The M19 Unretired(ish) roster (PS4)

[RandallB21]

9/26 - V1 is up. “UNRETIRED”
Now Available on PC!

In this roster I take the latest EA roster and throw in players who aren't in the league anymore because of early retirement or some other off the field issue that isn't something heinous.

For example my first creation is one of my favorite 49ers, Patrick Willis. At age 33 Willis would be in the declining years but could probably still be a productive MLB. I try to take the last rating he had in a Madden game and degrade him accordingly. My current Willis has an OVR of about 85. Willis last was in M15 and had an OVR of 94.

Now I don't create anyone. Only guys I think still have gas left in the tank and could make an actual roster today at their current age. So don't suggest Peyton Manning please! And don't say he would be my QB2 because Manning wouldn't come back to the NFL to be QB2.

In the case of players who basically can't help but torpedo their own career (i.e. Aldon Smith) I take it in a case by case basis. Smith is someone who I am considering because his acts really only hurt himself. This is basically a fantasy "What if" roster. What if Willis never had injury problems? What if Megatron was still in the league? What if Aldon Smith never got in trouble off the field? You get the picture.

I also make players not currently retired, but also not in the NFL. Like Tim Tebow and Johnny Manziel for instance.

I do take suggestions. I will not make every suggestion, just the ones I think fit the roster.

Here's my current list of players I am including: BOLD means they are currently available

NAME - OVR
Patrick Willis - 85
Calvin Johnson Jr. - 86
Tim Tebow - 66
Johnny Manziel - 69
Colin Kaepernick - 74
Chris Borland - 83
Jahvid Best
Joe Thomas
Tony Romo
Aldon Smith
Justin Blackmon

Players I am considering:

Zach Mettenberger
Jay Cutler
Andy Katzenmoyer
Lofa Tatupu
Myron Rolle (sorry I'm a childhood FSU fan always wanted to know how his career would have been)
Greg Reid (see above)
Bobby Carpenter
Leroy Hill
Aaron Curry
Reggie Bush
LaMichael James
Rolando McClain
Percy Harvin
Jordan Cameron
Pat McAfee
Jake Locker
Jerod Mayo

Over 40 club:
Terrell Owens (ran a 4.45??)
Charles Woodson (he was so good when he retired)
Chad Johnson (just because it's OCHO)

Nephew's favorite's he always wants in:
Pat White
Steve Slaton


If you are interested in the roster let me know. Also if you have a suggestion I would be open to looking into them.

This roster will come in two forms.

UNRETIRED
UNRETIREDwLS

LS being Long Shot characters Devin Wade and Colt Cruise as free agents.

Let me know what you all think. Thanks!

[jcblayze]

Rae Carruth

[brent3419]

ooh id love to see t. o or or if chris borland to see if he becomes a star lb

Sent from my SM-J727P using Tapatalk

[jerwoods]

colin kap his rating was close to right on madden 18

[RandallB21]

Quote: Originally Posted by jcblayze

Rae Carruth

Rae-enthal?? I don’t think so. Besides isn’t he like in his 40s? I know you are joking. At least I hope you are joking.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[RandallB21]

Quote: Originally Posted by brent3419

ooh id love to see t. o or or if chris borland to see if he becomes a star lb Sent from my SM-J727P using Tapatalk

I actually looked him up to see what his OVR was at the end of M15 which I think was when he was in. He ended with an 84 OVR. I was a little shocked he was that high. I didn’t think he would be higher than 80.

As far as TO I’d definitely be willing to put him in since he does want a comeback and he “allegedly” ran a 4.45.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[RandallB21]

Quote: Originally Posted by jerwoods

colin kap his rating was close to right on madden 18

Agreed. He should be the easiest to get an accurate rating on.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[DolphinRising]

Greg Hardy?
Zach Mettenburger?

Eh, maybe I know too many fringe guys...


Um...I'm going to add some to this post in Paul Posluszny and Trent Richardson