Home
Feature Article
MLB 09: The Show - The System Seller?

Can you believe that it is already March? March Madness is right around the corner, the NBA and NHL playoff chases are beginning to intensify, and the chill of winter will (hopefully) subside soon and give way to the warmth of spring.

And by now, many gamers are already playing the newest round of baseball titles for 2009, MLB 09: The Show and MLB 2K9 -- a sign that MLB Opening Day is on the horizon.

But because of the unfortunate gulf of quality between MLB 2K and The Show, there are probably many baseball fans, sports gamers and Xbox 360 owners presently battling with that ultimate question -- one that I have also been admittedly battling with. And that question is, "should I really spend hundreds of dollars on a PS3 just for one game?"

 


Is MLB 09: The Show worth a purchase of a new system?

True Marks of Greatness

Look, I am certainly no mathematician or rocket scientist, but I do understand what a killer app is and what elements it contains. For those who are not familiar with the term, a killer application or "killer app" is a computing term usually used to describe a unique feature or a piece of software -- or in this case a video game -- that causes people to buy the hardware it runs on just to own/play/experience it. These are typically your Marios, GTAs, Halos or Final Fantasys.

But how does The Show fit into that group? Well, it does and it does not

For one, I am not totally delirious, and I am not suggesting that The Show will ever approach the sales of a Mario game or something like a Gears of War. Nevertheless, The Show still possesses some unique attributes that ensure its place as a killer app for many sports fans.

The attributes I am hinting at are exclusivity and quality.

Seems simple, right? Well, it is. And if you go through any list of killer apps over the years, you will probably find that almost all of those titles possess those same traits. Exclusivity alone is why companies like EA, Sony and Microsoft are willing to pay millions to arrange for exclusive rights to an existing series, popular commodity, and yes, even a sports league or association. But the second portion, quality, well, that part is a bit harder to nail. And that is why The Show is in the position it is in at the moment.

Sony’s Real Killer App?

So how does The Show fit into those two categories? Well, the first, exclusivity, speaks for itself. As a game developed by SCE, The Show is essentially a Sony product and has been since its days on the PSone. In the past, though, baseball games were considerably more abundant, and fans had many more choices. At one point, there were a huge number of games out there to buy and play: Triple Play, All-Star Baseball, High Heat Baseball, Inside Pitch, the various 2K releases and probably a host of others I am forgetting.

But now, thanks to a marketplace growing ever more competitive and expensive, and the various licensing battles between 2K and EA, we are now left with two main baseball titles -- or three if you count Power Pros -- to fight it out for sandbox supremacy. And, unfortunately, for a few years now it has been a rather one-sided battle.

Now that is not to say I am totally discounting 2K’s offerings, but it is tough to succeed when you are competing against such stiff competition -- just ask the Blue Jays how they feel about being in the AL East.

Anyway, that also leads me to my next criterion, quality. And boy, does The Show excel in that department. For five years now, we have watched this series grow and blossom, and now it is one of the best sports series available today. Truthfully, I have been enjoying the series since before The Show even became a part of the name. (Maybe one day I will tell you all the story of how I literally trudged through a rough Toronto winter storm to pick up a PSP copy of MLB 2005.)

Simply put, it is a great series that has shown others how to properly manage and develop an exclusive franchise. In addition, The Show’s PS2 and PSP offerings still manage to attract loads of admirers to this day. It is important not to overlook that fact because those games are an integral part of the franchise’s overall success: If you put out a quality product for multiple years, you generate a loyal fan base. In other words, those players that get hooked on the PS2 and PSP versions will inevitably get the itch to play the "best" version of the game on the PS3.

So enter 2007, when the series made the leap to the PS3. This was the pivotal point when things really took off for the series. With the addition of truly realistic graphics, retention of the solid-as-a-rock gameplay, and a load of other fantastic and innovative features, The Show on the PS3 instantly became a game of real significance, and it instantly became a benchmark for sports gaming. Well, that all sounds pretty awesome, right?

Great game, I would sure love to play it. But to enjoy any of it, of course I would need a PS3 first.


So really, is MLB 09: The Show worth buying a PS3 for?

What’s Past Is Past

In a way, The Show is really the last of a dying breed. Real exclusivity has become somewhat of a rarity these days. Many third-party titles, including some former rock-solid exclusives like Final Fantasy, have become available on a multitude of platforms these days.

Even so, looking back at gaming history as a whole, when have sports games ever been a real killer app on par with the likes of Zelda, MGS or Halo? Looking back on it, Nintendo’s first-party sports offerings, which have usually been pretty Mario-centric, have been mostly good quality titles, but they have hardly met the hardcore sim standards that many seek.

