NBA 2K17 Twitch Stream - 2 Full Games (Ronnie2K vs. LD2K) - Archive Available

[renni]

Quote: Originally Posted by sniapeko

I'm wondering if you actually watched the full stream or if you played basketball in real life. Because calling it "smooth and realistic" seems like a bit of a stretch to me. Scroll up a bit to read a list of just SOME of the things that should never happen in a realistic game that I saw in this stream. Granted there were A LOT of good things and improvements, but please let's not collectively pretend that suddenly this game is perfect.

if you read what he said . He clearly said it wasn't perfect

[renni]

Quote: Originally Posted by Staffan54

Yes, they have added a lot of things. For me it was most important so see if they got rid of the 2 problems that I can not accept. 1, skating/sliding still there 2, physics. The ball can still go right through a players body which makes it uninteresting to play good positional defense. An example at 2.35 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ladhW0v580 So for me it is unplayable.

don't see why it would stop you from playing positions defense . It's not that frequent . If anything they cut down on it . It's still a game . Will be a few hiccups

[extremeskins04]

Quote: Originally Posted by sniapeko

I'm wondering if you actually watched the full stream or if you played basketball in real life. Because calling it "smooth and realistic" seems like a bit of a stretch to me. Scroll up a bit to read a list of just SOME of the things that should never happen in a realistic game that I saw in this stream. Granted there were A LOT of good things and improvements, but please let's not collectively pretend that suddenly this game is perfect.

While you're entitled to your opinion, no one said the game was perfect. I also liked the fact that that one of the players was out of bounds when he got passed the ball. Now if that happens all the time, it's a problem. Players make mistakes in real life too.

[lvnba]

No love for the playbook. Haven't seen them call a play in the whole stream.

[Staffan54]

Quote: Originally Posted by renni

don't see why it would stop you from playing positions defense . It's not that frequent . If anything they cut down on it . It's still a game . Will be a few hiccups

Good point, but I think it happens too often.
I saw some videos today and it was obvious in all gamed that I watched.

Most of the other sports games got this right by now, why is it so difficult for 2K?

[The 24th Letter]

I'm glad we have a ball tangibility slider this year. I think it will open some eyes as to how wacky things can get when jacked up- assuming its the same slider Czar told us about on the developer side....I think peiple get way too caught up in the fact that clipping occurs, and not in the context its happening in.

As far as the footage- guess for me the improvements immediately jump out...I played a lot of 2K16...that defensive stickiness muddying the game out has been eliminated....while still showing the ability to defend competently...

The real test will be when I get my hands on 5 on 5 gameplay....but it looks good to me...

[renni]

Quote: Originally Posted by Staffan54

Good point, but I think it happens too often. I saw some videos today and it was obvious in all gamed that I watched. Most of the other sports games got this right by now, why is it so difficult for 2K?

different kind of game. It would seem incredible hard too 100% get rid of it. Im just okay knowing its progress. Physics seems amazing this year and you get penalized more for hitting someones body and ect. I feel like their is more reward on defense for offensive errors , but you are right. It still has more it can improve on

[RNS1hunnid]

Quote: Originally Posted by BA2929

Are you going to buy 2k17? I'm honestly wondering if you should, because the body type thing seems to really, really bother you to the point that the game won't even be fun to play. On topic: Anyone notice if the post-game highlights are playing in the stream? I can't tell if they're playing 6 min quarters again to avoid the bug this year or not as I've jumped in and out of the stream.

It's doesn't just bother him it bothers a numerous amount of people including me it's a eye sore that can easily be patched


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk