MVP
|
1965 MLB Hall of Fame
![](https://i.imgur.com/GkDR2IL.png)
After no inductees in 1964, Major League Baseball added four players to its Hall of Fame for the 1965 class. CF Jess Lewis was easily the marquee star of the group, getting in on the first ballot at 88.7%. The other three were below the 80% mark, but still deserving. SP Alec Ebner got in at 75.5% on his third try, getting across the line after missing the 66% mark threshold last season by 0.1%. 2B Bob Puyol and CL Nick Hedrick were the others added with the former at 71.9% and the latter at 68.4%. Four others were above the 50% mark. No players were dropped following ten years on the ballot.
![](https://i.imgur.com/cDTVczc.png)
Jess Lewis – Center Fielder – Hartford Huskies – 88.7% First Ballot
Jess Lewis was a 5’11’’, 200 pound right-handed outfielder from Whitman, Massachusetts, a small town about 20 miles south of Boston. The town is best known as the birthplace of the chocolate chip cookie. Lewis was an excellent contact hitter with great speed and solid pop in his bat. He wasn’t a prolific power hitter, but would get you a good 20-25 homers per year with a nice amount of doubles and triples as well. At retirement, he was MLB’s career leader in triples. Lewis was great at avoiding strikeouts, but only okay at drawing walks. He was very durable, starting 130+ games in all but two of his 21 professional seasons. Lewis was primarily a center fielder, although he did make occasional starts in the corners in his later years. He was considered an above average to good defender, earning three Gold Gloves (two in RF, one in LF). A team captain, Lewis was one of the most tenured and respected players of the 1940s and 1950s in MLB.
Lewis went west for college, playing at UCLA. He won the NCAA Silver Slugger in his sophomore year, making him one of the highest touted prospects. Lewis was picked second overall in the 1938 MLB Draft by Hartford and would spend his entire career with the Huskies. He was an immediate success, posting 5.1 WAR in his rookie season, finishing third in National Association Rookie of the Year voting. He’d go on to have 11 seasons of 6+ WAR and 17 seasons of a .300+ batting average.
Lewis was rarely a league leader, but incredibly reliable year in and out. He was the leader in runs in 1949 (114) and triples in 1940 (21). He won four Silver Sluggers (1942, 43, 48, 49) and three Gold Gloves (1954, 55, 56). Lewis was the NA MVP at age 30 in 1949 with 114 runs, 199 hits, a .343 average, 27 home runs, 117 RBI, and 8.4 WAR. He was third in MVP voting in 1948.
Lewis was the face of the Hartford squad in an era where they were consistently solid. His second year was the only time in his Huskies tenure that they finished below .500. Hartford made the playoffs ten times in his run, winning the World Series in 1948 and taking runner-up in 1950, while making it to the NACS in 1943, 44, 47, and 57. In 94 playoff games, Lewis had 107 hits, 59 runs, 12 doubles, 16 triples, 16 home runs, 62 RBI, and 2.7 WAR. He also played in nine editions of the World Baseball Championship for the United States team, posting 3.3 WAR, 98 hits, 64 runs, 19 home runs, and 49 RBI over 106 games. He earned five championship rings with the American team.
Lewis stayed loyal to Hartford for his entire run as a full-time starter. The only seasons he missed part of were 1953 and 1955, due to shoulder inflammation and a fractured finger. In 1954, he earned his 1500th career run. 1955 saw Lewis’s 1500th RBI and 3000th hit. In 1958, he became only the sixth player to 3500 career hits. His consistent production finally dropped in his last year at age 40 in 1959, opting to retire at season’s end. Lewis finished with 3714 hits, second only to Stan Provost’s 4133. At retirement, Lewis retired first in triples at 274 and was also fourth in runs scored all time and top ten in stolen bases. His #18 uniform was retired as a Hartford Huskies legend.
The final stats for Lewis: 3714 hits, 1918 runs, 494 doubles, 274 triples, 404 home runs, 1809 RBI, 800 walks, 963 strikeouts, 796 stolen bases, .311/.355/.499 slash, and 124.7 WAR. At retirement, he was fourth all-time in WAR among MLB batters. With these totals, it’s a bit of a travesty that Lewis ONLY got 88.7% of the vote. Either way, he’s a very well deserved first ballot selection.
![](https://i.imgur.com/UJV2IZN.png)
Alec “Lucky” Ebner – Starting Pitcher – San Antonio Oilers – 75.5% Third Ballot
Alec Ebner was a 5’10’’, 200 pound right-handed pitcher from Plainview, Texas; a small town of around 20,000 people in the northern part of the state. Ebner was known for having outstanding stuff, led by a 99-101 mph cutter. He added a great curveball, along with a decent forkball, slider, and changeup. Ebner was thought to have good movement and average to above average control. He was also viewed as a strong defensive pitcher, winning four Gold Gloves in his career. Ebner was also a team captain and strong leader, which made him an important clubhouse presence.
