NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

[ebarws6]

Quote: Originally Posted by BORN4CORN

Its called an analogy..

I know..

But also an over exaggeration..

[ebarws6]

Quote: Originally Posted by ehovUOfan

If they fix it, I'll be glad but I won't congratulate them since they didn't do their job in the first place. I say that EA should take a look at how it runs game development and try to find ways to make sure mistakes like this don't happen again. Also, I think they should fire the game testers for NCAA since they should have at least caught some of the roster mistakes, unless they all played the same teams that were correct and not the lower-rung NCAA teams that seem to be the ones the are completely wrong.

But then again, how would those game testers know if those lower-rung schools' rosters are right?

[ehovUOfan]

If this had been done by any other person/group in another business, they would more than likely be fired or have a note of reprimand in their records. Nobody on the NCAA team should be congratulated for a job poorly done.

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by ebarws6

But then again, how would those game testers know if those lower-rung schools' rosters are right?

Well a lack of freshman on many of the teams might be a clue? Who does EA have testing for them? Good God I wished I was on this test team wow.

[Bat]

I'm shocked! Well not really considering its EA. Every year new trivial additions. How about making a great playing football game on and offline first. Enough with the fluff. All I have come to expect with EA is new features that I never use and bugs.

I'm not a 2k fanboy either. I preffered Madden. I just want developers to get the foundation right before they add junk on top of it.

Delay the game. The ability to patch has increased laziness IMO. I don't want my hard drive filled with fixes to games.

[jusmegamer]

I'm sorry but I don't see how it makes any sense to purchase this game. If the teams aren't accurate and they can't be without accurate ratings why not just play your favorite NCAA Football of the past? All you have is the Florida logo and the Swamp and no other accuracy, what makes this different from 06? This is a bad joke. No way I will even rent this unless it is made clear that the rosters and teams are accurate.

[ehovUOfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by ebarws6

But then again, how would those game testers know if those lower-rung schools' rosters are right?

I think you need to get testers who know college football, not just those who know only the top rated teams. EA should pull fans from every team to get their feedback. I would go as far as to have at least one tester or game developer for every team, even if it was just a temporary job for like a week to fact check rosters and uniforms.

[SHO]

Quote: Originally Posted by superjames1992

I've looked at the gameplay videos and they both seem pretty identical to me...

Wouldn't exactly go that far to say identical.