Ratings don't matter in Madden 25!!

[booker21]

I notice that all QB were Robo QB. Including users.. then i found this video with some test and i can tell why Offenses are so overpowered.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fVA5D3ZBikU

[Playmakers]

I wouldn't say ratings don't matter.

I think EA just makes the game extremely offensive heavy out of the box and default sliders are geared towards arcade play style.

What I wish they do is modify their game play sliders when a user selects Sumulation mode.

I'm not saying doing that will make game perfect but atleast if they had a few competent testers work on it they could release a game out of the box that plays some form of Simulation football.

As it stands now like every other year we have to spend hours, weeks or months fiddling with sliders just to a semi realistic football game

[booker21]

Hey Playmakers. I agree with you but i'm to old to test as i used to but seeing that he (video creator) edited QB acc to 1 and he was still making perfect throws hit me. Ratings should affect more, i understand if we can't see a difference between Footwork Agilty rating but Throw accuracy is pretty simple to see. is like if i edit a Speed to 1 and still keep up with a 99 player.

[King Gro23]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

I wouldn't say ratings don't matter. I think EA just makes the game extremely offensive heavy out of the box and default sliders are geared towards arcade play style. What I wish they do is modify their game play sliders when a user selects Sumulation mode. I'm not saying doing that will make game perfect but atleast if they had a few competent testers work on it they could release a game out of the box that plays some form of Simulation football. As it stands now like every other year we have to spend hours, weeks or months fiddling with sliders just to a semi realistic football game

Did you watch the video , the title is misleading. But pass accuracy ratings do not matter in practice would have to see it happen in game. I can attest as I did a similar test. The game has a very hard time creating inaccurate/uncatchable balls


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[oneamongthefence]

I can also confirm that pass accuracy slider doesn't work either. I had it at 0 and saw little to no change.

Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

[King Gro23]

Quote: Originally Posted by oneamongthefence

I can also confirm that pass accuracy slider doesn't work either. I had it at 0 and saw little to no change. Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

I am seeing it work with CPU ACC at 10-17
QBs are within 77-45% 7 game sample.

But it only works on certain players , haven’t found out if it’s abilities, or a true ratings threshold. I plan to test some of the top passers next round.

The highest tier QB I’ve played is Brock Purdy


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Kramer5150]

Quote: Originally Posted by oneamongthefence

I can also confirm that pass accuracy slider doesn't work either. I had it at 0 and saw little to no change. Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

Throw in the HUM Run Block slider as well, currently playing on All Madden, use run block set at 0, and Najee STILL gains 5-7 yards pretty much every time.

[Playmakers]

Quote: Originally Posted by Kramer5150

Throw in the HUM Run Block slider as well, currently playing on All Madden, use run block set at 0, and Najee STILL gains 5-7 yards pretty much every time.

Crazy ain't it

EA has had years to rebuild the sliders and they choose to ignore it

BTW I like pass accuracy at 10 in my earlier testing

I also like the physics slider at 55