On the other hand, Microsoft’s games on the Xbox were perfectly suited for the hardcore crowd, but I do not believe many people solely bought an Xbox just for Links, NBA Inside Drive, Top Spin, NFL Fever or NHL Rivals -- yet I admit that I bought my old Xbox used just to play Inside Drive 2003. And before The Show arrived, Sony’s mostly 989-developed offerings (NFL GameDay and NBA Shootout) were average to mediocre at best, hardly system sellers.

I suppose the 2K games on the Dreamcast were nice exclusives as NFL/NBA 2K were such a step above what else was available at the time. But on the other hand, the Dreamcast's total lack of EA games was seen as a boon for the Playstation and has been pointed to as one of the causes for the premature death of Sega’s last console.

Of course through the course of all this, I have been skipping over the best-selling sports app of all in Madden. It obviously has got the exclusivity portion figured out -- in a different sense of course -- and the series has been a quality product at times I suppose.

But Madden is on a different plane of existence than The Show. I mean, Madden is available on every platform imaginable and it is really the only football game in town at the moment. But even then, I still do not imagine that many gamers have bought their current-gen console of choice just to sample the latest flavor of Madden.

At the very least, Madden is really not comparable to what is going on with The Show right now. And with The Show in such a unique position at the moment, there is really only one last question left to ask.

Is It Worth It?

Kratos? Snake? Sackboy? Turismo? Blu-ray? 100-plus gigs of hard drive space? Well, I mean no offense, but like Shania Twain once sang, "that don't impress me much." Plus, as someone who already owns a 360 and Wii, it makes it an even tougher decision.

But, man, watching those gameplay videos makes me want to still run out and pick up the game. The Show is asking me to dig in a bit deeper so I can digitally dig into the box with Braun, Hanley or J-Ham. It is looking to me to just pitch in a few crisp hundreds so I can throw that 100-plus mph fastball with Zumaya.

There is no doubt that it is a difficult choice to make, but personally, I admit that if my laptop had not died on me recently, I would have made the leap. But alas, I suppose it just was not meant to be, at least not this year anyway.

And in the end, I suppose it will be a personal choice everyone has to make. But the fact that many people are even considering a sports game as a system seller during these hard times simply speaks volumes about The Show's quality.

So, sure, it is no Halo or Zelda, and Mark Teixeira or Miguel Cabrera may not be any real competition for Marcus Fenix or Niko Bellic. In the end, though, MLB 09: The Show has shown me that in its own unique way, it is indeed a killer app.


MLB '09: The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 1 Windu @ 03/10/09 02:58 PM
It was a system seller for me. Bought a PS3 for MLB 08. Still the only two games I have for the system. I'm sure if the 2k series was any good I would never have bought a PS3.
 
# 2 demboys6 @ 03/10/09 03:00 PM
I was one of these people. I have had my 360 since the first night it came out. I am a huge baseball fan so went and picked up 2k9. Could not make it through one game without it freezing on me. I looked at all the reviews for both 2k9 and The Show. Per the reviews there didn't seem to be much comparison as The Show seemed to be blowing the other out of the water. I just got home with my PS3 and The Show. So yeah, I am sure I am not the only one who had debated the switch because of this game. 2k9 freezing was the final straw for me.
 
# 3 irrelevant @ 03/10/09 03:16 PM
Greetings! First post after lurking for quite some time (and subsequently registering).

I purchased my PS3 the day before The Show '09 came out. I do not regret it one bit. I still love my 360 and will use it for a number of gaming needs (after the baseball season is over - LOL). I played the 2K series religiously and I was really excited about 2K9 - that is, until I watched the Angels vs. Yankess video for The Show. OMG. Sold. Converted. Done. Bow down.

I LOVE this game. I get really frustrated because I nearly can't hit to save my life and my pitching is spotty, but at the same time I love the the learning curve and the similarities to actually playing baseball. Never before have I faced this type of challenge in a sports game; and nothing feels better than getting that K or tearing the cover off the ball!

SCEA, I applaud your incredible work. OS peeps, this site rules. The Show, system seller... hands down.
 
# 4 moose1619 @ 03/10/09 03:37 PM
I am not a baseball purist, but I have played baseball games all my life up till about 2 years ago. I can remember atari baseball, nes baseball, rbi, bases loaded(one of my personal favorites), World Series on the Sega, Sony's MLB games of the late 90's, ASB in the early 2000's, High Heat 04, MVP 05, and the last I bought was MLB 2006. Over the last few years no game has made me say man I have to have that baseball game. I came close last year to getting the show but didn't. I didn't hesitate this year and I am not disappointed.

I don't know how to describe it, maybe it is the crack of the bat, the feeling of a well turned double play, or frustrations of losing a perfect game with two outs to go in the ninth. These are my feelings of baseball and my past history with baseball games. The fun factor in the field, the bright sunshine of a day game, and the feeling of a 99mph fastball to end the game. To me The Show has captured these elements and more. Obviously the graphics and sound are top notch and the animations are fluid. Does the game have glithces yes, but what game doesn't.