Ebner played college baseball for the Florida Gators and was picked 17th overall in the 1940 MLB Draft by San Antonio. He bounced between the rotation and relief in his rookie year, posting an excellent 5.2 WAR and winning his first of four straight Gold Gloves. He became a full-time starter from there onward with alright results in his first our seasons. Ebner didn’t get much help initially, as San Antonio had been a bottom rung franchise for roughly their first 40 or so seasons.
In his fifth season in 1945, Ebner suffered a torn UCL, putting him on the shelf for a year. He bounced back in 1946 for his best season to date with career bests in ERA, strikeouts, and WAR; finishing second in Pitcher of the Year voting. In 1947, he was the American Association leader in strikeouts (285) and WAR (8.5), both career bests. He again was second in Pitcher of the Year and took third in 1950, but ultimately never took the top prize. Ebner’s best production came post-injury though with eight 6+ WAR seasons in nine years.
San Antonio saw its first sustained success during this time frame as well. The Oilers made the playoffs six times from 1946-54 and made it to the AACS thrice, although they never got over the hump to get to the World Series. In 11 playoff starts, Ebner had a 5-5 record, 3.21 ERA, 71 strikeouts in 84 innings, and 2.3 WAR. He also pitched in the first three World Baseball Championships for the United States team, posting a 3.86 ERA over 28 innings with 47 strikeouts. He earned two world championship rings with the American team in 1947 and 1948.
Ebner remained loyal to San Antonio, ultimately playing 16 of his 17 professional seasons with the Oilers. In 1955 at age 35, he missed the second half of the season due to an arthritic elbow. The next summer, a torn labrum knocked him out. San Antonio let him go and he attempted a comeback at age 37 with Las Vegas in 1957. He pitched a full season for the Vipers, but with only league-average production. He did cross 3500 strikeouts with Las Vegas, becoming the 10th MLB pitcher to do so. Ebner opted to retire at the end of the year at age 37.
His final stats: 221-204 record, 3.52 ERA, 3873.2 innings, 3602 strikeouts, 282/494 quality starts, 224 complete games, FIP- of 81, and 90.9 WAR. A nice, steady career, but not the eye popping numbers or accolades of some of the other pitchers in the MLB Hall of Fame. As a result, he missed the cut on his first two attempts, albeit barely short of the 66% threshold (63.2, then 65.9%). On Ebner’s third try, he got the boost up to 75.5% to earn his spot among the hallowed greats.
![](https://i.imgur.com/EMrRHHq.png)
Bob Puyol – Second Base – Detroit Tigers – 71.9% First Ballot
Bob Puyol was a 5’10’’, 200 pound right-handed second baseman from Brooklyn, New York. Puyol was a terrific contact hitter with solid speed, making him a solid leadoff hitter. He was a master at putting the ball in play, very rarely striking out but also rarely drawing walks. Puyol’s home run power was very limited, but he had respectable gap power for getting doubles and triples. He played almost exclusively at second base and was considered an above average to good defender, once winning a Gold Glove.
Puyol attended Utah for college and returned to his home state of New York when picked by Buffalo eighth overall in the 1944 MLB Draft. His first pro season was spent in minor league Rochester, followed by his rookie year as a part-time starter in 1946. Puyol became the everyday starter at second base for the rest of his six year tenure with the Blue Sox.
Buffalo was a bottom tier team in his tenure with no playoff berths, but Puyol emerged as a star in his fourth MLB season. In 1949, he led the National Association in WAR (9.0) and hits (221), earning him second in MVP voting and his first of six Silver Sluggers. The next season, he won another Silver Slugger and his lone Gold Glove, adding a batting title (.369) and 8.1 WAR. He did this despite missing about a month to a hamstring injury. 1951 had another 8+ WAR seasons, earning third in MVP voting and his third Silver Slugger. In total with Buffalo, Puyol had 1102 hits, 463 runs, a .339 average, and 36.1 WAR. He also played in the World Baseball Championship for the American team from 1950-56, adding 97 hits and 54 runs in 103 games. Puyol earned world champ rings with the US team in 1951, 52, and 55.
With 1952 being a contract year, the Blue Sox figured they wouldn’t be able to keep the 28-year old Puyol, so they traded him to Detroit prior to the season for two prospects. He won his fourth Silver Slugger in his Tigers debut and Detroit opted to give him a big deal; eight years, $736,000. It paid off in the short term, as the Tigers snapped a playoff drought of 20 years in 1953. Detroit made it to the postseason in 1953, 54, and 55; winning the National Association title in 1953. In 23 playoff games, Puyol had 29 hits, 14 runs, and 0.6 WAR.
