Commentator Discussion Thread

[SAVE65]

I have heard and tend to agree that the commentating is getting a bit stale after years of the same commentating crew in The Show. So I beg the question:

Who would you want to commentate in MLB The Show 11'?



My vote goes for Joe Buck. I think he has an awesome voice for sporting events and whenever I hear him I know its either a big game or the game of the week.

[DonOfDeth]

Quote: Originally Posted by SAVE65

I have heard and tend to agree that the commentating is getting a bit stale after years of the same commentating crew in The Show. So I beg the question: Who would you want to commentate in MLB The Show 11'? My vote goes for Joe Buck. I think he has an awesome voice for sporting events and whenever I hear him I know its either a big game or the game of the week.

Chip Caray... j/k

[wrigleyville33]

Quote: Originally Posted by SAVE65

I have heard and tend to agree that the commentating is getting a bit stale after years of the same commentating crew in The Show. So I beg the question: Who would you want to commentate in MLB The Show 11'? My vote goes for Joe Buck. I think he has an awesome voice for sporting events and whenever I hear him I know its either a big game or the game of the week.

Oh God no. Joe Buck is horrible. My vote is Vin Scully.

[shaunjuan2000]

Vin Sculley was in the old MLB series. Get Tom Hamilton and Rick Manning. And don't even mention Hawk Harrelson and Steve Stone. Don't want to hear, " He gone!"

[SAVE65]

Quote: Originally Posted by wrigleyville33

Oh God no. Joe Buck is horrible. My vote is Vin Scully.

Man I have heard from many people they don't like him but I think he's the best broadcaster going. I know I may take some heat for this but Vin Scully has helped me out so much when i'm having a tough time falling asleep. I know he's "old-school standing around the radio listening to a baseball game" but i'm not much into him and I am a die-hard baseball purist. After second thought he would kinda be interesting in the game. Btw I also like the guy who does the Reds games ( can't think of his name) but I remember he used to be a prime-game broadcaster. I wonder what happened to him to get "demoted"?? Chip wouldn't be bad as you mention it ( I know it was a joke but I like the idea)

[MichaelCook17]

Anyone besides Hawk. Oh and nobody from
the SF team please.

[mercenaries-fan]

The Uke!! Bob Uecker would be epic....

[VMart41]

Quote: Originally Posted by shaunjuan2000

Vin Sculley was in the old MLB series. Get Tom Hamilton and Rick Manning. And don't even mention Hawk Harrelson and Steve Stone. Don't want to hear, " He gone!"

great idea man as an indians fan i have to agree with you a hundred percent