Madden NFL 10 Patch #2 Available, Impressions Here (PS3)

[KBLover]

Quote: Originally Posted by countryboy

Someone else brought up the fact that you will no longer see players who are injured listed as doubtful, questionable, or probable, and that is correct. Asomugha was injured in preseason and at the start of the season he was listed as out for one week. He sat out week one and returned week 2 without being listed on the injury list.

Isn't that the way it should be? If the guy isn't hurt anymore, why should he still be on the injury list?

For example, Rothlisberger had a concussion and was out a couple games. Now he's back and is not listed as anything on the injury report.

I've always thought that if a guy is out - he's out until he's cleared to play and is basically 100%.

P/Q/D injuries are for relatively minor injuries the player could play on, but won't be at 100% and so the decision is more up to the coaches (i.e. us) rather than the team doctors (i.e. Out injuries).

Perhaps the problem with the injury system is that there's too many OUT injuries and not enough P/Q/D for weeks injuries. Sometimes guys are held out but haven't suffered concussions or whatnot. OUT injuries should be reserves for totally severe stuff that the player just can't play on and those probably would take more than a week to heal.

[Pared]

Quote: Originally Posted by RayAllen20

I didn't mean players being out for only 3 weeks. I've had plenty of 1 week, 6 week, Season, and Career injuries. I'm not sure if this is what you are talking about but I have never seen any probable or questionable injuries. Maybe I'll have to look for it more often. I still don't have the patch, and am on the 360, if that makes a difference.

I have seen those injuries in-game, not in between weeks. And this was on the last patch as well.

It happened quite a few times in my online franchise after an injury.

Pause, go to depth chart, and there it is. It changes as the game progresses as well.

[countryboy]

Quote: Originally Posted by RayAllen20

I didn't mean players being out for only 3 weeks. I've had plenty of 1 week, 6 week, Season, and Career injuries. I'm not sure if this is what you are talking about but I have never seen any probable or questionable injuries. Maybe I'll have to look for it more often. I still don't have the patch, and am on the 360, if that makes a difference.

I saw those pre-patch, but not after the 2nd patch dropped.

[Hova57]

its like for ncaa football 10 on the injury report

[countryboy]

Quote: Originally Posted by KBLover

Isn't that the way it should be? If the guy isn't hurt anymore, why should he still be on the injury list? For example, Rothlisberger had a concussion and was out a couple games. Now he's back and is not listed as anything on the injury report. I've always thought that if a guy is out - he's out until he's cleared to play and is basically 100%. P/Q/D injuries are for relatively minor injuries the player could play on, but won't be at 100% and so the decision is more up to the coaches (i.e. us) rather than the team doctors (i.e. Out injuries). Perhaps the problem with the injury system is that there's too many OUT injuries and not enough P/Q/D for weeks injuries. Sometimes guys are held out but haven't suffered concussions or whatnot. OUT injuries should be reserves for totally severe stuff that the player just can't play on and those probably would take more than a week to heal.

In the NFL, guys are listed as P/Q/D all the time. Its either because they are trying to get over an injury or they have a very minor injury that is not guaranteed to put them out for the week and are game-time/day decisions.

But either way, it was in the game up until patch 2 dropped and now its not there anymore. I haven't seen anyone listed as P/Q/D in my franchise post patch 2.

[RayAllen20]

Oooo so you guys are talking about the Medical Center in-game, right? I have seen those. I thought you were talking about the injury report in the middle of the week. OK. That kinda sucks that it was taken out, but I can deal with it.

[NFLFanSince1979]

After reading everyones impressions on patch #2, it's good to know that I made the right choice to trade my Madden in for MW2.

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by NFLFanSince1979

After reading everyones impressions on patch #2, it's good to know that I made the right choice to trade my Madden in for MW2.

You must be referring to the 1st part of the thread where 95% of the complaints were about the stats issues.

Others are varied about the game play, some say it's been enhanced and some say it hasn't.

Best judge is yourself.