Players in the game with no good card

[iWaDe]

Here's a few good players in the game without a good card?

Please list other cards that you think should be better

REMEMBER THIS IS MY PERSONAL OPINON!!!

Tyrod Taylor (should be gold)
Rashard Mendenhall (silver) should be ELITE (Better than McFadden in college)
Dennis Dixon (Should be a gold card)
Terrell Pryor (should be gold)

[BleedGreen710]

Here is the place for NCAA Ultimate team discussion:

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...te-team-forum/

[RammerJammer1674]

Quote: Originally Posted by iWaDe

Here's a few good players in the game without a good card? Rashard Mendenhall (silver) should be ELITE (Better than McFadden in college)

You're kidding right?

Mendenhall

Illinois Fighting Illini
Season	Games	Rushing					Receiving
		Att	Yrds	Avg	TD	Lg	Rec	Yrds	Avg	TD	Lg
2005	10	48	218	4.5	0	18	13	82	6.3	2	16
2006	12	78	640	8.2	5	86	12	164	13.7	1	76
2007	13	262	1681	6.4	17	79	34	318	9.4	2	55
NCAA Career Totals	35	388	2539	6.5	22	86	59	564	9.6	5	76

McFadden

		Rushing					Receiving					Passing								Kickoff Returns
Year	G	Att	Yds	Avg	TD	Lg	Rec	Yds	Avg	TD	Lg	Cmp	Att	Pct	Yds	Avg	TD	Int	Lg	No.	Yds	Avg	TD	Lg
2005	11	176	1,113	6.3	11	70	14	52	3.7	0	12	1	2	50.0%	13	6.5	0	0	13	12	348	29.0	0	81
2006	14	284	1,647	5.8	14	80	11	149	13.5	1	70	7	9	77.8%	69	7.7	3	1	28	10	262	26.2	1	92
2007	13	325	1,830	5.6	16	80	21	164	7.8	1	57	6	11	54.5%	123	11.2	4	0	42	16	316	19.8	0	33
Totals	38	785	4,590	5.8	41	80	46	365	7.9	2	70	14	22	63.6%	205	9.3	7	1	42	38	926	24.4	1	92

Source is Wikipedia


Almost the same number of games AND McFadden was splitting carries with Felix Jones.

[iWaDe]

Quote: Originally Posted by RammerJammer1674

You're kidding right? Mendenhall Illinois Fighting Illini Season Games Rushing Receiving Att Yrds Avg TD Lg Rec Yrds Avg TD Lg 2005 10 48 218 4.5 0 18 13 82 6.3 2 16 2006 12 78 640 8.2 5 86 12 164 13.7 1 76 2007 13 262 1681 6.4 17 79 34 318 9.4 2 55 NCAA Career Totals 35 388 2539 6.5 22 86 59 564 9.6 5 76 McFadden Rushing Receiving Passing Kickoff Returns Year G Att Yds Avg TD Lg Rec Yds Avg TD Lg Cmp Att Pct Yds Avg TD Int Lg No. Yds Avg TD Lg 2005 11 176 1,113 6.3 11 70 14 52 3.7 0 12 1 2 50.0% 13 6.5 0 0 13 12 348 29.0 0 81 2006 14 284 1,647 5.8 14 80 11 149 13.5 1 70 7 9 77.8% 69 7.7 3 1 28 10 262 26.2 1 92 2007 13 325 1,830 5.6 16 80 21 164 7.8 1 57 6 11 54.5% 123 11.2 4 0 42 16 316 19.8 0 33 Totals 38 785 4,590 5.8 41 80 46 365 7.9 2 70 14 22 63.6% 205 9.3 7 1 42 38 926 24.4 1 92 Source is Wikipedia Almost the same number of games AND McFadden was splitting carries with Felix Jones.

Remember man, I said this was my own personal opinion, I watched them both play, despite stats I think Mendenhall was the better player

[badman33462]

Quote: Originally Posted by RammerJammer1674

You're kidding right? Mendenhall Illinois Fighting Illini Season Games Rushing Receiving Att Yrds Avg TD Lg Rec Yrds Avg TD Lg 2005 10 48 218 4.5 0 18 13 82 6.3 2 16 2006 12 78 640 8.2 5 86 12 164 13.7 1 76 2007 13 262 1681 6.4 17 79 34 318 9.4 2 55 NCAA Career Totals 35 388 2539 6.5 22 86 59 564 9.6 5 76 McFadden Rushing Receiving Passing Kickoff Returns Year G Att Yds Avg TD Lg Rec Yds Avg TD Lg Cmp Att Pct Yds Avg TD Int Lg No. Yds Avg TD Lg 2005 11 176 1,113 6.3 11 70 14 52 3.7 0 12 1 2 50.0% 13 6.5 0 0 13 12 348 29.0 0 81 2006 14 284 1,647 5.8 14 80 11 149 13.5 1 70 7 9 77.8% 69 7.7 3 1 28 10 262 26.2 1 92 2007 13 325 1,830 5.6 16 80 21 164 7.8 1 57 6 11 54.5% 123 11.2 4 0 42 16 316 19.8 0 33 Totals 38 785 4,590 5.8 41 80 46 365 7.9 2 70 14 22 63.6% 205 9.3 7 1 42 38 926 24.4 1 92 Source is Wikipedia Almost the same number of games AND McFadden was splitting carries with Felix Jones.

Not saying I agree with the poster because I do think McFadden was the better collegiate player but even though they had similar amount of games played, McFadden had twice as many carries as Mendenhall according to what you posted. That would explain why his numbers are so much greater than Mendenhall's

[BleedGreen710]

Quote: Originally Posted by iWaDe

Remember man, I said this was my own personal opinion

Remember man, just cause its your opinion doesn't mean people aren't allowed to question it

[crowhop]

Quote: Originally Posted by iWaDe

Remember man, I said this was my own personal opinion, I watched them both play, despite stats I think Mendenhall was the better player

McFadden won the Doke Walker twice.
McFadden was a two-time All American.
McFadden won the Walter Camp Trophy.

You are not entitled to your opinion. You are entitled to your informed opinion. No one is entitled to be ignorant.

[freernnur5]

Not going to get into the Mendenhall vs. McFadden debate, but wanted to point out Mendenhall didn't ever win the Doak Walker award so he can't have an Elite card. Those are for award winners only and is a special version of the player.