Bama Starting QB

[dingleberryfinn]

who would be yer starter? both are 86 overalls

#10 reshirt sophomore pocket passer 6'4'' 190lbs
speed 63
awareness 84
throwing power 87
throwing accuracy 88
stamina 87
injury 85
agility 53
acceleration 69

or:

#14 sophomore pocket passer 6'2'' 214lbs
speed 80
awareness 74
throwing power 91
throwing accuracy 84
stamina 80
injury 76
agility 72
acceleration 86

am i overlooking any important attributes for a good QB?

i think i will pick Sims, i mean #14

[ttech10]

I'm not a huge offense guy but #14 looks like the winner to me. Bama has a good RB so if stamina is an issue at 80 then I'd imagine Richardson could take the ball for a down and accuracy isn't that much less. It only leaves less injury resistance (I believe that's what the INJ stat means) and 10 less awareness, but does that stat mean much when you're in control of them?

[AutoMG]

Sims would be my choice but he will probably get injured every game if you try and scramble like Denard Robinson does when I use Michigan.

[The Pizza Guy07]

I pick #10 b/c of his awareness

[dingleberryfinn]

Quote: Originally Posted by ttech10

10 less awareness, but does that stat mean much when you're in control of them?

good point, i assume it at least plays some small part though

[cap032]

Well, in the real world they are neck and neck as well. In the game however. I started my dynasty with McCaron and after the second game I switched to Simms and never looked back.

[JohnnyWadd]

After having Sims injured the first quarter of every game I've played with I decided to change my entire playbook and roll with AJ over Sims. Cannot keep Sims healthy in my dynasty. Just impossible!

[Siggy778]

Quote: Originally Posted by AutoMG

Sims would be my choice but he will probably get injured every game if you try and scramble like Denard Robinson does when I use Michigan.

I played an exhibition with Michigan and he got knocked out of the game on the first play. Then my friend was using Michigan against me and the exact same thing happened. It's like EA thinks QB's are made of plastic.