Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[LordTC]

I think a lot of these ratings are based on the people around them rather than the players themselves.

Brees plays consistently at the level he typically played at, he wasn't magically better this year, but the O-Line and Defense stepped up so that turned into wins and now he's a 99 OVR ahead of Brady and Manning.

The Patriots had a lot of issues with the O-Line this year, with Brady having to hurry a lot of throws and getting sacked (typical examples include the complete inability to block in Q1 of the Ravens playoff game), so now Brady is a 95, 4 points below Brees despite being a better QB throughout the Career.

As for Asomugha vs Revis, in the regular season even though the Jets were 8-8 or whatever, in the last 6 games, he covered one of the leagues top 10 recievers man to man without help all games and in those 6 games he gave up 151 yards and no TDS (total). That's holding guys who average over 70 yds/game to an average of just over 30 and that's with no over the help top. He also had a good number of interceptions. Asomugha is without a doubt the best Zone coverage corner, but Man coverage at the level Revis provides is flat out better for a team.

[Luca Brasi]

Quote: Originally Posted by Skyboxer

Yep.. The rating isn't based on anything but stats.... 2009: 7th in QBR 4th in PCT 1 in Yards 5th in TD's 9 for most INT's based on last years stats I can see why Madden has him (Schaub) ranked there.

If thats the case Big Ben should be in the 90's. EA is obviously punishing him as well for a crime he didnt commit. Oh well..lol

[Luca Brasi]

Quote: Originally Posted by GreenReign86

steelers1, I can name another knock on Big Ben, but this is a family site, so I'm not going to go there. Can probably read in between the lines though.

Thats cool, we'll just forget the 500 yards and epic last minute game winning drive Big Ben put on your Pack's all-star secondary

[rooney8]

Quote: Originally Posted by lippe1888

Brees better than Manning?! I don't think so. Just cuz the Saints won the Super Bowl doesn't mean that Drew Brees even comes close to Manning. I absolutely hate Tom Brady but hands down he is better than Brees as well. Anyone who understands the game of football and who watches the top three QB's consistently would say Manning, Brady, the Brees. Don't get me wrong, Drew is a ridiculously good QB, but Peyton is an all-time great. Not even close.

The thing I love about Brees is his favourite receiver is the open receiver. Right now I would actually chose Brees but no doubt Manning has had the better career and will go down as possibly the best ever.

[Jono078]

Quote: Originally Posted by wheelman990

Peterson cant be a 98 with that amount of fumbles, many in big games. NOBODY in the history of the NFL has more fumbles per attempt. He got yanked in key moments in fear of a fumble. Sad. 97-99's should be reserved for Legends. Consistant 95+ players & historic HOF's

That's just flat out incorrect. If you do your research you'll find his fumbles per attempt is really similar to some of the greatest RBs and wasn't even the highest the last season.

[oneamongthefence]

Jim Leornard is comparable to John Lynch in my eyes. Nothing physically screams amazing but his play on the field makes him better than he appears. If you know what I mean.

[theant1h3ro]

Quote: Originally Posted by CaliDude916

Your comment is laughable, which is exact what I did. Willis is the best MLB in the league. Beason is good but not as good as Willis.

Bro their stats are almost identical....

[judasfavres]

Why does Nick Collins only have 89 speed still? He ran a 4.3some 40. Thats faster than Taylor Mays, Eric Berry, Percy Harvin, and the list goes on. Im not asking for 97 speed but can we give the dude 92 speed. Jesus thats fair enough.