Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Running Backs

[DeuceDouglas]

Quote: Originally Posted by splff3000

Well then going by that methodology, Chris Johnson should be in the top 10.

Maybe if his numbers hadn't declined so harshly over the last two years.

[OhioBuckeyes7]

top 10 HB's like in real life. with great ratings can't complain because all 10 are great and beast at what they do. Murray will be up there by season end. Go Cowboys!

[1D4ever]

Quote: Originally Posted by splff3000

Well then going by that methodology, Chris Johnson should be in the top 10.

By that logic Chris Johnson should be top 3.

Quote:

Maybe if his numbers hadn't declined so harshly over the last two years.

He hasn't declined a drop he is the same player; his numbers dropped when Vince Young left they jet put seven in the box now, if he were not still a great RB he would fell off the face of the earth ie Shaun Alexander not still put up 1000 yards you can't make Micheal Turner or even Gore better than CJ.

[SuckaRepellent]

You Raiders homers are amazing lol. He's a great player and could easily be in the top 5, but he's always hurt. He'll come in and beast 5 games and be in the bench the rest of the season.

Sent from my myTouch_4G_Slide using Tapatalk 2

[1D4ever]

Quote: Originally Posted by SuckaRepellent

You Raiders homers are amazing lol. He's a great player and could easily be in the top 5, but he's always hurt. He'll come in and beast 5 games and be in the bench the rest of the season. Sent from my myTouch_4G_Slide using Tapatalk 2

What rating out side of inj, and toughness should be affected by this. What they did they lowered his skill ratings to reflect his history of injury. This my problem they took from his awr, or his speed, or his cth to lower his overall because he had a freak foot injury that's garbage, he was a top 10 player not just RB in the league when he went down. He was a 94 in Madden 12 he played better last year there is no excuse for his skill ratings to go down.

[DeuceDouglas]

Quote: Originally Posted by 1D4ever

What rating out side of inj, and toughness should be affected by this. What they did they lowered his skill ratings to reflect his history of injury. This my problem they took from his awr, or his speed, or his cth to lower his overall because he had a freak foot injury that's garbage, he was a top 10 player not just RB in the league when he went down. He was a 94 in Madden 12 he played better last year there is no excuse for his skill ratings to go down.

If he's a top ten player with as little as he's done, then Jamaal Charles must be at least top five.

[raidertiger]

List is a joke. Turner, Jackson and Charles are not better than Darren McFadden. His speed, size, power, blocking and receiving ability should make him a lock to be in the top 10 in his position ratings wise. Wonder if they made him 80 speed to keep him out of the top 10? Or 40 strength? What a disgrace.

[raiderphantom]

Quote: Originally Posted by raidertiger

List is a joke. Turner, Jackson and Charles are not better than Darren McFadden. His speed, size, power, blocking and receiving ability should make him a lock to be in the top 10 in his position ratings wise. Wonder if they made him 80 speed to keep him out of the top 10? Or 40 strength? What a disgrace.

I think there's factors you are missing. Do I think McFadden is a top 10 runner? Well yeah, and I'm not biased. I understand that stats płay a big part in rating players and McFadden just hasn't been healrhyy enough to put up the numbers. The 2 best measures are yards after contact and missed tackles forced but they probably try to appeal to the majority of fans do they go by yards of the most recènt year, which is understandable. Not perfect, but I won't argue. But when forte's sub 1k performance lands him a 6 spot and cj can't even crack top 10 and Charles plays 2 games I wonder what they are basing this crap on. I'd be ok with McFadden as just a top 15 rb but these ratings are just wrong. P