In his second season with the Tigers in 1954, Puyol won the NA MVP as the WARlord (9.5), along with the batting title at .367 and a career-best 232 hits. This was his sixth and final Silver Slugger season. It was also his last great season as injuries would derail later efforts. He had a recurring issue with his thumbs, suffering a torn thumb ligament thrice in his career. MCL and hamstring issues also put him out for major stretches in his 30s. Although still good when healthy, the contract became a bit of an albatross for Detroit in the later years. By his last year at age 35 in 1959, he had been relegated to a bench role and struggled, choosing to retire at year’s end. His Tigers tenure had 1262 hits, 598 runs, a .323 average, and 36.4 WAR. Puyol remained a popular player though and saw his #26 uniform retired by the Tigers.
The final stats for Puyol, 2364 hits, 1061 runs, 373 doubles, 124 triples, 127 home runs, 772 RBI, 389 stolen bases, a .330/.364/.470 slash, and 72.5 WAR. His tallies actually are lower than you’d expect and at a hard to get noticed position at second base. Still, at retirement his .330 career average was behind only John Roberts’ .342 among MLB Hall of Famers and most would agree that in his era, Puyol was the top second baseman. With that, he received the first ballot nod at 71.9%.
![](https://i.imgur.com/uDodyyy.png)
Nick Hedrick – Closer – Cleveland Cobras – 68.4% First Ballot
Nick Hedrick was a 5’11’’, 190 pound right-handed pitcher from Rogersville, Missouri; a tiny town of less than 4,000 people in the southwest part of the state. The town was once referred to as the “Raccoon Capital of the World.” Hedrick had two stellar pitches, a 98-100 mph fastball and a wicked curveball with outstanding movement. He had solid control and excellent stamina, but because he only had two pitches, his pro career was spent as a reliever. However, he was used many times as a starter in the World Baseball Championship with excellent results. Hedrick was a team captain, making him a favorite in the clubhouse and over his various MLB stops.
Hedrick was a stellar starting pitcher at the University of Tennessee, winning NCAA Pitcher of the Year as a junior and taking third for the award as a freshman. This got the attention of Cleveland, who selected Hedrick third overall in the 1944 MLB Draft. He was immediately thrown into the closer role for the Cobras, winning Reliever of the Year in 1947 and taking second in 1946. In five seasons, he had 151 saves, 1.95 ERA over 355.2 innings, 534 strikeouts, and 17.6 WAR. It is the stop Hedrick had the most saves and the team he was inducted with, although he posted the most WAR over his next stop in Jacksonville.
The struggling Cleveland franchise traded Hedrick for three players before the 1950 season to the Gators. He spent four and a half seasons with Jacksonville, winning his second Reliever of the Year award in 1950 and taking third in 1953 and 1954. While there, he posted 140 saves, a 1.92 ERA over 323.1 innings, 522 strikeouts, and 19.2 WAR. Midway through the 1954 season, the 29-year old Hedrick was traded to Oakland.
Hedrick entered free agency and signed in 1955 with Las Vegas, although he was traded in the summer and finished the year with Detroit. In 1956, he signed back with Oakland and spent his final four MLB seasons with the Owls. He had 75 saves, 2.07 ERA over 169.1 innings with 253 strikeouts and was third in Reliever of the Year voting in 1956. His use and production waned with only 25 innings in his last two seasons with Oakland. Hedrick was let go after the 1959 season and spent his final big league season at age 35 in the newly formed Oceania Baseball Association. He signed with Christchurch and posted 39 saves. He attempted an MLB comeback in 1961 but only had one minor league inning in Fort Myers, retiring at age 37.
Hedrick’s most notable moments come in the World Baseball Championship, where he was a force for the United States team from 1947-59. He made 67 appearances with 35 starts, striking out a ridiculous 685 batters over 325.2 innings with a 1.85 ERA, 26-5 record, 12 saves, and 20.3 WAR. As off 2037, the 20.3 WAR and 685 strikeouts are career bests for the WBC all-time. His 109 strikeouts in the 1957 tournament remain a record as well, which included a record 25 strikeout game against Norway. He was named the Best Pitcher that season with a 0.65 ERA over 55.1 innings and earned seven world title rings with the Americans.
Counting the OBA season, Hedrick had a career of 428 saves, 54.8 WAR, 1.88 ERA, and 1518 strikeouts. In the MLB alone, he had 389 saves and 414 shutdowns, 1.86 ERA, 930.2 innings, 1434 strikeouts, and 52.8 WAR. The WAR tally was the most among relievers at retirement and would only get passed by Carson Hanford in later years. His save tally was fourth all-time at retirement. Despite this, MLB Hall of Fame voters are tough to sway when it comes to relievers. Hedrick only got in barely at 68.4%, but still got to say he was a first ballot selection.
|