MLB '10: The Show - Top Pitchers

[JahCreations]

Quote: Originally Posted by jvalverde88

No K-Rod yet Billy Wagner is up there?

I was thinking the same thing..

[Shauk25]

I have to say, i havent disagreed with any ratings but having the Cy Young Award Winner off the list is really really really suprising.

[king_hali]

Quote: Originally Posted by JoeCoolMan24

Not really. I can see the argument because Greinke only has done great for 1 season. Verlander and Cliff Lee are bigger omissions on the starters list really.

He has been under a 3.7 era the last three years, and last year was statistically the best pitcher in baseball. Sorry there is no way you can excuse that ...

[csker7]

Quote: Originally Posted by tommyjesus

i would think jeremy affeldt and brian wilson would make the top 10...

my thoughts exactly. wilson not in the top 10 is really not a big deal, cuz he still can improve...affledt was the best setup man in baseball last year, so i dont see how he isnt on the list.

[king_hali]

Quote: Originally Posted by Shauk25

I have to say, i havent disagreed with any ratings but having the Cy Young Award Winner off the list is really really really suprising.

exactly.....

[JoeCoolMan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by econoodle

ok, so who comes off? its not liek theres chumps up there lol

Carpenter, Haren, and maybe even Santana.

[JoeCoolMan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by king_hali

He has been under a 3.7 era the last three years, and last year was statistically the best pitcher in baseball. Sorry there is no way you can excuse that ...

I didn't say he has not been good, but he has not been great, or even a top 15 pitcher until last season. Again, I am not saying he does not deserve to be in the top 9, but to say it is the worst ratings ever, or however you exactly said it, is silly because there is a valid counter argument.

[JoeCoolMan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by csker7

my thoughts exactly. wilson not in the top 10 is really not a big deal, cuz he still can improve...affledt was the best setup man in baseball last year, so i dont see how he isnt on the list.

Thornton was the best set-up man last year, however, the Brian Wilson argument is valid....

http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.asp...n=2009&month=0