MLB '10: The Show - Top Pitchers

[kolasi]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mr M.Moss

Webb and Peavy barely pitched in 09 No Lee or Greinke? Mo Rivera is the greatest closer of all time and Nathan and Broxton are rated higher? I recall Nathan and Broxton having major meltdowns in the playoffs

well said.

[AInquisition]

Quote: Originally Posted by Aragorn523

No Verlander in the top 10 is suprising.

Agreed

Matt Thornton got hosed, he was the 2nd best reliever in the game last year based on WAR (behind Broxton)

[JoeCoolMan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by AInquisition

Agreed Matt Thornton got hosed, he was the 2nd best reliever in the game last year based on WAR (behind Broxton)

Great minds think alike. Of the 3 white sox omissions in my opinion, the Matt Thornton one if the most obvious. The other 2 are debatable, Matt Thornton is NOT.

[king_hali]

Leaving Zack Greinke out of the top 10 pitchers is the worst sports game rating I have ever seen in my life. He was the best pitcher in the league last year........

[ATLNYankee]

I cant wait to edit the closers. No way are Broxton and Nathan better than Mo. I am going to make Super Mariano 100 across the board. Nathan and Broxton can be at 90. Rivera is a god among mortals.

[JoeCoolMan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by king_hali

Leaving Zack Greinke out of the top 10 pitchers is the worst sports game rating I have ever seen in my life. He was the best pitcher in the league last year........

Not really. I can see the argument because Greinke only has done great for 1 season. Verlander and Cliff Lee are bigger omissions on the starters list really.

[BatsareBugs]

Really hard to list all the great pitchers in the league when you can only see nine on the list at the time. Again, like I've said numerous times already, it is possible that the players "omitted" have the same overall as the last player or two on the list, but because of the tie, they are ranked in no particular order.

I'm surprised that Mike Adams being the highest rated middle reliever, but I won't complain.

Edit: ATLNYankee, the only way Mo gets number 1 is if you drop Broxton's and Nathan's ratings, they are tied in overall.

[econoodle]

Quote: Originally Posted by JoeCoolMan24

Not really. I can see the argument because Greinke only has done great for 1 season. Verlander and Cliff Lee are bigger omissions on the starters list really.

ok, so who comes off?
its not liek theres chumps up there lol