Aaron Rodgers deserves a 100 overall rating!

[suthrnthug]

You can call me a homer, I don't care. We as football fans have NEVER seen a QB play at this level with this kind of consistency. He is the best player in the NFL hands down. If anybody deserves the 100 rating it is Aaron Rodgers. Go Pack!

[soxnut1018]

Quote: Originally Posted by suthrnthug

You can call me a homer, I don't care. We as football fans have NEVER seen a QB play at this level with this kind of consistency. He is the best player in the NFL hands down. If anybody deserves the 100 rating it is Aaron Rodgers. Go Pack!

I don't know if we've never seen it, but Aaron Rodgers is clearly the best QB in the league. I personally don't think any player should be 100, but if anyone deserves it, it's Rodgers.

[ymcajoe]

He has thrown 4 picks. He not perfect.

[alifeincomplete]

No one deserves a 100 rating.

[moose616]

Quote: Originally Posted by alifeincomplete

No one deserves a 100 rating.

I deserve 100

[havokeff]

Yeah, the 100 rating is silly, just because there is always room for mistakes.

However, what this does address is the ratings system as a whole. Right now Arron Rodgers should be the only 99 QB, and no one else should be within 4 or 5 points.

Brady should be a 94, Drew Brees a 93, Big Ben a 88 and so on and so fourth.

Seeing someone play as Rogers is, illustrates what elite actually is and EA, and we as homers for our team that just know EA isn't paying attention to our players and didn't rate them high enough, need to recognize that.

Pain in the behind, but drop every player on the game 10 points. (I did it a couple versions ago) It gives a better feel to the game and makes the guys in the 90s truly top flight and makes the rest of the league seem more realistic.

[Obnoxious]

Didn't Madden have a 100 rated player before? Or was that 2K Football? I swear I've seen it.



And I don't think so. It's not all Aaron Rodgers y'know? The ENTIRE Offense is complete. Nobody gives them credit. Give him a Chicago Bears OL and see how he does.

[havokeff]

Quote: Originally Posted by suthrnthug

You can call me a homer, I don't care. We as football fans have NEVER seen a QB play at this level with this kind of consistency. He is the best player in the NFL hands down. If anybody deserves the 100 rating it is Aaron Rodgers. Go Pack!

P.S. Yes we have. His stats are gaudy, but the play is comparable to Brady's best recently and Montana, Young, Marino, Elway in the past.

Please keep in mind also, that Green Bay isn't exactly playing any defensive powerhouses and that all the passing stats were inflated the first half of the season as defenses caught up from the lock out.

Look at who they have played...
New Orleans
Carolina
Chicago
Denver
Atlanta
St. Louis
Minnesota
San Diego
Minnesota

Now outside of Chicago, none of those teams IIRC are even in the top half of the league, let alone a top 10 defense, so lets not start knocking HoF busts out of the way just yet.

The guy is playing amazing, don't get me wrong, but I saw first hand, Montana and Young consistently, with some Marino and Elway sprinkled in. He needs to do this consistently.