Ok just wanted to confirm that it is a slider issue. The reason I didn't change them is because I'm lazy? lol..... Actually I didn't change them because I was just confused because it wasn't like that prepatch. I was in the process of trying to figure out what was wrong. The game was incredibly imbalanced so I wasn't sure if it was a slider issue or if 2k messed things up.
Looking at the sliders i don't know if 2k changed the default settings for allstar or something. They are actually very close to pro if you look at them. Then legend is a huge jump in power and contact for the cpu and baserunner speed.
After changing the sliders game plays very welll though. So that's the good news. I made allstar more in between pro and legend and the game plays nice.