I don't think people would complain about an expanded high school / college scenario, given they're really only 4 game seasons and people loved the experience so much. Give us the option to go one and done or the whole four years, and no one would complain
Hell when it comes to training camp/summer league, bring that back too, but just give us the option to sim. We can have the choice to improve our player through that or just skip it and jump straight to the games. I don't see how everyone can't be satisfied.
The setup for mycareer was definitely the best in 2k11, imo.