MLB '10: The Show - Player Potential Fix Coming in Next Roster Update

[Dmrepsuga5]

Quote: Originally Posted by jay10333

Current Potential / What is should be For the Mets: Pelfrey - C / B Perez - C / B Parnell - D / C Nieve - F / C Santos - D / C Thole - D / C Murphy - C / B Cora - D / C Wright - F / A Reyes - F / A Hernandez - F / D Franceour - D / B Thanks

As a Mets fan, I havae to disagree with some of these. Ollie's potential looks fine to me. He's pitched plenty and been inconsistent and I don't think he'll all of a sudden figure it out and become better than he was in '07. Omir Santos is a journeyman catcher who's now 4th on the depth chart. Cora is ancient, I don't see him getting any better. Anderson Hernandez is a bum, no more than a AAA player at this stage of his career. Francouer hasn't shown the ability to put it all together, so I think a C grade would be better...not B.

Thole I would bump up to a B actually, since he hit over .300 and can handle the bat already in the bigs and just needs to work on his catching skills, think he can be a perennial .300 hitter.

Wright and Reyes should both be B's. We've probably seen them have their best years, but they shouldn't degrade at an F clip. An A grade would be too much IMO.

Just my 2 cents!!! Go Mets

[stormshadow1]

I want to know if patching the "potential" issue in the roster will fix the CPU trading whilst set on manual.

It will prob fix the crazy trades but will it fix the CPU overiding your settings?

Again, this is a HUGE issue and will be a game breaker for me. I do not like to see "IF" there is a 2nd patch, in regards to this problem.

I understand the whole C.Y.A. aspect of the "IF" word, but sorry $60.00 for an "IF" in regard to the CPU screwing up your game does not cut it.

[Knight165]

Quote: Originally Posted by stormshadow1

I want to know if patching the "potential" issue in the roster will fix the CPU trading whilst set on manual. It will prob fix the crazy trades but will it fix the CPU overiding your settings? Again, this is a HUGE issue and will be a game breaker for me. I do not like to see "IF" there is a 2nd patch, in regards to this problem. I understand the whole C.Y.A. aspect of the "IF" word, but sorry $60.00 for an "IF" in regard to the CPU screwing up your game does not cut it.

How many other games you paid $60 for even gave you?
1. The opportunity to say.."it doesn't cut it"
2. A response 1 day after release

In regards to the game over riding....what's happening?
Is it when you hit auto to fix something...and the CPU making trades for you.
If so...I think it's been said that they found that bug

M.K.
Knight165

[fenwaymike]

Knight,

More importantly...how are those Rosters coming along? lol

On a serious note Knight...are your classic rosters that you made this past year still available and will they work for The Show 10? If so where can I find them in the vault? Enough questions for you? lol Thanks again Knight for all you do

[stormshadow1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Knight165

How many other games you paid $60 for even gave you? 1. The opportunity to say.."it doesn't cut it" 2. A response 1 day after release In regards to the game over riding....what's happening? Is it when you hit auto to fix something...and the CPU making trades for you. If so...I think it's been said that they found that bug M.K. Knight165

I know it was stated that it was found. I just expected more than an "If there is another patch" after the one just released (that was worked on pre-release).

I guess I am a little disappointed in myself that I bought the game on release day. I should have waited, lesson learned.

[Knight165]

Quote: Originally Posted by fenwaymike

Knight, More importantly...how are those Rosters coming along? lol On a serious note Knight...are your classic rosters that you made this past year still available and will they work for The Show 10? If so where can I find them in the vault? Enough questions for you? lol Thanks again Knight for all you do

No..they won't work in '10
There will be a couple of Classic rosters this year.

M.K.
Knight165

[EWRMETS]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dmrepsuga5

Wright and Reyes should both be B's. We've probably seen them have their best years, but they shouldn't degrade at an F clip. An A grade would be too much IMO. Just my 2 cents!!! Go Mets

I agree that Perez, Pellfrey and a lot of the other suggestions are overrating the Mets and I may be OK with B's for Reyes and Wright, but why are you suggesting that a 27 year old (Wright) and 26 year old (Reyes) have already peaked as players?

[Dmrepsuga5]

By saying they've had their best years, I mean they can still consistently have those types of good, big years, but I think they have peaked. That's not a bad thing.

Wright is a .300 hitter able to hit 30 HR, and drive in 100 RBI (see '05-'08). this makes him a GREAT player. but that's his peak (which isn't a bad peak to have). I don't think he'll be a .330 hitter who hits 45+ HR and drives in 150. So, I don't think an A potential is needed, because how much better can he get? I just don't want him to drastically decline with an F rating.

Same with Reyes. I believe his '06 will be his career year. He hit .300, 19 HR, 81 RBI, and stole 64 bags. I think he has the ability to consistently do that (maybe a little less), just not exactly MORE than that. He's a GREAT players if he can do that. Hence a B grade for "future" potential.