Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

[Dj_MyTime]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

Newton wasn't even close to Luck in college. In the nfl newton had a very good rookie year... But he threw a ton of picks. Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

Where do people get this "tons of picks" stuff from. He only threw 17 in comparison to his 21 passing TD's.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/stats/...994/cam-newton

Meanwhile QB's like Philip Rivers threw 20 (87 DAC) 92 ovr http://search.espn.go.com/philip-rivers/, Eli Manning threw 16 (96 DAC) 97 ovr, http://search.espn.go.com/eli-manning/.

So when compared to "elite type QB's" he stacks up fairly similary, so why the drop in accuracy across the board when in M 12 he finished the season with an 85 DAC rating iirc. 89 SAC, 86 MAC, 75 DAC....it just doesn't make sense when you compare his season to QB's who finished with similar statistics.

Then for players who don't even have NFL snaps under their belts to be as INFLATED as they are, there's no excuse. The ONLY reason RGIII is as hyped as he is, is because Newton set a new perception of black, mobile, spread QB's, simple as that. If Newton had stunk it up RGIII would've been drafted mid-late 1st, and Weeden would've been the first QB after Luck.

[XplosiveRunna26]

Honestly it doesn't seem to matter how FAST these QB's run....the D-Line somehow outruns them and catches them anyways...smh. It's so frustrating seeing vick get hawked by a 6'6 350lb lineman behind the line of scrimmaged.

[Dj_MyTime]

Quote: Originally Posted by XplosiveRunna26

Honestly it doesn't seem to matter how FAST these QB's run....the D-Line somehow outruns them and catches them anyways...smh. It's so frustrating seeing vick get hawked by a 6'6 350lb lineman behind the line of scrimmaged.

That's what the "speed threshold" of 15 has helped eliminate. It's default is 35 points higher at 50, which means that there is less of a Madden difference between slower and faster players which is why that happens as often as it does.

[MattGarza13]

Quote: Originally Posted by XplosiveRunna26

Honestly it doesn't seem to matter how FAST these QB's run....the D-Line somehow outruns them and catches them anyways...smh. It's so frustrating seeing vick get hawked by a 6'6 350lb lineman behind the line of scrimmaged.

Speed threshold is your friend.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattGarza13

Speed threshold is your friend.

Good developers who know how to make a game that's already good should be our friend.

[KingV2k3]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jono078

Apparently 68 of the 113 Quarterbacks throw on the run equally the same. Not sure if anyone has said that yet, but that's the big thing I noticed.

Quote: Originally Posted by Jono078

I can't believe no one has commented on this one yet! I thought this would have sent the community into a rage.

Personally, this threw me into a fit of "why am I not surprised"?

[codyj123_321]

Quote: Originally Posted by 1D4ever

um no...As a Raiders fan I can't stand Tebow I think he is one of the most overrated players in sometime. Brady Quinn can't tie his shoes, Brady Quin can't tie any one shoes. Quinn is so bad I still think JaMarcus Russell is better. Tebow accomplished more in two game than Quinn has his whole career, Not that He won those game anymore's than the defense or Willis but I don't think Quinn could have managed those games good enough to win.

Once you said JaMarcus Russell was better you lost all credability. One of these days Quinn will get his chance and start lightin' D's up and i'll just sit back and laugh. Been my dude since Notre Dame and i still got my faith in him

[bucknut88]

I'm ok with Andy Dalton's overall rating. I think he's a solid quarterback (who will probably have a worse 2nd year than rookie year). But he isn't a stud...isn't elite, and probably never will be. But one thing he is, is accurate. He doesn't have a cannon but he knows where to throw the ball. Now, AJ Green really helped make him look better than I think he actually is, but his accuracy seems a little too low to me. ESPECIALLY, when you compare it to Tebow. I'm sorry if this has been said, and I'm sorry if this is obvious but Tebow's throwing accuracy is wayyyy too high.

EDIT: Sorry I failed to realize that was Deep ball accuracy. In that case, I think 81 is too high for Dalton...he doesn't throw it deep unless he throws a jump ball to AJ Green who usually makes the play because he's a beast.