i am complaining. Unlike bondsfan, I actually like the pitch edits a lot (except for there almost being no straight fast balls), but i disagree with the stamina edits. Otherwise, this roster is seriously UNREAL. If SCEA hired them to do this, i would definitely pay whatever i had to get my hands on these. I hope there is a V4.1 to fix the stamina edits, but if not, then i don't mind at all. Yet again, thanks again to all involved in this project.

Pitch edits and stamina edits have been part of these rosters since i can remember (07) this is the first year that i can remember people have had a problem with em. SCEA made some changes this year that effected parts of the game that they weren't expecting.

[Dean3790]

Alright guys. I am doing some testing now with an early build of v4. I will post results as I get them...

Update #1- doing at least 5 seasons using the same numbers I was using earlier. These are on default sliders with injury frequency at 2. The first sim seemed good. The second was even better.

[MizzyMike05]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheRunAndShoot

Pitch edits and stamina edits have been part of these rosters since i can remember (07) this is the first year that i can remember people have had a problem with em. SCEA made some changes this year that effected parts of the game that they weren't expecting.

thanks for the response runandshoot. i am just trying to help everyone figure out a possible way to solve the franchise stats problem that some people are running into. i have gone deep into 2 frannys with V3 and have had some pretty ridiculous numbers myself. A-rod hitting 60 dingers a year and 150+ rbi's.

[Dean3790]

v4 is looking like it might have solved some problems. I will post my findings when I am all done.

[merg311]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dean3790

v4 is looking like it might have solved some problems. I will post my findings when I am all done.

This is great news! Not sure how much longer I can hold out!