ESPN NFL 2K5 vs Madden NFL 08 Part One

[Jon22]

So, are people going to do this EVERY YEAR until Madden is better? This is getting worse than spygate.

[ka520]

2k5 blew out Madden when it came to alternates. Madden & NCAA still hasn't caught up.

[landoniandeux]

2k was the absolute best football game to ever be made. gameplay was the best i ever played and madden has never had or will ever have. 2k >>>>than all maddens

[Lintyfresh85]

Wow... so for years we couldn't comment on the competition between the two franchises because it'd start a flame war... yet now, after the site was bought up and turned to ****... you openly write articles comparing the two, and basically begging for a flame war?


Ha. amazing.

[tril]

I never knew thats what VIP did. WOW!!!!
2k5 still gives me fits, I have been fired numerous of times, and I havent won a superbowl except on the first 2 levels.


Madden is still enjoyable. so I look forward to seeing the outcome.

Id have to pick 2k5 though.

[mutler]

Yeah I just picked up Madden 08 for the psp. Its ok but it feels to arcadie. once you set the sliders in 2k5, each game feels intense, because I have to play smart and fight for the every yard. I think 2k5 forces you to play sim.

[StayPlation82]

give me a break people. madden is best, it sells more (outsold 2k5). if that game was so great, why didn't anyone buy the thing and the were giving them away at like 29.99. sad. presentation is like 10% of a game anyway and other than that the game had bad player models, cheap humor and bad physics. for some of you the game is great but to the other millions of fans that buy madden we say the game was just ok. R.I.P. 2k5...and people thought Elvis was great too. please! get out of here!

[Kramer5150]

Quote: Originally Posted by StayPlation82

give me a break people. madden is best, it sells more (outsold 2k5). if that game was so great, why didn't anyone buy the thing and the were giving them away at like 29.99. sad. presentation is like 10% of a game anyway and other than that the game had bad player models, cheap humor and bad physics. for some of you the game is great but to the other millions of fans that buy madden we say the game was just ok. R.I.P. 2k5...and people thought Elvis was great too. please! get out of here!

Ah yes....just gotta love it when these "new guys" spread their thoughts and deep impressions.
What I have in bold,is exactly what you should consider doing.

This thread has remained civil,it's garbage posts like these that start the flame war crap.