Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)

[jbooc13]

Antonio gates and witten should have the same speed 80. jackson and westbrook should both be at 90. philip rivers should the 4th or 5th best quarterback. wheres eli ?

[jbooc13]

Antonio gates and witten should have the same speed 80. jackson and westbrook should both be at 90. philip rivers should the 4th or 5th best quarterback. wheres eli ? tomlinson should have 100 carry.out of all 16 games he didn fumble once.

[celg35]

and another note...arm strength has nothing to with how good you are as a qb...example...i remember a qb named ryan leaf, who had a great arm.......hmmmm.......whatever happened to him

[PGaither84]

I think the other problem is the concept of what does "overrated" mean? Giving Tom Brady a 97THP is overrated, giving Manning higher TAS and TAM than tom makes him "overrated." However, saying Brady and Manning are equally great QBs and amoung the best in the NFL is "overrating" Brady is ignorant.

People want to hate on a player just becasue they beat you, or some other reason. One friend of mine was talking about how he hates Brady becasue "all he does is throw short passes." Later he tells me how much he likes Chad Pennington... Yeah, he is a Steelers fan. I'm sure those AFC championship games losses and the whooping NE put on Pitt in 07 have nothing to do with him thinking Brady is overrated and hating him Colts fan watching Indy lose to SD, and NE over and over again in the post season after a great regular season year after year breads resentment [and not and honest break down of the opposition.]

The fact of the matter is that players like McNabb, Manning and other make consistant mistakes that cost their teams games just like Romo and others. Brady get lucky [eveyone knows that], but it isn't just luck that wins games for NE. In fact there was a clip I saw on ESPN where Brady said "I'd rather be lucky than good," with a smile on his face.

As a football fan I just love to watch Colts/Pats games becasue you KNOW it will be a good one no matter what becasue you are watchign the best in the league.

[steelers1]

Quote: Originally Posted by celg35

this is a ridiculous debate about tom brady....he is the best QB in football............you have to be an ignorant to see otherwise. he has all the tools and he has the most important tool....his football iQ. this argument is just nonsense......he reached his peak in 06-07???????? what, when he broke the touchdown record............name a qb who is better...............guess what you...............are wrong....................

That's your opinion. A person isn't ignorant just because they think that Peyton Manning or even Drew Brees is a better QB. I know a lot of people who believe that Brady is the product of a system. They will all say he is a great player, but they saw how Cassel did and think that if a guy who hasn't started a game since high school can put up numbers like that, it says more about the coach than the player.

[Broncos86]

This is just speculation, but seeing how Matt Cassel did last year, does anyone ever question if Brady could be as effective on another team? For me, Peyton Manning could be plugged into any offense and succeed. He will find a way to succeed. I'm not convinced Brady is the same. For the same reason I believe that Matt Cassel will be a dud in KC.

The same could be said for several ex-Broncos RBs who tried to go elsewhere, after having success in Denver, and turned in subpar performances. Yes, a player must execute, this much is true. But I've seen enough evidence to suggest that some players are a one-system kind of player.

[steelers1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Broncos86

This is just speculation, but seeing how Matt Cassel did last year, does anyone ever question if Brady could be as effective on another team? For me, Peyton Manning could be plugged into any offense and succeed. He will find a way to succeed. I'm not convinced Brady is the same. For the same reason I believe that Matt Cassel will be a dud in KC. The same could be said for several ex-Broncos RBs who tried to go elsewhere, after having success in Denver, and turned in subpar performances. Yes, a player must execute, this much is true. But I've seen enough evidence to suggest that some players are a one-system kind of player.

That's pretty much how I feel. Although I think Cassel has a chance to succeed in KC because they run a similar offense (just not as good weapons or oline).

[iBlievN5]

i cant see how you can rate brady as the best. manning is better, no doubt. judging people on team accomplishments/failures and using them to compare is asinine imo.