The simple truth is, if you are a baseball purist or just a simple man you must own a PS3 and you must own MLB 09: The Show.
 
# 5 dave_sz @ 03/10/09 03:40 PM
Its only a system seller for baseball fans, like gran turismo is a system seller for racing fans and metal gear is a system seller for metal gear fans. For a casual gamer this game has no chance.
 
# 6 hq3000 @ 03/10/09 03:45 PM
It was a system seller for me. I went to Gamestop with the sole intention of picking up a PS3 and 07. Spent mad money to get 2 controllers and an HDMI cable. This has been the only time I bought a system just for one game. Totally worth it because now I can watch The Dark Knight beautiful HD quality. So yeah, totally worth it.
 
# 7 NAFBUC @ 03/10/09 04:19 PM
I was always a PC baseball player. I never thought I would be a console gamer. I was over at a friends and he was playing The Show 07 which tweaked my interest. Just before the release of The Show 08, I bought my PS3. I am now in baseball heaven.
 
# 8 BuccaneerFan @ 03/10/09 04:28 PM
MLB '08 The Show and MLB '09 The Show are the only games I own for PS3. So yes, it was a system seller for me. Although the Blu-Ray player was a big factor too.
 
# 9 rudyjuly2 @ 03/10/09 04:28 PM
It can be a system seller for the hardcore baseball fan with a nice wallet. It can certainly be a system seller for those that haven't made the leap to next gen yet and like baseball. For exclusive sports gaming fans (dying breed), the PS3 offers every choice + the Show.
 
# 10 nomarhits400 @ 03/10/09 04:29 PM
Count me in as well- new PS3 last week for this game- probably wouldn't have done it without the PS3 Card offer for $300 off- but even so, I only considered because of The Show.
 
# 11 jerk @ 03/10/09 04:42 PM
It was a system seller for me! Didn't really care for any other games on the ps3 other than the show!
 
# 12 Bumble14 @ 03/10/09 05:01 PM
I bought a PS3 last year for The Show 08. A year later I still only own 2 PS3 games- The Show 09 and Killzone 2.

As a hardcore gamer, my 360 is my console of choice. As a hardcore baseball fan, my PS3 was worth every penny extra just to play The Show.
 
# 13 EnigmaNemesis @ 03/10/09 05:32 PM
If you are a hardcore sports gamer, and a fan of baseball, then HECK YES this is a system seller.

'08 is what got me to purchase a PS3 last year (was holding off on more price drops but could not wait any longer). And '09 even more so.

It was one of the best gaming decisions I have made in a long time. The PS3 has come a long way with their firmware updates, and is one heck of a multi-media device. And Blu-Ray is stellar.

Not to mention it has some darn awesome first party games as well. As other mentioned already, a darn fine list.

Phenomenal machine, and worth every penny. ESPECIALLY for the best baseball game ever created (IMO).
 
# 14 demboys6 @ 03/10/09 05:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rudyjuly2
For exclusive sports gaming fans (dying breed), the PS3 offers every choice + the Show.
That was my thought process. I am exclusively a sports gaming fan, that is almost all I buy. I live on these boards just obviously never post. I can get every sports title I want for the PS3.
 
# 15 JMD @ 03/10/09 06:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Windu
It was a system seller for me. Bought a PS3 for MLB 08. Still the only two games I have for the system. I'm sure if the 2k series was any good I would never have bought a PS3.
Same here. My console of choice is the 360, but I got a PS3 because MLB 2k8 was so bad, I wanted the Show 08.
 
# 16 Zorb @ 03/10/09 06:48 PM
MLB 08 sold me a PS3.
 
# 17 sgthalka @ 03/10/09 06:58 PM
I can't believe he wrote that entire article and didn't even buy the system or play the game.
 
# 18 gbx34 @ 03/10/09 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jerseyjay14
If it isnt a "system Seller" it is certainly a huge contributor to the cause giving sony another excellent exclusive to go along with blu-ray.

the 360 is a great machine, with some ncie exclusives, but recently, sony has come out with some nice exclusives of its own:

The show
Hot shots golf
uncharted
Killzone 2
Warhawk
Little Big Planet
Resistance
Gran Tourismo 5
God of War 3

and those are just the SCEA games... meaning they will always be exclusives(unlike say final fantasy or bioshock)
MGS4

It was talked about coming to 360, but hasn't yet.
 
# 19 pvigg001 @ 03/10/09 07:34 PM
No it's far from a system seller.
 
# 20 Bigtonyclark @ 03/10/09 07:53 PM
It's a system seller for me. Hopefully I'll have it in my greedy little hands by this Saturday.
 

« Previous1234Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.