NCAA Football 11 Video: First Look at Presentation Upgrades

[stoncold32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bigdmo9999

Wow those unrealistic replays are going to get boring. Why do they keep using the word realistic for the ESPN stuff. I want a TV broadcast, not ESPN overlays

I'm a champion of complaining about NCAA, BUT you're wrong. Matter of fact, name me one game that uses REAL TV presentation on replays. NBA 2K's replays are GREAT, but they aren't what you see in a real game, nor are the replays from The Show.

It's a videogame, and sometiems "unrealistic" stuff comes off better than if they were to do it exactly the way its done in real life.

[ConVick]

Looks like I'll be skipping those replays

[Bigdmo9999]

Quote: Originally Posted by stoncold32

I'm a champion of complaining about NCAA, BUT you're wrong. Matter of fact, name me one game that uses REAL TV presentation on replays. NBA 2K's replays are GREAT, but they aren't what you see in a real game, nor are the replays from The Show. It's a videogame, and sometiems "unrealistic" stuff comes off better than if they were to do it exactly the way its done in real life.

NCAA Basketball 10 uses REAL broadcast-like replays.

[moylan1234]

i disagree stoncold, NBA 2K10's replays are way closer to broadcast than what we're seeing here especially their player highlight packages which even end on an isolated reaction shot just like tv does

[SageInfinite]

Quote: Originally Posted by stoncold32

I'm a champion of complaining about NCAA, BUT you're wrong. Matter of fact, name me one game that uses REAL TV presentation on replays. NBA 2K's replays are GREAT, but they aren't what you see in a real game, nor are the replays from The Show. It's a videogame, and sometiems "unrealistic" stuff comes off better than if they were to do it exactly the way its done in real life.

NBA 2k10's replays are exactly what you see on TV.

[Solidice]

while I don't hate the new replay angles, I do think it's zoomed in a little too far. in the videos from thezoneblitz.com, there was a replay that was so zoomed in, you couldn't even see the ball being thrown. then it kept swapping camera angles so fast you couldn't really get a good look at what was happening.

hopefully the replay system is being tweaked here and there.

there was also a butt shot of a ref when he was signaling a first down(I think it was the same video). why? I don't want to see the ref's butt.

[Bigdmo9999]

Here stoncold, watch

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pS5rTvpTDaw

Realistic cameras are used in this whole video

[SageInfinite]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bigdmo9999

Here stoncold, watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pS5rTvpTDaw Realistic cameras are used in this whole video

While this is 1 of EA's better efforts, NBA 2k10 is still the best representation of an actual broadcast.