NCAA Football 12 Team Ratings and Prestige Revealed (Tradition Sports Online)

[blkrptnt819]

Quote: Originally Posted by jaredlib

I agree the process should be longer and more difficult...it should be a long term accomplishment to get that sixth star not a one year turnaround.

I very much agree with this.

[Bucs1211]

I still dont understand how Miami is better then ND when we clearly out played them is the bowl game.

[TheRealCar10ck]

wow ECU's special teams an A-...what did they see last year? We lost Dwayne to the Cowboys sooo...eh what am I talking about I'll take it. Should be a C+ or B- ha. And our D a B-? We were the worst in the NCAA last year but...eh I'll take that too ha.

[blkrptnt819]

Miami should be a 4* as should TCU. Boise is a 4.5* but do to rounding go up. Prestige Stars 1-4 should take a year. A 5* should take 2 years and a 6* should take 3 after that. So with that being said to go from a 1-6* should take 8 years and that's still generous. PSU is a 5*, Texas definitely deserves to stay a 6*. UNC should be a 3*, Fresno should be a 3*.

[coogrfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by TDenverFan

It seems like a couple of non-AQs randomly lost prestige. Fresno 3 to 2 after an 8 win year Hawaii 3 to 2 after an almost top 25 Year There may be others I didn't see Also, I noticed Wazzou is the only 1* AQ, not Duke. And Texas is still 6*?!?! Houston, a 4* last year, went 5-7 year, dropped a star. Texas, a 6*, went 5-7 and didn't drop a star. Also, thanks for posting!

For the record, UH was a 3* in NCAA 11.

[Bucs1211]

Notre Dame got a top 10 recruiting class and get bumped down to a 5 star????

[SlickRick11]

Quote: Originally Posted by jaredlib

Come on slick.....it's not that people have a problem no matter what. Be realistic man, not every school has a B+ defense. There are good schools, take Arkansas recently, who really had pretty medicocre defenses (C,C+, or B- tops) that are still good teams. I don't like how EA inflates everything year in and year out. Online Dynasty will be the same this year as last....in the fourth season every user team will have a stable of 99s and then there will be a dropoff for everybody in year 5

I completely agree with you jared.....especially on the online dynasty part.....thats exactly what'll happen by year 5 or 6 and that will hurt the long-term dynasties but I am being realistic in my opinion!! I clearly know and understand not every team has a B+ defense but I just like the equality of it and it creates less mismatches.....the ratings may not resemble exactly what they really should, but thats why its a video game..... there may not be a logical or understandable reason for it but I would just much rather them overrate teams than underrate them thats all no big deal

[The JareBear]

Yeah, I see you're point. Fair enough.

Plus they let us edit rosters to our hearts content anyway