Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Top 10 Defensive Players

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Quote: Originally Posted by Aggies7

Haha then I'll ask you the tough question. If Aldon is an 89. Where do you put Von Miller.

I put both at 89.

[sparky54017]

Quote: Originally Posted by Juce734

10. Mario Williams - OVR 97 9. Ed Reed - OVR 97 8. Troy Polamalu - OVR 97 7. Haloti Ngata - OVR 97 6. Julius Peppers - OVR 97 5. Justin Smith - OVR 98 4. Jared Allen - OVR 98 3. Patrick Willis - OVR 98 2. DeMarcus Ware - OVR 99 1. Darrelle Revis - OVR 99 I'm surprised Jared Allen is still considered a top 10 guy. I'd argue that everyone behind him on this list is better than him.

The guy had 22 sacks last year. What you talking about?

[MaddenSaints]

Quote: Originally Posted by Juce734

10. Mario Williams - OVR 97 9. Ed Reed - OVR 97 8. Troy Polamalu - OVR 97 7. Haloti Ngata - OVR 97 6. Julius Peppers - OVR 97 5. Justin Smith - OVR 98 4. Jared Allen - OVR 98 3. Patrick Willis - OVR 98 2. DeMarcus Ware - OVR 99 1. Darrelle Revis - OVR 99 I'm surprised Jared Allen is still considered a top 10 guy. I'd argue that everyone behind him on this list is better than him.

Considering I think he had the most sacks last season.

[Juce734]

Quote: Originally Posted by MaddenSaints

Considering I think he had the most sacks last season.

He did lead the league in sacks last year. Also I think he is a fantastic player. I don't think he is the best at his position right now though. As I said before 6 sacks came in his 2 games against Detroit. 3.5 sacks came in one game against Chicago. As a Lions fan I have seen a lot of him but am not afraid of going against Jared Allen.

[dlk90514]

That last pass breakup in the video with Revis was a pretty cool animation. Hopefully we will see me pass breakup attempts in actually gameplay. IMO everything is looking pretty good from that video.

[87Birdman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Aggies7

I would've said 89 or 90. Aldon Smith was step for step (or should I say sack for sack) with Von Miller. I could see them both being 89.

Problem with that was Smith was just a pass rusher and that was ll he did. He was a rotational player while Miller wasn't. Miller also had that injury to his hand which caused his play to dip, so I would say Miller is ahead of Smith so he should be in that 90 to 92 range. (not that I agree with it, but based off of where everyone else is rated that is where Miller should be.

[ghettogeeksta]

Mario Williams is not top 10.

[NYwRiter94]

Kind of hard to believe JPP doesn't make this list. Carries the Giants' defense on his back for 15 weeks and posted arguably the best defensive stats in the league last year.