Madden NFL 17 Player Ratings - Top 5 Kickers

[TrapBasedGod]

Where the hell is justin tucker


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[manEATgod]

Quote: Originally Posted by TrapBasedGod

Where the hell is justin tucker Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Last time I checked he was still the 2nd most accurate kicker in NFL history. He missed a few more 50+ yarders than usual but would they really downgrade his accuracy that much, holding that against him?

Not that it matters for my online CFM. Will just get him to 99 kick power and accuracy in about a season. Plus his clutch trait will make him even better when it really counts.

[mrprice33]

Quote: Originally Posted by solmon

What does it take to get to 90 OVR as a kicker..? Seems odd that high, elite numbers like 97 / 93 don't put a guy there.

I agree. The kicker overalls should basically be an average of KPW and KAC, with a slight modifier for AWR or clutch traits.

[iMaverickHD]

Thought Brandon McMannus might sneak in there.

[Hova57]

They might do a punter 1 separately

Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk

[solmon]

Shooter said on twitter today they intentionally wanted to keep K/Ps out of the "elite" group of players

[Sheba2011]

Quote: Originally Posted by solmon

Shooter said on twitter today they intentionally wanted to keep K/Ps out of the "elite" group of players

I disagree with this sentiment entirely when it comes to kickers, they are some of the most elite players in the NFL. There job isn't glamorous and they don't often have highlight reel plays but the difference between an elite kicker and a good kicker in the real NFL is noticeable and will affect games. That's one huge problem with Madden in the past, there was really no such thing as a bad CPU kicker, they could all nail 55 yd game winning field goals with ease.

[Godgers12]

Quote: Originally Posted by solmon

Shooter said on twitter today they intentionally wanted to keep K/Ps out of the "elite" group of players

Well, they aren't people, so I kinda agree.


Oh and no Crosby? Makes me a saaaaaaaad panda.