NBA 2K17 Arena Authenticity Trailer

[KGDunks]

Quote: Originally Posted by aholbert32

You are though. I'm talking about your original post not what you are saying now. You said the whole trailer was ball sounds and it wasnt. Thats hyperbole. Now if you wanted to say you didnt see anything new...you shouldve said that. It would be wrong because the Hornets chant is new and the crowd sounds are definitely new but it would support what you are saying now.

Go back and read my other posts. I'm complaining that it's such a meh trailer because there really isn't a great deal of new stuff, compared to what they originally advertised. None of the stuff they've added is going to make it feel like a proper game, like I hoped.

I've never even heard that Hornets chant in real life either.

[Goffs]

Quote: Originally Posted by KGDunks

Seriously, watch this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFu3OWjNC_w That game was made seven years ago, and was absolutely amazing for audio. The only thing 2K beats it in is having a PA announcer that tries to at least imitate the real life ones. Every possession is filled with variety and realistic sounds, just like what you get watching a Celtics game. In 2K we're limited to one or two sounds, and a lot of the time they're generic. That trailer showed nothing at all to indicate that they worked heavily on this area. Ball on floor and rim/net sounds are nice, but you're going to notice crowd noises, chants and organs a hell of a lot more.

You know why it sounds so good? It sounds natural....how the sound of the organ just started playing. 2k sounds unnatural....

Need to see some actual gameplay vids from 2k to see if they dethroned Live lol

[ClevelandinDistress]

Constructive criticism is one thing. Whining and complaining is another. It seems this forum's posters have lost the ability to differentiate between the two. Or maybe I'm just a gentleman....or getting old.

[ProfessaPackMan]

As one of the more critical folks here in regards to Atmosphere and Crowd noise, I honestly didn't see anything in that trailer to make me believe they got it right this time.

And don't even get me started on that weak *** OKC Chant, lol. Ball sounds is cool I guess, even though it's probably last on my list as far as important issues in regards to atmosphere.

This is one of those issues where a trailer won't tell us if they got it right or if it's improved from last year.

Meh.

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by KGDunks

Go back and read my other posts. I'm complaining that it's such a meh trailer because there really isn't a great deal of new stuff, compared to what they originally advertised. None of the stuff they've added is going to make it feel like a proper game, like I hoped. I've never even heard that Hornets chant in real life either.

I dont care if your opinion is its a "meh" trailer. Like I said, you dont have to overstate or ignore things to make your point. Thats my point.

I'm happy about the crowd sounds but could give a **** about the rim, horn or net sounds (honestly I dont really notice those sounds much). Neither of us know whether this is going to make it "feel like a proper game" until we play it or see videos.

You dont have to act like the trailer is nothing but ball sounds (when its not) to make your point. If anything, it takes away from your point because you are exaggerating.

[Jumpman14]

Has anybody here tweeted 2k or guys like Ronnie and LD2K that about the Knicks and Bucks courts?

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jumpman14

Has anybody here tweeted 2k or guys like Ronnie and LD2K that about the Knicks and Bucks courts?

Knicks and Bucks fans should be tweeting the hell out of them, Beluba, Czar and any other 2k dev who is on twitter. Talking about it in random threads here wont get their attention.

[Mintsa]

Quote: Originally Posted by SkillazKill

Looks like there's no Raptors fans outside the arena this year

To be honest that only happens during the playoffs. So for the sake of authenticity should only happen during playoff games.